@RustedTruck650: DS game end game bosses were also an issue: Bed of Chaos and 4 kings anyone???

@iloveyourface: thats the problem here: the critical analysis doesn't stand up - I'm a Gen Xer BTW

@LucasLinoMota: nothing wrong with a poor score. Another site gave it a 7 BUT their rating was justified much more clearly than here - thats the issue with this review the rating does not reflect the cons listed.

@gunther_fenz: except the cons dont justify the poor score.

I dont mind a poor review. And lets face it compared to DS1 and DS2 this is a poor review - however the review does not justify the rating of 8. The TWO cons listed are similar cons to DS1. On top of that DS1 had frame rate issues and the PC version barely worked. If this is about lack of innovation (as other poor reviews have pointed out) then fair enough, but this review does not make mention of that, so why the poor score?? Is it because it ends on a whimper not a bang? Then list that in the cons! This review does not make logical sense....unless there is something about the game that the reviewer is not mentioning which merits such a low score......