Gamespot's RPG Winner is Demon's Souls ,Are you Agree ?

Come on more then 50% of people Vote for Dragon Age Origins , So don't tell me i'm upset because it's PS3 exclusive !

They are very different games and i think Dragon Age which I played and loved is more mainstream then Demon's Souls. Less people played Demon's Souls so less people voted for it, Gamespot played both and decided 1 was better then the other. I have not played Demon's souls yet but now i think i may have to.

They are very different games and i think Dragon Age which I played and loved is more mainstream then Demon's Souls. Less people played Demon's Souls so less people voted for it, Gamespot played both and decided 1 was better then the other. I have not played Demon's souls yet but now i think i may have to.

Justincor

If you play it, you'll know why it won. ;)

i feel asleep

Yes I am agree as well.

I am agree most definetely.

me agree also

Clear and loudly: NO!

Clear and loudly: NO!

DoomZaW

[QUOTE="DoomZaW"]

Clear and loudly: NO!

Sean2moore

^^ Spoken for the truth.

Demon's Souls did something new to the RPG genre, which is probably the reason why it won RPGoTY. There's isn't really another game like Demon's Souls, and it does a great job at what it does.

Demon's Souls is the best game this year, and easily the best RPG. I wonder if the people who hate it have even played it.uyiop0t

I agree, lot of these naysayers either never played or don't have patience to play challenging games. No RPG lately has been so much brutally challenging, fun and rewarding in many years. Demons Souls for GOTY!

[QUOTE="uyiop0t"]Demon's Souls is the best game this year, and easily the best RPG. I wonder if the people who hate it have even played it.fun-da-mental

I agree, lot of these naysayers either never played or don't have patience to play challenging games. No RPG lately has been so much brutally challenging, fun and rewarding in many years. Demons Souls for GOTY!

I wish everyone who hasn't played it could get a chance to play it and just see what it's really like, because there is no game to even compare it to. In almost every way, it does its own thing.

Dragon Age 9.5 Demon's Soul 9.0

Greg & jeff i miss you guys ;(

i havent finish DS yet (hard as hell) and its a good hack&slash game

and you can left notes for others players just like Farmville but better than DA no way jose.

I am Agreed to the i am agree, agreeingly.

[QUOTE="DoomZaW"]

Clear and loudly: NO!

Sean2moore

The only thing innovative it did was the message system, and that doesn't automatically = RPGOTY, neither does a hard difficulty, and when you look past those two things, you find a shallow story, ugly graphics, craptacular voice acting, and a lot of gameplay design flaws. And for the record, yes i played it, and i did also play DA:O and DA:O was superior to DS in every possible way

[QUOTE="Sean2moore"][QUOTE="DoomZaW"]

Clear and loudly: NO!

DoomZaW

The only thing innovative it did was the message system, and that doesn't automatically = RPGOTY, neither does a hard difficulty, and when you look past those two things, you find a shallow story, ugly graphics, craptacular voice acting, and a lot of gameplay design flaws. And for the record, yes i played it, and i did also play DA:O and DA:O was superior to DS in every possible way

Is someone mixing up Opinion with Fact again? Tsk tsk tsk.

[QUOTE="Sean2moore"][QUOTE="DoomZaW"]

Clear and loudly: NO!

DoomZaW

The only thing innovative it did was the message system, and that doesn't automatically = RPGOTY, neither does a hard difficulty, and when you look past those two things, you find a shallow story, ugly graphics, craptacular voice acting, and a lot of gameplay design flaws. And for the record, yes i played it, and i did also play DA:O and DA:O was superior to DS in every possible way

I don't have either, but I'm getting Dragon Age: Origins. I was planning on getting Demon's Souls until I heard it was very hard, and you die a lot? Is this true? Maybe I'll try a demo if there is one, but still, I'm not a fan of the very hard difficulty.

I haven't played either so neither deserve it! :PStevo_the_gamer

You Know guys i like Dragon Age because of the dialogs and optional ways to do game , and gameplay was awsome . but maybe DS have a better gameplay or graphic but it's me i love this kind of game like masseffect,dragon age,heavy rain, fable 2inferna_hermit

It definitely deserved it. It actually innovated that genre and was a superb RPG, very deserving of the praise it gets.

It definitely deserved it. It actually innovated that genre and was a superb RPG, very deserving of the praise it gets.

Phoenix534

Come on more then 50% of people Vote for Dragon Age Origins , So don't tell me i'm upset because it's PS3 exclusive !

inferna_hermit

I agree that Demon Souls is an excellent and especially innovative RPG whereas DA:O pretty much does what has been done before. Nevertheless DA:O might not innovate but what it does do it does so perfectly, story, characters, all the things that are important for a good RPG DA:O does allot better than Demon Souls. The "Best Of" thing is an editors vote, it's their choice on who to give it to. As for the community of gamers surrounding GS they've clearly chosen DA:O over Demons Souls.Lone_Warrior_66

Dragon Age is also a multiplat from Bioware, which many people have heard of (as opposed to Atlus), and many people have not played Demon's Souls and some have tried it and found it too hard, so the amount of people supporting Demon's Souls isn't going to be nearly as large. That's why I'm glad these things aren't won by a popularity vote.

I blame the lack of polearms.

Please don't Call every Game Innovative so easily - Dragon Age is great and Demon's Souls is great too but in these games ,there is no innovation thing .name one inferna_hermit

yes they are cool but not innovating to change games history ,like halo - in lots of games your health will be regenerate and halo is the game done it for the first time and change history of games ,and now you can see this creative mind in most of the games. and these things you said already done to other games like some webgames ,and don't do any revolution in games. innovation is somthing change the game and do revolution not improving games or changing some gameplay elements

Dragon Age is also known for its very hard difficulty and doesn't exactly appeal to the mainstream audience because of said difficulty and a geeky title like Dragon Age. You're equating it to a Modern Warfare 2 of RPGs, which it is not.F1_2004

That's why I'm glad these things aren't won by a popularity vote.uyiop0t

[QUOTE="uyiop0t"]That's why I'm glad these things aren't won by a popularity vote.Lone_Warrior_66

yes they are cool but not innovating to change games history ,like halo

inferna_hermit