All Harry Potter and the Deathly Hollows discussion here

[QUOTE="bradleybhoy"]

[QUOTE="sHaDyCuBe321"][QUOTE="Liquid-Prince"]I don't understand. Originally JK said she was going to kill Harry in the 7th book and everyone complained and nagged her for months. Then she changes the book and people are still whining. Personally I thought the ending was amazing.Liquid-Prince

Don't worry about him, he likes to make things up off the top of his head and then try to pass them off as fact.

Watch your mouth. I don't like being insulted and you saying what you said is as good as a slap to the face. And as a matter of fact it was on the radio a couple months ago that there were people flooding JK with emails begging not kill Harry in the 7th book as she had it planned.

[spoiler] I'm not really sure she said that he would actually die, butI thinkI know why you might think that. I do remember several times when she hinted that he could. Someone asked her if there would be more Potter books and she said that the ending made it quite clear what happens to Harry. She has been really careful not to give anything away. I doalso remember people, including Stephen King, pleading with her not to kill Harry. A lot of people presumed that she would to prevent other people from writing stories about Harry and ruining the series. She considers the books her special babies and to let someone else tamper with her work, would be unbearable. [/spoiler]

[QUOTE="Liquid-Prince"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"]

[QUOTE="sHaDyCuBe321"][QUOTE="Liquid-Prince"]I don't understand. Originally JK said she was going to kill Harry in the 7th book and everyone complained and nagged her for months. Then she changes the book and people are still whining. Personally I thought the ending was amazing.Travo_basic

Don't worry about him, he likes to make things up off the top of his head and then try to pass them off as fact.

Watch your mouth. I don't like being insulted and you saying what you said is as good as a slap to the face. And as a matter of fact it was on the radio a couple months ago that there were people flooding JK with emails begging not kill Harry in the 7th book as she had it planned.

[spoiler] I'm not really sure she said that he would actually die, butI thinkI know why you might think that. I do remember several times when she hinted that he could. Someone asked her if there would be more Potter books and she said that the ending made it quite clear what happens to Harry. She has been really careful not to give anything away. I doalso remember people, including Stephen King, pleading with her not to kill Harry. A lot of people presumed that she would to prevent other people from writing stories about Harry and ruining the series. She considers the books her special babies and to let someone else tamper with her work, would be unbearable. [/spoiler]

If I wrote such engaging and popular stories, I'd think the same way as her. And Harry Potter should never be written by anyone other then her.

If I wrote such engaging and popular stories, I'd think the same way as her. And Harry Potter should never be written by anyone other then her.

I agree. Nobody should ever try to tamper with this great series. It's like when they wrote a sequel for Gone with the Wind. WHHYY?

[spoiler] I feel so bad for hating Snape as much as I did now, after reading "the Prince's Tale". It was so heartbreaking. He was an ass at times, but he was on Harry and Dumbeldore's side all along, and was obviouslypretty emotionalywracked because of Lily. [/spoiler] justiceboy13

[spoiler] I felt so sad when Dobby died, it was like the first character since the beginning of the series, other than maybe Sirius, whom I genuinly felt sad for having passed away. But when Snape died and after Harry went through his memories I really, really felt bad for hating him so much [/spoiler] d_eM_s

Same here..both of those parts made me cry.

No book has brought me so close to tears as this one. I'm somewhat ashamed of saying so but when grow to love some characters so much you just can't help but do so. d_eM_s

No need to be ashamed.

[QUOTE="d_eM_s"]No book has brought me so close to tears as this one. I'm somewhat ashamed of saying so but when grow to love some characters so much you just can't help but do so. princemarth23

No need to be ashamed.

[spoiler] When Dobby died was probably the most emotional part of the book for me. :( [/spoiler]

[spoiler] When Dobby died was probably the most emotional part of the book for me. :( [/spoiler]

bradleybhoy

[spoiler] Knowing about Snape's past made his death much more emotional to me. He is a true hero. You kinda got a sense that he would end up good, at the end, but not quite this emotional. [/spoiler]

[QUOTE="bradleybhoy"]

[spoiler] When Dobby died was probably the most emotional part of the book for me. :( [/spoiler]

Travo_basic

[spoiler] Knowing about Snape's past made his death much more emotional to me. He is a true hero. You kinda got a sense that he would end up good, at the end, but not quite this emotional. [/spoiler]

[spoiler] The thing about Snape's death was, you didn't actually really know the truth about him until after he was dead. I (as did most other people) were prepared for either outcome, either Snape would've been a double agent death eater (for some reason we didn't find out until now) or he would've been bad all along. Snape hated Harry and his dad, I don't think he felt sorry for them at all. He only cared about Lily, and it was he that caused her death in the first place. To tell you the truth I wasn't that moved by his death. But that's just my feelings. :) [/spoiler]

No book has brought me so close to tears as this one. I'm somewhat ashamed of saying so but when grow to love some characters so much you just can't help but do so. d_eM_s

but anyways so many deaths so little time!

[QUOTE="Tylendal"]What J.K. Rowling should do, is open up the Harry Potter series for an extended universe, sort of like Star Wars, Dragon-Lance, and Magic: The Gathering, all the same world, but written by different people.ZeldaFan2329

It wouldn't be the same if other people wrote it. They don't have the gift Rowling has.

But I can't belive how she layed the story out. The plot and story line has so many twists and turns and revolves around other books. Once you start thinking about it you realise how amazing she really is.

JK Rowling is not a great writer, she may write interesting situations, but her writing style is very simple. There are many authors who could write an extended universe better than she wrote the actual books, she is not a great writer in any way.

[QUOTE="Travo_basic"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"]

[spoiler] When Dobby died was probably the most emotional part of the book for me. :( [/spoiler]

bradleybhoy

[spoiler] Knowing about Snape's past made his death much more emotional to me. He is a true hero. You kinda got a sense that he would end up good, at the end, but not quite this emotional. [/spoiler]

[spoiler] The thing about Snape's death was, you didn't actually really know the truth about him until after he was dead. I (as did most other people) were prepared for either outcome, either Snape would've been a double agent death eater (for some reason we didn't find out until now) or he would've been bad all along. Snape hated Harry and his dad, I don't think he felt sorry for them at all. He only cared about Lily, and it was he that caused her death in the first place. To tell you the truth I wasn't that moved by his death. But that's just my feelings. :) [/spoiler]

[spoiler] If Iwere in Snape's shoes, I would hate James too. James had everything, and on top of that he was a complete ass to Snape. The pensieves memories from the previous books showed that. [/spoiler]

[QUOTE="Liquid-Prince"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"]

[QUOTE="sHaDyCuBe321"][QUOTE="Liquid-Prince"]I don't understand. Originally JK said she was going to kill Harry in the 7th book and everyone complained and nagged her for months. Then she changes the book and people are still whining. Personally I thought the ending was amazing.Travo_basic

Don't worry about him, he likes to make things up off the top of his head and then try to pass them off as fact.

Watch your mouth. I don't like being insulted and you saying what you said is as good as a slap to the face. And as a matter of fact it was on the radio a couple months ago that there were people flooding JK with emails begging not kill Harry in the 7th book as she had it planned.

[spoiler] I'm not really sure she said that he would actually die, butI thinkI know why you might think that. I do remember several times when she hinted that he could. Someone asked her if there would be more Potter books and she said that the ending made it quite clear what happens to Harry. She has been really careful not to give anything away. I doalso remember people, including Stephen King, pleading with her not to kill Harry. A lot of people presumed that she would to prevent other people from writing stories about Harry and ruining the series. She considers the books her special babies and to let someone else tamper with her work, would be unbearable. [/spoiler]

am I the only one who thinks its funny that stephen king, one of the most popular HORROR writers of all time pleaded with her not to kill a character:lol: Cmon stephen you kill off tons of character in bloody ways, grow some balls and not plead to kill off one character:roll:

I just finished the book today, and one question is still posed:

Why does JK Rowling never explain why people always say Harry has his mother's eyes? I assumed it would have SOME relevance to the plot...

[QUOTE="Travo_basic"][QUOTE="Liquid-Prince"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"]

[QUOTE="sHaDyCuBe321"][QUOTE="Liquid-Prince"]I don't understand. Originally JK said she was going to kill Harry in the 7th book and everyone complained and nagged her for months. Then she changes the book and people are still whining. Personally I thought the ending was amazing.Film-Guy

Don't worry about him, he likes to make things up off the top of his head and then try to pass them off as fact.

Watch your mouth. I don't like being insulted and you saying what you said is as good as a slap to the face. And as a matter of fact it was on the radio a couple months ago that there were people flooding JK with emails begging not kill Harry in the 7th book as she had it planned.

[spoiler] I'm not really sure she said that he would actually die, butI thinkI know why you might think that. I do remember several times when she hinted that he could. Someone asked her if there would be more Potter books and she said that the ending made it quite clear what happens to Harry. She has been really careful not to give anything away. I doalso remember people, including Stephen King, pleading with her not to kill Harry. A lot of people presumed that she would to prevent other people from writing stories about Harry and ruining the series. She considers the books her special babies and to let someone else tamper with her work, would be unbearable. [/spoiler]

am I the only one who thinks its funny that stephen king, one of the most popular HORROR writers of all time pleaded with her not to kill a character:lol: Cmon stephen you kill off tons of character in bloody ways, grow some balls and not plead to kill off one character:roll:

[QUOTE="Film-Guy"][QUOTE="Travo_basic"][QUOTE="Liquid-Prince"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"]

[QUOTE="sHaDyCuBe321"][QUOTE="Liquid-Prince"]I don't understand. Originally JK said she was going to kill Harry in the 7th book and everyone complained and nagged her for months. Then she changes the book and people are still whining. Personally I thought the ending was amazing.Greatgone12

Don't worry about him, he likes to make things up off the top of his head and then try to pass them off as fact.

Watch your mouth. I don't like being insulted and you saying what you said is as good as a slap to the face. And as a matter of fact it was on the radio a couple months ago that there were people flooding JK with emails begging not kill Harry in the 7th book as she had it planned.

[spoiler] I'm not really sure she said that he would actually die, butI thinkI know why you might think that. I do remember several times when she hinted that he could. Someone asked her if there would be more Potter books and she said that the ending made it quite clear what happens to Harry. She has been really careful not to give anything away. I doalso remember people, including Stephen King, pleading with her not to kill Harry. A lot of people presumed that she would to prevent other people from writing stories about Harry and ruining the series. She considers the books her special babies and to let someone else tamper with her work, would be unbearable. [/spoiler]

am I the only one who thinks its funny that stephen king, one of the most popular HORROR writers of all time pleaded with her not to kill a character:lol: Cmon stephen you kill off tons of character in bloody ways, grow some balls and not plead to kill off one character:roll:

stephen king wrote a 7 part fantasy series too, the dark tower where he killed off pretty much everyone. And the dark tower had some of the best developed characters and story of any fantasy series:|

stephen king wrote a 7 part fantasy series too, the dark tower where he killed off pretty much everyone. And the dark tower had some of the best developed characters and story of any fantasy series:|

Film-Guy

[QUOTE="Film-Guy"]

stephen king wrote a 7 part fantasy series too, the dark tower where he killed off pretty much everyone. And the dark tower had some of the best developed characters and story of any fantasy series:|

Greatgone12

why do you think the dark tower sucked?

[QUOTE="Greatgone12"][QUOTE="Film-Guy"]

stephen king wrote a 7 part fantasy series too, the dark tower where he killed off pretty much everyone. And the dark tower had some of the best developed characters and story of any fantasy series:|

Film-Guy

why do you think the dark tower sucked?

[QUOTE="bradleybhoy"][QUOTE="Travo_basic"][QUOTE="bradleybhoy"]

[spoiler] When Dobby died was probably the most emotional part of the book for me. :( [/spoiler]

CrimzonTide

[spoiler] Knowing about Snape's past made his death much more emotional to me. He is a true hero. You kinda got a sense that he would end up good, at the end, but not quite this emotional. [/spoiler]

[spoiler] The thing about Snape's death was, you didn't actually really know the truth about him until after he was dead. I (as did most other people) were prepared for either outcome, either Snape would've been a double agent death eater (for some reason we didn't find out until now) or he would've been bad all along. Snape hated Harry and his dad, I don't think he felt sorry for them at all. He only cared about Lily, and it was he that caused her death in the first place. To tell you the truth I wasn't that moved by his death. But that's just my feelings. :) [/spoiler]

[spoiler] If Iwere in Snape's shoes, I would hate James too. James had everything, and on top of that he was a complete ass to Snape. The pensieves memories from the previous books showed that. [/spoiler]

True. I kind of feel sorry for him now. He had no love in his life. :(

[QUOTE="Film-Guy"][QUOTE="Greatgone12"][QUOTE="Film-Guy"]

stephen king wrote a 7 part fantasy series too, the dark tower where he killed off pretty much everyone. And the dark tower had some of the best developed characters and story of any fantasy series:|

Greatgone12

why do you think the dark tower sucked?

wtf, thats not a reason, thats just stupid:|

[QUOTE="ZeldaFan2329"]

[QUOTE="Tylendal"]What J.K. Rowling should do, is open up the Harry Potter series for an extended universe, sort of like Star Wars, Dragon-Lance, and Magic: The Gathering, all the same world, but written by different people.Film-Guy

It wouldn't be the same if other people wrote it. They don't have the gift Rowling has.

But I can't belive how she layed the story out. The plot and story line has so many twists and turns and revolves around other books. Once you start thinking about it you realise how amazing she really is.

JK Rowling is not a great writer, she may write interesting situations, but her writing style is very simple. There are many authors who could write an extended universe better than she wrote the actual books, she is not a great writer in any way.

[QUOTE="Greatgone12"][QUOTE="Film-Guy"][QUOTE="Greatgone12"][QUOTE="Film-Guy"]

stephen king wrote a 7 part fantasy series too, the dark tower where he killed off pretty much everyone. And the dark tower had some of the best developed characters and story of any fantasy series:|

Film-Guy

why do you think the dark tower sucked?

wtf, thats not a reason, thats just stupid:|

[QUOTE="ZeldaFan2329"]

[QUOTE="Tylendal"]What J.K. Rowling should do, is open up the Harry Potter series for an extended universe, sort of like Star Wars, Dragon-Lance, and Magic: The Gathering, all the same world, but written by different people.Film-Guy

It wouldn't be the same if other people wrote it. They don't have the gift Rowling has.

But I can't belive how she layed the story out. The plot and story line has so many twists and turns and revolves around other books. Once you start thinking about it you realise how amazing she really is.

JK Rowling is not a great writer, she may write interesting situations, but her writing style is very simple. There are many authors who could write an extended universe better than she wrote the actual books, she is not a great writer in any way.

Just because her writing style is simple, it doesn't mean the books aren't masterfully written. She is a great author and that is undeniable.

[QUOTE="Film-Guy"][QUOTE="ZeldaFan2329"]

[QUOTE="Tylendal"]What J.K. Rowling should do, is open up the Harry Potter series for an extended universe, sort of like Star Wars, Dragon-Lance, and Magic: The Gathering, all the same world, but written by different people.Liquid-Prince

It wouldn't be the same if other people wrote it. They don't have the gift Rowling has.

But I can't belive how she layed the story out. The plot and story line has so many twists and turns and revolves around other books. Once you start thinking about it you realise how amazing she really is.

JK Rowling is not a great writer, she may write interesting situations, but her writing style is very simple. There are many authors who could write an extended universe better than she wrote the actual books, she is not a great writer in any way.

Just because her writing style is simple, it doesn't mean the books aren't masterfully written. She is a great author and that is undeniable.

[QUOTE="Film-Guy"][QUOTE="ZeldaFan2329"]

[QUOTE="Tylendal"]What J.K. Rowling should do, is open up the Harry Potter series for an extended universe, sort of like Star Wars, Dragon-Lance, and Magic: The Gathering, all the same world, but written by different people.Liquid-Prince

It wouldn't be the same if other people wrote it. They don't have the gift Rowling has.

But I can't belive how she layed the story out. The plot and story line has so many twists and turns and revolves around other books. Once you start thinking about it you realise how amazing she really is.

JK Rowling is not a great writer, she may write interesting situations, but her writing style is very simple. There are many authors who could write an extended universe better than she wrote the actual books, she is not a great writer in any way.

Just because her writing style is simple, it doesn't mean the books aren't masterfully written. She is a great author and that is undeniable.

I second that. You don't need all the flourish and crap like that. If you write a simple book well, it often turns out better than a fancy book written poorly.

Ok, now that I've confirmed the spoiler works *see above*, my thoughts are below.

[spoiler] well, it was my favorite book, it kept me in suspense, the action was great (the siege of Hogwarts was astonishing, that will be an amazing battle on the big screen), and the characters were as lively as ever. I was crushed with the deaths of so many-Lupin, Tonks, Dobby, Fred, Mad-Eye...and my favorite char, Snape. Here's hoping there's another bookl...I was a tad letdown with the epilogue, I wanted to find out what happened with George and the Weasleys....and though I wanted to see Neville off Bellatrix, it was great watching Mrs. Weasley kick some butt. Lol, sweetMrs. Weasley kicing Lestrange's arse...*chuckles*. And I loved how Neville killed Nagini, he's another one of my favorites. A little surprised Draco made it through, evenmore surprised he acknowledged Harry in the epilogue. [/spoiler]

EPILOGUE WAS GREAT SEEING AS HOW IT WAS JUST EXTRA AND WAS NEVER SAID TO HAVE BEEN PUT IN. IT WAS ICING ON THE CAKE. What I dont get cause I may have skimmed over this part briefly is:

[spoiler] How did Neville get the Sword? [/spoiler]

Ok, now that I've confirmed the spoiler works *see above*, my thoughts are below.

[spoiler] well, it was my favorite book, it kept me in suspense, the action was great (the siege of Hogwarts was astonishing, that will be an amazing battle on the big screen), and the characters were as lively as ever. I was crushed with the deaths of so many-Lupin, Tonks, Dobby, Fred, Mad-Eye...and my favorite char, Snape. Here's hoping there's another bookl...I was a tad letdown with the epilogue, I wanted to find out what happened with George and the Weasleys....and though I wanted to see Neville off Bellatrix, it was great watching Mrs. Weasley kick some butt. Lol, sweetMrs. Weasley kicing Lestrange's arse...*chuckles*. And I loved how Neville killed Nagini, he's another one of my favorites. A little surprised Draco made it through, evenmore surprised he acknowledged Harry in the epilogue. [/spoiler]

stewiegriffin78

Why were you surprised? [spoiler] Harry saved the entire world, wizarding and muggle, from the hands of Voldemort. The least he could do was give Harry a nod of recognition. [/spoiler]

[spoiler] Alright am i the only one that was kinda disappointed by teh ending in harry potter. I mean i just read somewhere between three to four thousand pages of harry potter over the course of a couple years. And it came down to harry say expeleriamus and getting the wand. But i mean after reading this much and having the entire plotline focus on this final battle, dont you think she should have made it a little more climatic. All they did was basically circle for five pages like some dragonball z episode and then one little move and it was over. There should have been at least a chapter for the battle itself in my opinion. I know i am probably gonna get flamed for this post, but i also know i am not the only one who feels this way. Maybe i was just expecting something too epic for a final fight, but i mean if your writing 7 books i think the event that all the books were focusing on should be epic. Also ithought it was funny how when dumbledore and harry were speaking before harry went to fight voldemort he wsa like oo voldemorts and harrys souls are connected, like it was some gigantic revelation, but i mean come on, we knew that already they had only been seeing into each others minds for how many books now. Maybe im just frustrated that it didnt meet my expectation, maybe im not . Whatever the rest of the book was good in my opinion. Thoughts anyone? [/spoiler]

[spoiler] Alright am i the only one that was kinda disappointed by teh ending in harry potter. I mean i just read somewhere between three to four thousand pages of harry potter over the course of a couple years. And it came down to harry say expeleriamus and getting the wand. But i mean after reading this much and having the entire plotline focus on this final battle, dont you think she should have made it a little more climatic. All they did was basically circle for five pages like some dragonball z episode and then one little move and it was over. There should have been at least a chapter for the battle itself in my opinion. I know i am probably gonna get flamed for this post, but i also know i am not the only one who feels this way. Maybe i was just expecting something too epic for a final fight, but i mean if your writing 7 books i think the event that all the books were focusing on should be epic. Also ithought it was funny how when dumbledore and harry were speaking before harry went to fight voldemort he wsa like oo voldemorts and harrys souls are connected, like it was some gigantic revelation, but i mean come on, we knew that already they had only been seeing into each others minds for how many books now. Maybe im just frustrated that it didnt meet my expectation, maybe im not . Whatever the rest of the book was good in my opinion. Thoughts anyone? [/spoiler]

st3wi3

[spoiler] We knew they were connected but I doubt you knew Harry had to die. Also the battle at the end was epic, and Harry did his spell which caused Voldemorts Avada Kedavra to flyback at him and kill him. I thought it was pretty epic. [/spoiler]

[QUOTE="st3wi3"]

[spoiler] Alright am i the only one that was kinda disappointed by teh ending in harry potter. I mean i just read somewhere between three to four thousand pages of harry potter over the course of a couple years. And it came down to harry say expeleriamus and getting the wand. But i mean after reading this much and having the entire plotline focus on this final battle, dont you think she should have made it a little more climatic. All they did was basically circle for five pages like some dragonball z episode and then one little move and it was over. There should have been at least a chapter for the battle itself in my opinion. I know i am probably gonna get flamed for this post, but i also know i am not the only one who feels this way. Maybe i was just expecting something too epic for a final fight, but i mean if your writing 7 books i think the event that all the books were focusing on should be epic. Also ithought it was funny how when dumbledore and harry were speaking before harry went to fight voldemort he wsa like oo voldemorts and harrys souls are connected, like it was some gigantic revelation, but i mean come on, we knew that already they had only been seeing into each others minds for how many books now. Maybe im just frustrated that it didnt meet my expectation, maybe im not . Whatever the rest of the book was good in my opinion. Thoughts anyone? [/spoiler]

Liquid-Prince

[spoiler] We knew they were connected but I doubt you knew Harry had to die. Also the battle at the end was epic, and Harry did his spell which caused Voldemorts Avada Kedavra to flyback at him and kill him. I thought it was pretty epic. [/spoiler]

[spoiler] The irony was that Lupin told Harry not to make expelliarmus his signature move since they were mainly going for kills, but in the end the spell actually did help in killing voldemort. [/spoiler]

[QUOTE="Liquid-Prince"][QUOTE="st3wi3"]

[spoiler] Alright am i the only one that was kinda disappointed by teh ending in harry potter. I mean i just read somewhere between three to four thousand pages of harry potter over the course of a couple years. And it came down to harry say expeleriamus and getting the wand. But i mean after reading this much and having the entire plotline focus on this final battle, dont you think she should have made it a little more climatic. All they did was basically circle for five pages like some dragonball z episode and then one little move and it was over. There should have been at least a chapter for the battle itself in my opinion. I know i am probably gonna get flamed for this post, but i also know i am not the only one who feels this way. Maybe i was just expecting something too epic for a final fight, but i mean if your writing 7 books i think the event that all the books were focusing on should be epic. Also ithought it was funny how when dumbledore and harry were speaking before harry went to fight voldemort he wsa like oo voldemorts and harrys souls are connected, like it was some gigantic revelation, but i mean come on, we knew that already they had only been seeing into each others minds for how many books now. Maybe im just frustrated that it didnt meet my expectation, maybe im not . Whatever the rest of the book was good in my opinion. Thoughts anyone? [/spoiler]

catfishmoon23

[spoiler] We knew they were connected but I doubt you knew Harry had to die. Also the battle at the end was epic, and Harry did his spell which caused Voldemorts Avada Kedavra to flyback at him and kill him. I thought it was pretty epic. [/spoiler]

[spoiler] The irony was that Lupin told Harry not to make expelliarmus his signature move since they were mainly going for kills, but in the end the spell actually did help in killing voldemort. [/spoiler]

[spoiler] Even if harry had not cast the spell, i do not think that teh avada kedavra curse would kill him becaause the elder wand was afterall harrys and so could not attack or at least kill its rightfull owner. I think thats why harry did not feel any pain with cruciatus curse when voldemort cast it. Also it could be that the elder wand itself turned the spell on voldemort and that really any or no spell at all from harry would have done the trick [/spoiler]

Finished reading this afternoon, a very satisfying ending to a very entertaining series. Whatever the hardcore fantasy nerds want to believe, this really is the Lord of the Rings/Narnia of its generation and will take its place among those greats. Master_Hermes

What a nerd o_O

Finished reading this afternoon, a very satisfying ending to a very entertaining series. Whatever the hardcore fantasy nerds want to believe, this really is the Lord of the Rings/Narnia of its generation and will take its place among those greats. Master_Hermes

in your opinion:P I am no hardcore fantasy nerd in any way, but I have read a book series that is better than harry potter imo, and its is still going on today

just finished.

amazing.

[QUOTE="Master_Hermes"]Finished reading this afternoon, a very satisfying ending to a very entertaining series. Whatever the hardcore fantasy nerds want to believe, this really is the Lord of the Rings/Narnia of its generation and will take its place among those greats. Film-Guy

in your opinion:P I am no hardcore fantasy nerd in any way, but I have read a book series that is better than harry potter imo, and its is still going on today

like what?

Harry potter was the best series i have ever read in my entire life.