I'd say MGS5 is a much better game than The Witcher 3, but I'm happy with TW3 winning GOTY. Those are my top 2 of the year.

@wookiegr: This is just Amazon. Halo already outsold Bloodborne and Splatoon, though it's only better than one.

EDIT: I just noticed it's not based on sales. LOL at Fallout or Mario Maker being above MGS. What a joke.

The jokes write themselves!

@abcde: Switch MGS and Witcher and you're golden

Until Dawn and Dying Light have no business being above Xenoblade.

208 hours of Halo 5. Holy shit.

I made use of this service already: I bought Rogue Galaxy (and FF7, but that's a "remaster"). I have the physical copy as well, but I wanted it in 1080p, 60FPS, and with trophies.

It's 1080p. It's got trophies. It's certainly not 60 FPS. Not sure why they advertised 60 FPS when the game is still 30, but there it is.

For a game like RG, $15 is a good price. I bought it new for $50 years and years ago, but that's the type of game that doesn't go down in price much. Used, on Amazon, it's at least $20.

For something like Dark Cloud, GTA3, Vice City, or Twisted Metal Black? Sony is overcharging...big time.
Dark Cloud can be had on Amazon for $11.
GTA3? $6 brand new. Some people are selling it for less than a dollar. Less than a dollar.
Vice City? $8 brand new, $4 used.
TM Black? $10 shrink-wrapped, 57 cents used.

In fact, I'd say that Rogue Galaxy is the only game currently that's worth what Sony is charging. For the others? You're paying for:
>a bump in resolution
>trophies
>convenience

Of the two games I bought, neither are the promised 60 FPS. Which is the biggest thing I wanted...but oh well.

@chaosbrigade: Reviewers gave Undertale 9s and 10s. They have the odd standards.

I bought two copies because I saw they were making only one print. I opened one and plan to keep the other sealed for a bit as a collector's item.

It's not even that bad. Not sure why it's getting low scores. It's a solid 6.

It's Kamiya. It's guaranteed to be awesome.