This topic is locked from further discussion.
i have never eaten fomeat though i do eat tofu sometimes, the only vegetarian qualities i might have is the occasional eating a head of cabbage like an apple. i do eat a lot of fruits and veggies and even grow some of my own even still fomeat just seems so wrong to me. surrealnumber5
[QUOTE="topgunmv"] Plants are living things too, just because you relate to them less than animals doesn't change that.WitchsightDo you really equate killing a pig to harvesting broccoli?
What makes a pig better than broccoli? Just because the broccoli can't walk around doesn't make it any less alive.
I didn't choose to be a vegetarian - it isn't some ideal I'm trying to live by or some morality - it's the natural response
Isn't it funny how most meat eaters wouldn't be able to kill their own food personally? - even that Jamie Oliver - when he killed that lamb with the knife he burst into tears & looked away whilst cutting it's neck
[QUOTE="surrealnumber5"]i have never eaten fomeat though i do eat tofu sometimes, the only vegetarian qualities i might have is the occasional eating a head of cabbage like an apple. i do eat a lot of fruits and veggies and even grow some of my own even still fomeat just seems so wrong to me. foxhound_fox
Do you really equate killing a pig to harvesting broccoli?[QUOTE="Witchsight"][QUOTE="topgunmv"] Plants are living things too, just because you relate to them less than animals doesn't change that.topgunmv
What makes a pig better than broccoli? Just because the broccoli can't walk around doesn't make it any less alive.
Oh no, this is like when my science teacher asked us to prove why fire wasnt alive because it needed oxygen... If the thought of death is like gravy to some people... i dunno how bright the future looks :(Isn't it funny how most meat eaters wouldn't be able to kill their own food personally? - even that Jamie Oliver - when he killed that lamb with the knife he burst into tears & looked away whilst cutting it's necksoren008
why do people separate fish from meat? you eat the flesh of bothWhy would I want to do that?
Fish and meat are scrumptious.
howlrunner13
[QUOTE="topgunmv"][QUOTE="Witchsight"] Do you really equate killing a pig to harvesting broccoli?Witchsight
What makes a pig better than broccoli? Just because the broccoli can't walk around doesn't make it any less alive.
Oh no, this is like when my science teacher asked us to prove why fire wasnt alive because it needed oxygen... If the thought of death is like gravy to some people... i dunno how bright the future looks :(Except broccoli is alive. It has cells. You eat it, and through it's death and consumption, you get energy. The supposition you're making is that intelligence makes one life form inherently better than another. Killing is killing, whether it walks on 4 legs and oinks or is powerless to stop you. Until humans can feed themselves by suntanning, we're all guilty.
The supposition you're making is that intelligence makes one life form inherently better than another.topgunmvThat sums things up nicely.
Oh no, this is like when my science teacher asked us to prove why fire wasnt alive because it needed oxygen... If the thought of death is like gravy to some people... i dunno how bright the future looks :([QUOTE="Witchsight"][QUOTE="topgunmv"]
What makes a pig better than broccoli? Just because the broccoli can't walk around doesn't make it any less alive.
topgunmv
Except broccoli is alive. It has cells. You eat it, and through it's death and consumption, you get energy. The supposition you're making is that intelligence makes one life form inherently better than another. Killing is killing, whether it walks on 4 legs and oinks or is powerless to stop you. Until humans can feed themselves by suntanning, we're all guilty.
youre only guilty if you think its wrong and do it.You're looking at it wrong. These meat eaters that you say couldn't kill their own food, well thats because they don't have to. If it was a choice between starving to death and killing an animal I for one would have no problem doing it.I didn't choose to be a vegetarian - it isn't some ideal I'm trying to live by or some morality - it's the natural response
Isn't it funny how most meat eaters wouldn't be able to kill their own food personally? - even that Jamie Oliver - when he killed that lamb with the knife he burst into tears & looked away whilst cutting it's neck
soren008
[QUOTE="soren008"]You're looking at it wrong. These meat eaters that you say couldn't kill their own food, well thats because they don't have to. If it was a choice between starving to death and killing an animal I for one would have no problem doing it. i wonder if sewer rat taste like pumpkin pieI didn't choose to be a vegetarian - it isn't some ideal I'm trying to live by or some morality - it's the natural response
Isn't it funny how most meat eaters wouldn't be able to kill their own food personally? - even that Jamie Oliver - when he killed that lamb with the knife he burst into tears & looked away whilst cutting it's neck
mtmatt
[QUOTE="soren008"]You're looking at it wrong. These meat eaters that you say couldn't kill their own food, well thats because they don't have to. If it was a choice between starving to death and killing an animal I for one would have no problem doing it.I didn't choose to be a vegetarian - it isn't some ideal I'm trying to live by or some morality - it's the natural response
Isn't it funny how most meat eaters wouldn't be able to kill their own food personally? - even that Jamie Oliver - when he killed that lamb with the knife he burst into tears & looked away whilst cutting it's neck
mtmatt
Well I don't know .. meat to most of us is just the flesh that's packaged in the supermarkets with catchy names
The other animals are just ideas in our heads - we don't recognize they breathe the same air as us - we think we are better than the other animals
It is not neccessary - leave them alone man :(
I'm not lying when I say that I find people who feel remorse for eating meat ridiculous... It's dead, what's the problem? You're not personally killing it and the only thing you're doing by not eating it is putting it to waste. The world has enough meat-eaters, meat will never be made obsolete. Just enjoy it, a good steak is one of the great pleasures of life, and I honestly don't see what's so wrong about it, animals are killed everyday by other animals.
You're looking at it wrong. These meat eaters that you say couldn't kill their own food, well thats because they don't have to. If it was a choice between starving to death and killing an animal I for one would have no problem doing it.[QUOTE="mtmatt"][QUOTE="soren008"]
I didn't choose to be a vegetarian - it isn't some ideal I'm trying to live by or some morality - it's the natural response
Isn't it funny how most meat eaters wouldn't be able to kill their own food personally? - even that Jamie Oliver - when he killed that lamb with the knife he burst into tears & looked away whilst cutting it's neck
soren008
Well I don't know .. meat to most of us is just the flesh that's packaged in the supermarkets with catchy names
The other animals are just ideas in our heads - we don't recognize they breathe the same air as us - we think we are better than the other animals
It is not neccessary - leave them alone man :(
I for one would have no trouble killing my own food..
You're looking at it wrong. These meat eaters that you say couldn't kill their own food, well thats because they don't have to. If it was a choice between starving to death and killing an animal I for one would have no problem doing it.[QUOTE="mtmatt"][QUOTE="soren008"]
I didn't choose to be a vegetarian - it isn't some ideal I'm trying to live by or some morality - it's the natural response
Isn't it funny how most meat eaters wouldn't be able to kill their own food personally? - even that Jamie Oliver - when he killed that lamb with the knife he burst into tears & looked away whilst cutting it's neck
soren008
Well I don't know .. meat to most of us is just the flesh that's packaged in the supermarkets with catchy names
The other animals are just ideas in our heads - we don't recognize they breathe the same air as us - we think we are better than the other animals
It is not neccessary - leave them alone man :(
It's not like they're enjoying their life big time standing there all day doing nothing...
You're looking at it wrong. These meat eaters that you say couldn't kill their own food, well thats because they don't have to. If it was a choice between starving to death and killing an animal I for one would have no problem doing it.[QUOTE="mtmatt"][QUOTE="soren008"]
I didn't choose to be a vegetarian - it isn't some ideal I'm trying to live by or some morality - it's the natural response
Isn't it funny how most meat eaters wouldn't be able to kill their own food personally? - even that Jamie Oliver - when he killed that lamb with the knife he burst into tears & looked away whilst cutting it's neck
soren008
Well I don't know .. meat to most of us is just the flesh that's packaged in the supermarkets with catchy names
The other animals are just ideas in our heads - we don't recognize they breathe the same air as us - we think we are better than the other animals
It is not neccessary - leave them alone man :(
I get what your saying but we were born with canine teeth for a reason.That sums things up nicely.[QUOTE="Witchsight"][QUOTE="topgunmv"] The supposition you're making is that intelligence makes one life form inherently better than another.topgunmv
And what's the reasoning behind that?
Necessity, or the lack thereof. I dont expect everone to think that pulling a leak off a tree is the same as dropping the hammer on a cow, you might be in the minority there, but about that i digress. At one point (and at some point in the future maybe) we simply had to hunt and kill animals who were doing the same for thier families. If at some point through In Vitro meat or any other scientific advancement we can get the same result without having to devote entire farm ranges to these animals, i dont see why it wouldnt be in our interest to persue it.[QUOTE="mtmatt"][QUOTE="soren008"]
I didn't choose to be a vegetarian - it isn't some ideal I'm trying to live by or some morality - it's the natural response
Isn't it funny how most meat eaters wouldn't be able to kill their own food personally? - even that Jamie Oliver - when he killed that lamb with the knife he burst into tears & looked away whilst cutting it's neck
You're looking at it wrong. These meat eaters that you say couldn't kill their own food, well thats because they don't have to. If it was a choice between starving to death and killing an animal I for one would have no problem doing it.Well I don't know .. meat to most of us is just the flesh that's packaged in the supermarkets with catchy names
The other animals are just ideas in our heads - we don't recognize they breathe the same air as us - we think we are better than the other animals
It is not neccessary - leave them alone man :(
So that they can what? Live life to the fullest and appreciate every moment of it? No. And they'll probably end up killing other animals before getting killed by one.[QUOTE="mtmatt"][QUOTE="soren008"]You're looking at it wrong. These meat eaters that you say couldn't kill their own food, well thats because they don't have to. If it was a choice between starving to death and killing an animal I for one would have no problem doing it. i wonder if sewer rat taste like pumpkin pieI just got done filming an episode with Andrew Zimmern for Bizarre Foods. I was his guide to surviving in the abandoned tunnels under New York. We both felt the sewer rat decidedly tasted like chicken.I didn't choose to be a vegetarian - it isn't some ideal I'm trying to live by or some morality - it's the natural response
Isn't it funny how most meat eaters wouldn't be able to kill their own food personally? - even that Jamie Oliver - when he killed that lamb with the knife he burst into tears & looked away whilst cutting it's neck
surrealnumber5
[QUOTE="surrealnumber5"][QUOTE="mtmatt"]You're looking at it wrong. These meat eaters that you say couldn't kill their own food, well thats because they don't have to. If it was a choice between starving to death and killing an animal I for one would have no problem doing it. mtmatti wonder if sewer rat taste like pumpkin pieI just got done filming an episode with Andrew Zimmern for Bizarre Foods. I was his guide to surviving in the abandoned tunnels under New York. We both felt the sewer rat decidedly tasted like chicken.
And you didn't save any for me!?!? :cry:
Entirely irrelevant. You assume vegans think it is immoral to eat meat under any circumstance. It comes down to necessity vs desire. We don't live in an environment where we need meat to live. If I was in the woods camping and I needed food, I would hunt.I would like to see a television reality series that places a bunch of vegans in the forest and tells them to survive on what they can find. Without energy from animal meat, they wouldn't last very long (considering carbs and lentils aren't available in the forest).
foxhound_fox
I was a vegetarian for at least 8 years. My dad was a vegetarian and cooked most of the time. So it was easy to not eat meat, if one wanted. Then I went on a trip to Europe. Once I reached Spain, I had to try the food. I was living with a woman who could cook. I haven't tried going back to vegetarianism since then.
You could justify countless behaviors of what humans were "meant" to do. People love to throw around the naturalistic fallacy whenever it pleases their needs. Tell me, if you are afflicted with a genetic disease, or perhaps an infection, would you take medication? If so you, are you not going against nature by depending on supplements instead of your immune system? If you had a genetic disease, would you not be going against nature by artificially sustaining yourself instead of succumbing to death and rooting out your bad genes? There's our interpretation of nature, which you are taking lightly and using it your needs, and there's nature in a sense of unavoidable instincts. One we have a choice, the other we don't. We have a choice in our diet.No, humans were meant to eat meat, and it's only because of the vast availability of food and supplements now that being a vegan/vegetarian is even an option.
topgunmv
[QUOTE="topgunmv"][QUOTE="Witchsight"] That sums things up nicely.Witchsight
And what's the reasoning behind that?
Necessity, or the lack thereof. I dont expect everone to think that pulling a leak off a tree is the same as dropping the hammer on a cow, you might be in the minority there, but about that i digress. At one point (and at some point in the future maybe) we simply had to hunt and kill animals who were doing the same for thier families. If at some point through In Vitro meat or any other scientific advancement we can get the same result without having to devote entire farm ranges to these animals, i dont see why it wouldnt be in our interest to persue it.I would think killing an entire cow would be more like killing an entire tree. And in such an example, I would actually consider a grown tree to be of more worth than a grown cow, considering how much good it does in terms of providing oxygen, a preventative measure against erosion via it's root system, and shelter to other animals. But I too digress.
To get more to the point, both agriculture and livestock are destructive to the environment.
Do you really equate killing a pig to harvesting broccoli?[QUOTE="Witchsight"][QUOTE="topgunmv"] Plants are living things too, just because you relate to them less than animals doesn't change that.topgunmv
What makes a pig better than broccoli? Just because the broccoli can't walk around doesn't make it any less alive.
I would tell you read an elementary biology book, but not even that would probably help you. A pig is sentient and broccoli is not. I'll leave it at that.[QUOTE="Xx_Hopeless_xX"]
I for one would have no trouble killing my own food..
soren008
I dunno manyboys say that kind of stuff- I don't believe you - but I believe you believe you :P
Perhaps if you knew me you would believe me...i have no reason to hide behind a facade on an internet forum..
So that they can what? Live life to the fullest and appreciate every moment of it? No. And they'll probably end up killing other animals before getting killed by one.Solid_Snake325
That was hilarious - you mean Pigs-Cows & Sheep - yep there a trouble some bunch those guys probably end up killing a bunch of endangered species just for kicks
Necessity, or the lack thereof. I dont expect everone to think that pulling a leak off a tree is the same as dropping the hammer on a cow, you might be in the minority there, but about that i digress. At one point (and at some point in the future maybe) we simply had to hunt and kill animals who were doing the same for thier families. If at some point through In Vitro meat or any other scientific advancement we can get the same result without having to devote entire farm ranges to these animals, i dont see why it wouldnt be in our interest to persue it.[QUOTE="Witchsight"][QUOTE="topgunmv"]
And what's the reasoning behind that?
topgunmv
I would think killing an entire cow would be more like killing an entire tree. And in such an example, I would actually consider a grown tree to be of more worth than a grown cow, considering how much good it does in terms of providing oxygen, a preventative measure against erosion via it's root system, and shelter to other animals. But I too digress.
To get more to the point, both agriculture and livestock are destructive to the environment.
man is the only real evil, in order to save the environment we must only consume the flesh of those who would destroy and harm our mother planet. am i in the right ballpark here or was that out of line?[QUOTE="Solid_Snake325"] So that they can what? Live life to the fullest and appreciate every moment of it? No. And they'll probably end up killing other animals before getting killed by one.soren008
That was hilarious - you mean Pigs-Cows & Sheep - yep there a trouble some bunch those guys probably end up killing a bunch of endangered species just for kicks
Yeah I didn't really think that through XD I was just trying to come up with an easy argument. But I don't think their lives would be of any value elsewhere.I've thought about it. I don't eat beef or pork but I do prefer to keep chicken and fish in my diet.
[QUOTE="topgunmv"][QUOTE="Witchsight"] Necessity, or the lack thereof. I dont expect everone to think that pulling a leak off a tree is the same as dropping the hammer on a cow, you might be in the minority there, but about that i digress. At one point (and at some point in the future maybe) we simply had to hunt and kill animals who were doing the same for thier families. If at some point through In Vitro meat or any other scientific advancement we can get the same result without having to devote entire farm ranges to these animals, i dont see why it wouldnt be in our interest to persue it.surrealnumber5
I would think killing an entire cow would be more like killing an entire tree. And in such an example, I would actually consider a grown tree to be of more worth than a grown cow, considering how much good it does in terms of providing oxygen, a preventative measure against erosion via it's root system, and shelter to other animals. But I too digress.
To get more to the point, both agriculture and livestock are destructive to the environment.
man is the only real evil, in order to save the environment we must only consume the flesh of those who would destroy and harm our mother planet. am i in the right ballpark here or was that out of line?Yes, we must all become cannibals.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment