TW3 is a great game, and one that will probably be the winner here (as in the other categories). It has the widest appeal. It probably also has the largest fanbase as it is spread across all the platforms, and was released earlier than many of the other games on the list.
Still, Bloodborne's unique atmosphere, clever level/world design and "don't-break-your-controller-just-calm-down-improve-your-skill-and-keep-pushing-to-destroy-that-boss" approach sure have my futile vote locked in.
bjvill's comments