just a couple things to tc:

1: I see how you could think that, I mean in a game like wii boxing I'll admit that the punches dont do exactly what your motions do.  That is intentional I think, or else the game would succomb to a motion sensing version of button mashing.  You have to learn to control your movements, if you go too jerky and erratic then the game will punish you.  I noticed  this when my brother, who just got to try the wii, would suck on a lot of games thinking he was doing them right when he wasnt.

GunSmith1_basic

Yeah, I pretty much totally disagree with the title of this thread.

 Why? I'm on my third game of Zelda:TP and I'm still loving it. It doesn't feel gimicky at all. (neither do all of my other Wii games)

Am I a fanboy? No. I didn't even finish Z:OoT, and the only other Zelda I played was the gameboy one...for about 5 hours total.

Maelkav

I think the Wii can be saved by Nintendo themselves by showing everyone else how good the controls can be for a game. Super Mario Galaxy looks perfect with the wiimote. Metroid Prime 3 (which is made by Retro-Studios, not Nintendo, but they are probably cooperating) also looks very good. I don't think third party developers have spend a lot of time in making their games good, so I guess that's where the problem is. I do not doubt that games will be a lot better for the Wii in the future.Litchie