Is it bad that my favorite game for the wii is still twilight princess?

After 2 years he wii has been out my favorite game is a game that came out right as the wii did. Sure other good games came out but still the most replability and fun is still twilight princess

Something has to be your favorite.

I feel the same way. While it isn't my favorite Zelda, it is one of the only ones I couldn't wait to finish more of.

[QUOTE="funsohng"]I love TP myself. i dont care the so-called teh hardcore zelda fans trashing TP, i love it.sonic_spark

No. Hardcore fans love the game. People bashing TP are morons. There is not a single valid claim. NOT ONE. It was the best Zelda.

There are only so many superb games on the Wii. So TP being your favorite still. Completely legitimate. Its mine too. With Metroid Prime 3 a very close second.

Its not bad a bad thing at all, it was a great game and i thoroughly enjoyed it as well. As long as you like it that's all that matters, and all the naysayers of the game can dislike it all they want, doesn't mean it wasn't good and we cant enjoy it.

Personally I think it's the worst Nintendo made Zelda since Zelda 2 and one of the worst games I've ever played

If you like it though then that's great, as long as it's you playing it and not me have a ball.

Nothing wrong with that. I disagree with you though. :P

[QUOTE="funsohng"]I love TP myself. i dont care the so-called teh hardcore zelda fans trashing TP, i love it.sonic_spark

No. Hardcore fans love the game. People bashing TP are morons. There is not a single valid claim. NOT ONE. It was the best Zelda.

There are only so many superb games on the Wii. So TP being your favorite still. Completely legitimate. Its mine too. With Metroid Prime 3 a very close second.

That's fine it's your favorite, but it's definitely not mine.

I agree with Jayson though, it's one of the worst by far imo

It had sooooooo much potential, but unfortunately did not deliver imo. I've been playing since day one, and again... it's not even close to my favorite. Midna though, is my favorite Zelda character. Too bad, they shot her down

I got about 3 hours into it when the inlaws got their copy, but that wasn't enough time to fall in love with it. It's on my list of titles to track down in due time.

Nope Twilight Princess is awesome and is my second favorite game on the Wii.

Yeah it's my favorite game for the Wii as well, I'm currently playing through it again. I'm a huge Zelda fan, as it's my favorite game franchise. Super Mario Galaxy and Okami were excellent games as well though.

Not at all its one of the finest titles this gen but my favourite goes to Mario Galaxy.

[QUOTE="funsohng"]

No. Hardcore fans love the game. People bashing TP are morons. There is not a single valid claim. NOT ONE. It was the best Zelda.

There are only so many superb games on the Wii. So TP being your favorite still. Completely legitimate. Its mine too. With Metroid Prime 3 a very close second.

sonic_spark

[QUOTE="funsohng"]I love TP myself. i dont care the so-called teh hardcore zelda fans trashing TP, i love it.sonic_spark

No. Hardcore fans love the game. People bashing TP are morons. There is not a single valid claim. NOT ONE. It was the best Zelda.

There are only so many superb games on the Wii. So TP being your favorite still. Completely legitimate. Its mine too. With Metroid Prime 3 a very close second.

@Jason, could you please elaborate on why you hate it so much? Haven't you said that you haven't even beaten it yet before?

It's an awesome game so no I don't see what's wrong. I have to replay it.

It's still my favorite too. I love many Wii games but Zelda will always win. I imagine it will stay my favorite until the next Wii Zelda comes out. And people who say this is a bad game have issues. Saying its too similar to other Zelda's is a valid criticism (you really could say that about most Zeldas with the exception of Zelda II, Majora's Mask and Phantom Hourglass). Even then a similiar product to an amazing series can't really be considered bad just not original. I can't even recall Nintendo ever making a bad game (there are quite a few mediocre ones such as Yoshi's Story though) let alone a Zelda game. At least personally for me Twilight Princess is my 2nd favorite Zelda game under A Link To The Past. Now if they did a Wind Waker Wiimake and added that extra dungeon that was cut out then I may reconsider.

If you love a game you love it. Its not bad if there are no other games that toped that for you on the Wii.

No, I'm replaying it for the 3rd time so my friend can watch and it's a fantastic game.

Nothing wrong with that. My favorite Wii game is still Super Smash Brothers Brawl and that has been out for nearly a year and a half or so.

For me Super Mario Galaxy is my favorite Wii game, however Twilight Princess is my second. Metroid Prime Trilogy would be third.

I'm gonna go ahead and say that it is NOT a bad thing that Twilight Princess is your favorite game. Hell, it's still my second favorite game (I like it more than Mario Galaxy which is also stellar). But my favorite Wii game is Suda 51 and Grasshopper Manufacture's No More Heroes! Most badass game I've played this entire console gen, hands-down!

*shrug* Something has to be your favourite, TP is as good a choice as any. Heck, my favourite wii game is Mario Strikers.

I'm gonna go ahead and say that it is NOT a bad thing that Twilight Princess is your favorite game. Hell, it's still my second favorite game (I like it more than Mario Galaxy which is also stellar). But my favorite Wii game is Suda 51 and Grasshopper Manufacture's No More Heroes! Most badass game I've played this entire console gen, hands-down!

NeonNinja

[QUOTE="NeonNinja"]

I'm gonna go ahead and say that it is NOT a bad thing that Twilight Princess is your favorite game. Hell, it's still my second favorite game (I like it more than Mario Galaxy which is also stellar). But my favorite Wii game is Suda 51 and Grasshopper Manufacture's No More Heroes! Most badass game I've played this entire console gen, hands-down!

gamefan67

Mine would read:

No More Heroes
Twilight Princess (a distant second)
Mario Galaxy (a close third)

We do have a bit of a similarity, except that I don't like Metroid Prime 3: Corruption at all. I think it pales very much so next to the two previous Prime games. On the other hand, I think Galaxy is a huge step up from Sunshine. I don't know, I figure people will always have similarities but no one will be exactly alike. That's be wierd. :P

i pretty much feel the same way . the wii has a huge good release gap for me , my favs are already pretty old , finished , and replaying them wouldnt make much sense becaus i've got plenty other games on my other systems to finish yet , however after MK ,SMG ,RE4 , Bully , Okami, NMH there were almost no games that would interest me and when i had to choose a top notch mutiplat game vs. a average wii exclusive you can guess what my choice is , but finally something good will come , i mean the new mario .....

Twilight princess is my favorite game from this generation (I own wii, ps3, ds, and pc). Exploring hyrule is very awe inspiring. There is something special about that game.

People bashing TP are morons. There is not a single valid claim. NOT ONE. It was the best Zelda.sonic_spark

*Starts counting valid complaints*

It seems like there is a fair amount.

TP was my first venture into the 3D zelda games. After my amazing experience with Okami on the PS2, and people comparing it with zelda. This franchise had a lot to prove. It met that challenge with the mediocre game known as TP.

No of course it isnt bad! TP was amazing.

It's one of my favourite Zelda games behind Wind Waker,Ocarina of Time and A Link to the Past.

[QUOTE="sonic_spark"]People bashing TP are morons. There is not a single valid claim. NOT ONE. It was the best Zelda._Tobli_

*Starts counting valid complaints*

It seems like there is a fair amount.

TP was my first venture into the 3D zelda games. After my amazing experience with Okami on the PS2, and people comparing it with zelda. This franchise had a lot to prove. It met that challenge with the mediocre game known as TP.

Name just a few please.

How can you possibly find Zelda TP mediocre? Sheer scope of the game, quality of the dungeons, one of the more original stories in the franchise, tons of new cool weapons, finishing combos introduced, great controls, great artstyle.

The only knock on the game and I'll concede this, is that it probably could've used a bump in production values (orchestrated music for example). And the game was on the easier side of things.

But really, this game is so polished. So if you actually have complaints, list them. Mediocre, definitely not.

How can you possibly find Zelda TP mediocre?

sonic_spark

[QUOTE="funsohng"]I love TP myself. i dont care the so-called teh hardcore zelda fans trashing TP, i love it.sonic_spark

No. Hardcore fans love the game. People bashing TP are morons. There is not a single valid claim. NOT ONE. It was the best Zelda.

There are only so many superb games on the Wii. So TP being your favorite still. Completely legitimate. Its mine too. With Metroid Prime 3 a very close second.

False, there are many valid complaints. Way too easy, and cut and paste design of past games come to mind immediately.

Name just a few please.sonic_spark

In my eyes it is mediocre compared with Okami. If i actually compared them point by point. The only category where TP would win is puzzles.

I agree. People who say TP isn't the best, for this or that reason, have valid points. But saying it isn't the best Zelda, is a long way from saying it stinks aranom

Superb=/=mediocre=/=bad

5/10 in this instance doesn't mean that it stinks. It just means that my reaction to the game is a big meh.

Name just a few please.

How can you possibly find Zelda TP mediocre? Sheer scope of the game, quality of the dungeons, one of the more original stories in the franchise, tons of new cool weapons, finishing combos introduced, great controls, great artstyle.

The only knock on the game and I'll concede this, is that it probably could've used a bump in production values (orchestrated music for example). And the game was on the easier side of things.

But really, this game is so polished. So if you actually have complaints, list them. Mediocre, definitely not.

sonic_spark

Well, first off, I love TP. But two VERY major complaints is that, as I said before, it is extremely similar to every other Zelda. The next is the easy difficulty. Other valid complaints include: a relatively empty overworld, lack of interesting characters, lack of worthwhile sidequests, and badly played out wolf sections (finding the tears of light.

With all that said, I still think it's an amzing game, but it just was too much of the same in the end.

False, there are many valid complaints. Way too easy, and cut and paste design of past games come to mind immediately.

TaMuK711

[QUOTE="TaMuK711"]

False, there are many valid complaints. Way too easy, and cut and paste design of past games come to mind immediately.

After 2 years he wii has been out my favorite game is a game that came out right as the wii did. Sure other good games came out but still the most replability and fun is still twilight princess

baseballSGFkid

I don't think that is necessary a bad thing, my favorite PS3 game is still MGS4 and for 360 (while i don't have one) is still DOA4.