It's been some time now since I bought my Wii and I would like to make some considerations about my experience with the console so far. Although I can recognize that these are limited 'single-player-window' point of views I think they can hopefully raise a question or two.
List of games played (with completion status)
Super Mario Galaxy (100%)
Wario Land: Shake It! (100%)
de Blob (Completed and going for 100%)
Endless Ocean (Completed and going for 100%)
Pokemon Battle Revolution (Completed and still playing)
Star Wars: The Force Unleashed (Completed)
Star Wars - The Clone Wars: Light Saber Duels (Completed)
Mario Party 8 (Completed)
Okami (Now playing)
Elebits (Now playing)
Wii Sports (Can't be completed and NOT going for 100%)
Lego Batman (Abandoned)
Sonic and the Secret Rings (Abandoned)
Mario & Sonic at the Olympic Games (Trying it just now)
The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess (Trying it just now)
Best games played
Super Mario Galaxy: Obvious choice... But I can't say it's a perfect game with its camera issues and a little too much recycled action (I'll review it someday).
de Blob: Artistically impressive - mixing color and sound in such a beautiful way is a respectable achievement.
Okami: Once you manage to tame the drawing controls it's an astounding piece of art.
Surprisingly good games
Endless Ocean: Maybe this is not even a game but it's easy to spend hours in it.
Star Wars: The Force Unleashed: The motion controls felt unexpectedly fluent and enjoyable to me – especially in the "finish him" boss sequences.
Most disappointing games
Lego Batman: That game is a complete mess. I won't detail it that much but I can say that the gameplay elements were all scattered randomly into the game. It's far from the pleasant experience Lego Star Wars games gave me before.
Sonic and the Secret Rings: oversensitive motion controls and a terrible choice regarding the way you jump made this one a letdown to me.
Complaints
I must say my overall experience with the Wii until now was... Fair. Maybe my expectation bar was set too high but here are some major complaints that can support my point of view in some way.
Gimmicks: there's a fair amount of games in my list that were (slightly or badly) harmed by a bad execution of/unnecessary use of motion controls: Super Mario Galaxy (the ray races), Wario Land (the subwarine stages), Okami (the pointer is harder to use than an analog stick), Elebits (opening doors and faucets), Sonic and the Secret Rings (tilting the remote sideways to steer)... I hate that OBLIGATION of putting all the hardware features into a game – sometimes even at the expense of the gameplay or the experience.
Lack of polish: Some of those games should be a must have if the developers had put a little more effort into polishing them. Endless Ocean (bad human models and movement, a 'new' sign in the items/fishes you found recently), Pokemon Battle Revolution (a little more options with your starting team), Star Wars: The Force Unleashed (better access to the extras and an easier way to start a 'New Game +') and so on. That really pisses me of because they're accomplishing the harder goals and letting the games down on account of some lack of care with details.
Final considerations
As said above my experience with the Wii has been only fair. I didn't run after any specific game to play, I just let the games surrounding me to enter my console and that allowed me to have a wider sight of its capabilities and potential. It's kinda weird to see that some of my favorite games in the system are ports (Okami, de Blob). I'll look for games that really interest me and see if they can change my mind, but until now I must say I'm far happier with my DS and I consider it a more solid gaming platform. And last but not least, being a Nintendista as I am is hard for me to say that games like Demon's Souls make me want to trade my Wii for a PS3...
Your thoughts, comments, recommendations?
Log in to comment