I was asked to watch this video about reclaiming "geek" on my G+. Â Since I don't work for Destructoid, my thoughts on the video are as follows.
Â
https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=WUU4L0QzA0E
Â
Watched the video. This video reminded me of Moviebob complaining about the Scream movies because they revealed that comprehensive movie trivia knowledge does not make you unique.
You remember the whole "Hardcore/Casual" gamer thing which led to places like The Escapist and Gamespot turning up their nose at "casuals"Â and led to statements like "The Wii is lame."?
It's something like that. Using gamers as an example, the gamer mantra for years was the long-suffering martyr question of "How can we make the public like our games?" Then Nintendo ruined it by turning the question into "How can we make games that the public likes?" All of a sudden, being a gamer became something that everyone was. Gamers achieved the public acceptance that they kept hoping for only to find that being a gamer was no longer something that made them unique. Thus, they started throwing up barriers such as "hardcore/casual" to try to preserve their former uniqueness.
It's the same sentiment here and Felicia Day (who has a stake in defining "Geek" as an outsider and thusly unique with a martyr complex) is playing to it. If geek becomes defined as anyone with a geeky interest, then there is no uniqueness. There is no martyr complex. Your interests no longer define you as unique.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A8I9pYCl9AQ
I embrace this happening. Most of the people who want to throw up these barriers are fundamentally lazy. Rather than developing a rich and unique personality, they want to take the lazy way out and say "My hobby makes me a unique butterfly in an underground mindset."
Screw that.Â
Being an outsider or a rebel sometimes means taking up the axe for an unpopular cause (admitting that gamers had a big hand in forming EA into what they are now). It sometimes means painful self-introspection and admitting that an opposite number (see my post on Moviebob and Kickstopper) has a good point worthy of discussion/acceptance. Instead of just being a "super" because of the social group you belong to or your interests, it requires truly marching to the beat of your own drum. Defining subsets such as geek is just someone's way of saying "I'm too lazy and the path is too hard to truly develop a unique personality."
Log in to comment