[QUOTE="Wasdie"]
[QUOTE="tenaka2"]
But didn't they ban guns in New York city?
tenaka2
Not totally, just put really harsh restrictions on selling guns, and you cannot legally carry one concealed.
They did ban gun in australia with very good results, why wouldn't it work in the U.S.?
The gun ban was backed up by a mandatory buy-back program that substantially reduced gun possession in Australia.
iReporter: 'AK-47 a weapon for war'
The effect was that both gun suicides and homicides (as well as total suicides and homicides) fell. Importantly, while there were 13 mass shootings in Australia during the period of 1979--96, there have been none in the sixteen years since.
In 1996, then-Prime Minister John Howard stated that the "whole scheme is designed to reduce the number of guns in the community and make Australia a safer place to live." The Australian attorney general praised the cooperation and responsibility of Australian firearms owners with the gun controls and buy-back, saying, "they have been paid cash for their firearms - giving our nation a welcome Christmas gift by removing unnecessary high-powered firearms from the community. It offers all of us the real chance of a safer festive season and New Year."
Opinion: Can we feel safe in a crowd anymore?
Of course, the Australian gun control law in 1997 enjoyed an extremely high level of public support and was not hampered by any domestic gun industry (since Australia did not have any).
Such would not be the case in the United States where pro-gun political views and NRA power create a very different climate. In the wake of another tragic massacre of innocent lives, we should look carefully at the Australian experience to see if the American public will ever rise up as one against gun violence.
It's pretty much apples and oranges. Australia isn't only an island (where trade can be monitored much more closely), it has less than a quarter of the population of the USA (only 22 million people), shares no land borders with any nation, it has no internal weapons manufacturing, and is far less diverse in culture than that of the USA (which is still a huge issue as cultures still don't get along like they should).
They could easily strip gun rights away in Australia. It doesn't and never did have the gun culture that the USA does. It had one, but that was really the minority of the nation. As you said, the people welcomed it in Australia. They wouldn't welcome it here.
Comparing the USA to Australia is absolutely pointless.
Log in to comment