I like IGN's review of this game better than GS. This is probably the last time I take GS reviews seriously, especially when this particular reviewer gives a 2 hour, overpriced game like "Gone Home" a 9.5, and a masterpiece like GTA V gets something lower. I usually came for the badges and the pros and cons for the games, but now I see a lot of personal bias from the reviewers, and I rarely agree with any of their reviews anymore.

@shadowhunter0 just one step above Sony fanboys.

@LOKIIGODX41 I'll be honest, the game is played for merely enjoyment, all the malicious deeds committed in this game do not necessarily carry over to real life. I'd like to think I'm a good person, I don't commit crimes and have a clean criminal record. But I've been playing this game series for over 7 years now. It's all about the guilty pleasure, but it doesn't mean you're actually committing crimes by sitting on front of a TV and playing this game. Just like you don't become a mass murderer/cannibal by watching Hannibal Lecter films. See what I'm saying?

I wonder how all the dumb b****es will feel who voted for Elder scrolls when they play GTA V and realize they made the dumbest choice for the best games series of the decade poll.

For some reason, I can't get past the licensing issues. I had fun playing both, but I hate the commentaries not being varied enough to use real name or address real stadiums (like the Santiago Bernabeu in FIFA 13 gets talked about).

@Quarkzquarkz It is NOT worth the whole $20, there are games with far better production values and attention to detail. It has virtually no replay value, and even though the story is emotional and the sense of exploration is exciting at first, it's just a simple detective game where you're interacting with your surroundings and the people who live there. At best it is worth half that price, for only 2 hours of entertainment. That's rating number is incredibly deceptive.

If this game is a 9.5, then L.A. Noire and Heavy Rain should be 10s. Caroline, why you rated this game 9.5 is questionable, and the bias is kinda obvious if one realizes the plot and theme of the story.

I played this game, and I honestly don't find what's so fascinating about it. I also find it intriguing and obvious as to why this makes such an emotional connection to some rather than others. It takes a pretty mature mind to take it all in, but I believe Caroline definitely overrated this game, better games with much more attention to detail have been rated 8.5 or less, while this 2 hr game gets a 9.5 because someone doesn't know the criteria that makes a game valuable. Is it a 9.5? ABSOLUTELY NOT! Is it a good game, definitely. I'm disappointed at GS.

Buy the console you want and shut the F*** up! Nobody is forcing you to buy a PS4 if you're a microsoft fan or a Xbox One if you're a sony fan. Grow up, and quit trying to "junk measure" with the other group of fanboys.

And you'll never convince a fanboy to buy otherwise.

What I don't understand is, what the heck does your choice of console have anything to do with what others pick? PS4 and Xbox One fanboys are worse than religious zealots these days.