Super mario galaxy vs. Zelda TP

i m wondering what ppl think is better Super Mario Galaxy or

The Legend of Zelda Twilight Princess for me Zelda is better

justby alittle bit

Super Mario Galaxy it is more fun to play but both excellent games.

Twilight princess was the best Wii game i have played.

Heck it was the best nintendo game ive played (YES IM TALKING TO YOU OCARINA)

mario galaxy was okay. but nothing that (GoOD)

Legend of Zelda Twilight Princess is my favorite Wii games, and Super Mario Galaxy is my second.

Neither was as good as its predecessors. Twilight Princess felt almost like a clone of OoT. Windwaker brought tons of new ideas and concepts to the Zelda franchise. All Twilight Princess brought was prettier graphics. Super Mario Galaxy; despite being gimmicky as it gets, was the most solid of the two.

Super Mario Galaxy was the Mario experience that Twilight Princess SHOULD had been for Zelda; SMG was a game that managed to stay true to its roots, without paying too much homage to its predecessors, while still providing a gameplay experience that was fun and fresh. There are those rare games that just fits a system like a glove, and SMG is that game for the Wii. Awesome gameplay, solid controls that make the most of the Wii remote, and a beautiful atmosphere puts Galaxy in a league of its own when concerning Wii games.

both are great ames but i enjoyed Super Mario Galaxy a bit more because of it's awesome levels and 120 stars. LOZ twilight Princess was good to. I loved using the bow and arrow :D

Both are incredible games, but I have always enjoyed Mario more than Zelda because his games always last MUCH longer. Galaxy gives me way more to do than Twilight Princess. I love getting high coin scores in each level because there are some AMAZING secrets just for yellow coins!

Galaxy is better imo, Zelda was great but felt dated and Galaxy felt so fresh

i say glaxay

I liked Twilight Princess a little better, but both are top-notch games.

I liked TP better but that's only because

A) I'm a bigger fan of Zelda

and

B) I don't complain about TP being unoriginal like SOME people do.

That said, Super Mario Galaxy is still an amazing game.

Note: Has anyone noticed all of these new members in the Wii forums?

SMG

quality wise it just isnt even close. both games are great but SMG just dominated.

SMG is far better

SMG.

Twilight Princess. Best Wii game I think.

Galaxy is the more current Wii game in regards to how it's built and the experience, but Twilight Princess was better for me.

Twilight Princess by far.

Super Mario Galaxy. LoZ TP isnt truly a Wii game because it was first gonna be released for the Gamecube. We still await for a truly Wii Zelda. (Coming soon)

But I enjoyed SMG more then zelda.

Super Mario Galaxy was nearly as complete and polished as it could have been.Twilight Princess,though still great,has lots of things the developers could have (and should have) improved upon.

Galaxy, it felt new and fresh. Plus, I don't like Zelda all that much, and like Mario games a lot more.

Super Mario Galaxy is much more original and fun than Twilight Princess. Still I love them both even though I don't consider TP to be a Wii game, that is a Gamecube game ported to the Wii.

Galaxy takes a viscious dump on twilight princess. And not just a regular dump, a horrrible demeaning one at that.

Galaxy takes a viscious dump on twilight princess. And not just a regular dump, a horrrible demeaning one at that.

ActicEdge

........................No comment.

I really liked Zelda: TP, but it just doesn't stand up to the awesomeness of Super Mario Galaxy.

I enjoyed TP a little bit more, but I consider Galaxy to be the better game of the two.alphamale1989

They're both great games, but I like Galaxy more because it's fun and it has very high replayabilty.

Both gamesare great but I'm going to have to say Super Mario Galaxy was better

They are both great,Twilight Princess has better slightly better gameplay while Galaxy has a way higher replay value. Galaxy doesn't even need replay value because it is so long if you are going to get all of the stars. Twilight Princess barely has a replay value.

Super Mario Galaxy is better.

I have to go with Super Mario Galaxy, I think it's a game that even rivals Ocarina of time.master_sword90

i like the Zelda series more, but I have to give the thumbs up to Galaxy on this one

i like the Zelda series more, but I have to give the thumbs up to Galaxy on this one

chex81

Well to be fair, i can't really compare due to the fact I've only ever played Galaxy. :P But i've always prefered mario games, and galaxy was EPIC in my opinion. I want to get TP, though, but the thing is with this comparison is TP is also on the GC, so its a tiny bit unfair to compare a remake for another console with a purely wii title. I think a good comparison would be the new Zelda wii and SMG 2 when they come out. Maybe. :P

Galaxy was disappointing and I hate the Zelda games as a whole, so I go with Galaxy