@aj87: Then by your logic, ALL BC 360 games are in the Xbox One library, so the REAL metacritic average for the Xbox One has to include ALL those BC games.
@domiddian: It is SO FKIN OBVIOUS that you are a fanboy, are you kidding me? Either that or you are stupid. The PS4's higher average comes from remaking high-scoring games. Remake the rest of the Gears games, remake KOTOR, the Fable games and Project Gotham Racing...if XBOX remade games like SOny does, then XBOX would have the higher average. Including all the remakes is comparing apples to oranges
@domiddian: You really can't understand why remakes don't count?? OK, consider this, assume no new IPs will be created anymore, in fact, NO NEW GAMES AT ALL. Just remakes...how long would you continue to game?? One generation, if that? If there is nothing new, there is nothing to play and with nothing to play the console becomes useless. It's not because the game is also on a PS3, remakes don't count because they don't bring anything new.
As for the Halo and Gears remakes, first of all, these are the only franchises where a remake DOES count because these games are that good. Secondly, $60 for the Master Chief Collection is a tremendous tremendous tremendous deal.
vatorus' comments