How should Rapists be punished?

[QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]

They shouldn't be punished. The psychological torment of knowing that they were incapable of convincing a female to sleep with them is sufficient punishment.

TheArGaia

Their victims should be compensated by the state. It was the state that failed to recognize the social instability of the rapist and provide him/ her with the necessary counseling to deal with it.

[QUOTE="Radiatedrich91"]

[QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]

Why should a rapist be punished? They should be helped. They obviously have some sort of deficit when it comes to socializing. Being able to convince a member of the opposite sex to seek companionship in you is typical; not being able to do so is atypical and is a sign of some sort of personality or behavioral disorder. Disorders should not be punished; they should be treated and cured.

BluRayHiDef

While I agree that a rehab-based system would probably prevent rape better than a punishment-based system, not all rapists are unable to seek companionship; they'd RATHER rape victims against their will.

Well, considering the fact that it's easier to rape a woman, instead of tyring to get with her the normal way, rape is the most viable way of spreading your genes from an evolutionary standpoint.

[QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]

[QUOTE="Radiatedrich91"]

While I agree that a rehab-based system would probably prevent rape better than a punishment-based system, not all rapists are unable to seek companionship; they'd RATHER rape victims against their will.

CreasianDevaili

Well, considering the fact that it's easier to rape a woman, instead of tyring to get with her the normal way, rape is the most viable way of spreading your genes from an evolutionary standpoint.

Humans are animals. The difference between Humans and other creatures is one of degree, not type. Humans can do things to a better degree than animals,but there are very few things that we do exclusively. A lot of our behavior can be found in other species, such as Chimpanzees and Gorillas.

Very long time in prison under rehab process.

With a bullet to the head.

[QUOTE="CreasianDevaili"]

[QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]

Well, considering the fact that it's easier to rape a woman, instead of tyring to get with her the normal way, rape is the most viable way of spreading your genes from an evolutionary standpoint.

Humans are animals. The difference between Humans and other creatures is one of degree, not type. Humans can do things to a better degree than animals,but there are very few things that we do exclusively. A lot of our behavior can be found in other species, such as Chimpanzees and Gorillas.

An alternative solution would be to create a place called "Rape Land". Single female parents who have a hard time raising and providing for their kids could volunteer to live in "Rape Land" to serve as "victims". In exchange, the government would take care of their kids and provide them with the best care. Rapists could be sent to "Rape Land" to live out their wildest dreams without any fear of punishment. This way, society could be safe from the rapists. Problem solved.

BluRayHiDef

:o... you Serious?:lol:

An alternative solution would be to create a place called "Rape Land". Single female parents who have a hard time raising and providing for their kids could volunteer to live in "Rape Land" to serve as "victims". In exchange, the government would take care of their kids and provide them with the best care. Rapists could be sent to "Rape Land" to live out their wildest dreams without any fear of punishment. This way, society could be safe from the rapists. Problem solved.

BluRayHiDef

An alternative solution would be to create a place called "Rape Land". Single female parents who have a hard time raising and providing for their kids could volunteer to live in "Rape Land" to serve as "victims". In exchange, the government would take care of their kids and provide them with the best care. Rapists could be sent to "Rape Land" to live out their wildest dreams without any fear of punishment. This way, society could be safe from the rapists. Problem solved.

BluRayHiDef

An alternative solution would be to create a place called "Rape Land". Single female parents who have a hard time raising and providing for their kids could volunteer to live in "Rape Land" to serve as "victims". In exchange, the government would take care of their kids and provide them with the best care. Rapists could be sent to "Rape Land" to live out their wildest dreams without any fear of punishment. This way, society could be safe from the rapists. Problem solved.

BluRayHiDef

Genius.

[QUOTE="Radiatedrich91"]

[QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]

Why should a rapist be punished? They should be helped. They obviously have some sort of deficit when it comes to socializing. Being able to convince a member of the opposite sex to seek companionship in you is typical; not being able to do so is atypical and is a sign of some sort of personality or behavioral disorder. Disorders should not be punished; they should be treated and cured.

BluRayHiDef

While I agree that a rehab-based system would probably prevent rape better than a punishment-based system, not all rapists are unable to seek companionship; they'd RATHER rape victims against their will.

Well, considering the fact that it's easier to rape a woman, instead of tyring to get with her the normal way

um, no?

Cut their balls off.

An alternative solution would be to create a place called "Rape Land". Single female parents who have a hard time raising and providing for their kids could volunteer to live in "Rape Land" to serve as "victims". In exchange, the government would take care of their kids and provide them with the best care. Rapists could be sent to "Rape Land" to live out their wildest dreams without any fear of punishment. This way, society could be safe from the rapists. Problem solved.

BluRayHiDef

.

An alternative solution would be to create a place called "Rape Land". Single female parents who have a hard time raising and providing for their kids could volunteer to live in "Rape Land" to serve as "victims". In exchange, the government would take care of their kids and provide them with the best care. Rapists could be sent to "Rape Land" to live out their wildest dreams without any fear of punishment. This way, society could be safe from the rapists. Problem solved.

BluRayHiDef

[QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]

An alternative solution would be to create a place called "Rape Land". Single female parents who have a hard time raising and providing for their kids could volunteer to live in "Rape Land" to serve as "victims". In exchange, the government would take care of their kids and provide them with the best care. Rapists could be sent to "Rape Land" to live out their wildest dreams without any fear of punishment. This way, society could be safe from the rapists. Problem solved.

magicalclick

It had happened during WWII. Volunteer Taiwanes females were sent to Japanese army base to comfort the soldiers during WWII (at the time, Japan took over Taiwan if you are confused).

In "Rape Land", the volunteers would be given assignments to accommodate situations that simulate actual rapes. For example, every week they'd receive an itinerary telling them what streets to traverse and at what times. The rapists would traverse the streets of "Rape Land" and go searching for victims. I'm pretty sure that it wasn't done this way with the volunteer Taiwanese females during WWII.

Don't agree with Rape land but it would make for a great movie :lol:

[QUOTE="magicalclick"]

[QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]

An alternative solution would be to create a place called "Rape Land". Single female parents who have a hard time raising and providing for their kids could volunteer to live in "Rape Land" to serve as "victims". In exchange, the government would take care of their kids and provide them with the best care. Rapists could be sent to "Rape Land" to live out their wildest dreams without any fear of punishment. This way, society could be safe from the rapists. Problem solved.

BluRayHiDef

It had happened during WWII. Volunteer Taiwanes females were sent to Japanese army base to comfort the soldiers during WWII (at the time, Japan took over Taiwan if you are confused).

In "Rape Land", the volunteers would be given assignments to accommodate situations that simulate actual rapes. For example, every week they'd receive an itinerary telling them what streets to traverse and at what times. The rapists would traverse the streets of "Rape Land" and go searching for victims. I'm pretty sure that it wasn't done this way with the volunteer Taiwanese females during WWII.

Although I'm 95% sure you're just trolling at this point I'll respond.

How exactly would this cure the rapists ? It's just going to feed their hunger but it won't stop it, you need rehabilitation not rape simulation.

[QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]

[QUOTE="magicalclick"]

It had happened during WWII. Volunteer Taiwanes females were sent to Japanese army base to comfort the soldiers during WWII (at the time, Japan took over Taiwan if you are confused).

Sagem28

In "Rape Land", the volunteers would be given assignments to accommodate situations that simulate actual rapes. For example, every week they'd receive an itinerary telling them what streets to traverse and at what times. The rapists would traverse the streets of "Rape Land" and go searching for victims. I'm pretty sure that it wasn't done this way with the volunteer Taiwanese females during WWII.

Although I'm 95% sure you're just trolling at this point I'll respond.

How exactly would this cure the rapists ? It's just going to feed their hunger but it won't stop it, you need rehabilitation not rape simulation.

Some disorders can't be cured. Maybe the urge to rape is one of them. Also, I'm not trolling.

Assuming that the jury/judge is absolutely certain that that criminal comitted the crime, I think the death penalty should be used.If one of my family members was raped, I know that I would want the rapist to face the death penality, so I think it would be a double standard to desire a lesser penalty on a case of rape that involves a victim who's not one of my family members.

[QUOTE="Sagem28"]

[QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]

In "Rape Land", the volunteers would be given assignments to accommodate situations that simulate actual rapes. For example, every week they'd receive an itinerary telling them what streets to traverse and at what times. The rapists would traverse the streets of "Rape Land" and go searching for victims. I'm pretty sure that it wasn't done this way with the volunteer Taiwanese females during WWII.

BluRayHiDef

Although I'm 95% sure you're just trolling at this point I'll respond.

How exactly would this cure the rapists ? It's just going to feed their hunger but it won't stop it, you need rehabilitation not rape simulation.

Some disorders can't be cured. Maybe the urge to rape is one of them. Also, I'm not trolling.

So because MAYBE it can't be cured you're gonna give up on it altogether ? What you're suggesting is free prostitution. If the rapist gets some sick pleasure from rape, would he get it when the "victims" are willingly on "Rape Island" ? I don't think so. Otherwise it's just normal sex, only in a different environment.

I voted "Other" because I believe that it depends on the severity of the rape; such as the amount of violence used, the age of the victim, how many times the rape was repeated etc. I don't believe that a frat boy who has sex with a drunken college girl should get the same penalty as an older man who rapes a 5 year old. Again, it just depends on the severity of the rape.

I think they should spend a short amount of time in an asylum. They should speak to professional psychologists, because a man who raped a girl or woman obviously has some mental issues. Afterwards they should spend some in jail for the charges of rape. Thats just my opinion though.

First/second time, jail. Third strike, execution.

First/second time, jail. Third strike, execution.

stevoqwerty

[QUOTE="stevoqwerty"]

First/second time, jail. Third strike, execution.

Crimsader

Hmm... shoot on the spot?

good point to poster above me,

But who in the name of the lord voted let em off scott free?

sonofsmeagle

Chemical castration is an option.

However its a difficult crime to judge as it has many levels of severity. it can also be difficult to prove as its often one persons word against another.

It can also be easily exploited.

Why should a rapist be punished? They should be helped. They obviously have some sort of deficit when it comes to socializing. Being able to convince a member of the opposite sex to seek companionship in you is typical; not being able to do so is atypical and is a sign of some sort of personality or behavioral disorder. Disorders should not be punished; they should be treated and cured.

BluRayHiDef

Not everyone is curable. Some people cannot be helped.

Rapist SHOULD BE PUNISHED. You are dellusional if you think they are curable and not giving them a crime sentence will help.

With that argument, murderers should not be punished since they need help...

[QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]

Why should a rapist be punished? They should be helped. They obviously have some sort of deficit when it comes to socializing. Being able to convince a member of the opposite sex to seek companionship in you is typical; not being able to do so is atypical and is a sign of some sort of personality or behavioral disorder. Disorders should not be punished; they should be treated and cured.

Omni-Wrath

Not everyone is curable. Some people cannot be helped.

Rapist SHOULD BE PUNISHED. You are dellusional if you think they are curable and not giving them a crime sentence will help.

With that argument, murderers should not be punished since they need help...

[QUOTE="BluRayHiDef"]

An alternative solution would be to create a place called "Rape Land". Single female parents who have a hard time raising and providing for their kids could volunteer to live in "Rape Land" to serve as "victims". In exchange, the government would take care of their kids and provide them with the best care. Rapists could be sent to "Rape Land" to live out their wildest dreams without any fear of punishment. This way, society could be safe from the rapists. Problem solved.

Swift_Boss_A

:o... you Serious?:lol:

"Disarm" them, so they can't use the "weapon" anymore, if you know what I mean.

Rapist is quite broad.. Do you realize that having sex with a drunk person can be considered rape? Because their ability to consent is impaired meaning they are unable to?.. And what about statutory rape in which the offender is in fact only a few years older than the supposed victim at best? sSubZerOo

Castration.CptJSparrow

You know women can be charged with rape too, right?

[QUOTE="CptJSparrow"]Castration.sSubZerOo

You know women can be charged with rape too, right?