[QUOTE="SoraX64"] Well, more like out argued, I guess.
clicketyclick
People argued against him with things that he already accepted or with irrelevant facts. For example, people keep quoting the review to "prove" that the reviewer agrees and telling him to read it, not look at the marks. Jaysonguy already read it. He knows what it says. His problem is with the mark they give it because he asserts that it is an unfair score. All these people prove is that IGN's reviewer agrees with Jaysonguy's premise (that the game is going for an 8-bit art-styIe and achieves it well), and so they should follow Jaysonguy's logic to its conclusion (giving the game a higher graphics score.) That is, unless someone can show why games that perfectly nail their art-styIe (which is not generic in design; it has personality) should get marked down for not maxing out a machine's capacities with moar lens-flare.
Another argument that keeps being recycled against him is that the Graphics score doesn't count towards the final score, so it doesn't matter and you shouldn't care about it. Well, that is true, but it makes the assumption that the final score is the only thing that matters. If it were the only thing that mattered, then IGN would just get rid of the score breakdown like G-Spot did. The score is posted and they put a justification for each score, therefore, it is legitimate to critique each score they assigned.
What I think he is failing to see, though, is that all of the games that IGN and GameSpot review are compared to other games, especially in graphics. It would be unfair to give Mega Man 9 a good score in graphics because the graphics are purposely bad. IGN clearly states that the graphics are a positive part of the game, but they don't compare to other games. The graphics in this game are meant to be retro, so they are not very good. What Jaysonguy said was that IGN had no credibility because they rated the game with bad graphics. The individual scores do not combine for an average score, so the game DOES get the 8.6 it deserves. The graphics just are not good.
I have been on GameSpot for years and I have yet to see someone back up an argument like Jaysonguy does. I am not disrespecting him when I say this, but he should try a little harder to argue with things less, because I bet a nice chunk of our posters here are young/ too young, and he should use his intellegence for something other than arguing.
Log in to comment