Where the heck is Kung Fu Panda!?gigatrainerwere it belongs...........off the list. thats the only thing they got rite
This topic is locked from further discussion.
[size=11]Terrible list... Beauty and the Beast is the best animated film of all time? :| [/size]msudude211
Yeah thats bad, and I hate Iron Giant. Once in 2003 thir were showing a nonstop marathon of Iron Giant for 24 hours! It was so boring!
were it belongs...........off the list. thats the only thing they got rite Kung Fu Panda was certainly a movie that shouldn't even be in the top 100. Good (or decent) movie it may have been, but it can't lay a finger on The Lion King, and that didn't even get to the top 5.[QUOTE="gigatrainer"]Where the heck is Kung Fu Panda!?x8VXU6
Well, they can. It is fair enough, I think critical and general opinion of the movies was on par. It probably depends on whether you prefer the originality of the original, or the extent to which Toy Story 2 expanded on the qualities of the original and really did bring in some new, well-executed ideas.How can they say that Toy Story 2 is better than the first Toy Story?!
MrBubbles59
Probably because Pixar has made better films? Yep thats itthat is a pretty terrible list actually. Way too much pixar and not enough oldschool disney.
dissonantblack
were it belongs...........off the list. thats the only thing they got rite[QUOTE="gigatrainer"]Where the heck is Kung Fu Panda!?x8VXU6
that movie was awesome :)
Alot of Pixar movies on that list. Wall-E is definitely my favorite animated movie of all time.Jd1680a
mine too
But that list was weird, some should'nt have been there - like all 3 toy stories on the list is unacceptable... Where's Paprika and Akria should be in top 10, you don't speak of anime unless you've seen Akira.
[QUOTE="Jd1680a"]Alot of Pixar movies on that list. Wall-E is definitely my favorite animated movie of all time.AtlanticRock
mine too
But that list was weird, some should'nt have been there - like all 3 toy stories on the list is unacceptable... Where's Paprika and Akria should be in top 10, you don't speak of anime unless you've seen Akira.
Being someone who has seen Akira I would never want to see it in the top 10.Having seen Akira I don't think it belongs anywhere near the top 25.DJ_LaeIn that case I would extend it to the top 50.
[QUOTE="Laserwolf65"][QUOTE="cd_rom"]Why is it whenever someone releases a list of top whatever, someone always says it's the worst list ever? Does that mean that every list is consistently worse than the last? If I made a list of the worst lists ever made, would #1 be the list that I was making?cd_romto be fair i said it was ONE of their worst lists ever. I just find it odd that people complain heavily about lists when it's a purely subjective topic. For that matter, I get extremely annoyed when websites like IGN try to pass this stuff off as factual news. The reason they make these list is for the reaction... Not everyone is going to have a good reaction.
Some of those are good choices. If some of you disagree with IGN's choices have a look at my top 25 and see if you disagree with that:P
1. Watership down
2. Princess mononoke
3. Triplets of belleville
4. Whisper of the heart
5. Plague dogs
6. Persepolis
7. Sita sings the blues
8. Paprika
9. Tokyo godfathers
10. Mary and max
11. Waltz with bashir
12. The Iron giant
13. South park: Bigger, longer, and uncut
14. Fantasia
15. Spirited away
16. A Scanner darkly
17. Grave of the fireflies
18. Milemmium actress
19. Barefoot gen
20. The Girl who leapt through time
21. 5 Centimenters per second
22. Sword of the stranger
23. When the wind blows
24. An American tail
25. Chicken run
were it belongs...........off the list. thats the only thing they got rite[QUOTE="x8VXU6"]
[QUOTE="gigatrainer"]Where the heck is Kung Fu Panda!?munchlax99
that movie was awesome :)
Agreed, I found it way better than The Incredibles.I feel that it limited itself to only kid-oriented animation films and Anime, not a bad thing, but I felt that made it missing out on a few greats. The adding of South Park was pretty funny to me. I still wish that these kinds of lists stopped neglecting The Adventures of Prince Achmed.
Jazz_Fan
I just looked up Prince Achmed. Why didnt you tell me about this film earlier you butt:evil:
[QUOTE="Phoenix534"]
[QUOTE="Wolf-Man2006"]
Where is Princess Mononoke?
SgtKevali
I know! WTF?
This. That movie was great.
The only environmental film I ever liked. (Avatar being included in the classification.)Incidentally, I believe IGN did a similar list a while ago and made choices that more people on this forum were likely to agree with. I wonder what happened to that . . .deepdreamer256They basically re-wrote the article to be up-to-date the original was done in 2007, here is the old list that I found on another forum. [QUOTE="Old IGN List"] 25. Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within 24. Pinocchio 23. Bambi 22. Princess Mononoke 21. Fantasia 20. Monsters, Inc. 19. Metropolis 18. Charlotte's Web 17. Transformers: The Movie 16. Grave of the Fireflies 15. Dumbo 14. Shrek 13. The Lion King 12. Toy Story 11. The Little Mermaid 10. Beauty and the Beast 9. Aladdin 8. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs 7. The Incredibles 6. Spirited Away 5. The Nightmare Before Christmas 4. Finding Nemo 3. South Park: Bigger, Longer and Uncut 2. Iron Giant 1. Toy Story 2 Still have South Park on :s
[QUOTE="deepdreamer256"]Incidentally, I believe IGN did a similar list a while ago and made choices that more people on this forum were likely to agree with. I wonder what happened to that . . .heselThey basically re-wrote the article to be up-to-date the original was done in 2007, here is the old list that I found on another forum. [QUOTE="Old IGN List"] 25. Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within 24. Pinocchio 23. Bambi 22. Princess Mononoke 21. Fantasia 20. Monsters, Inc. 19. Metropolis 18. Charlotte's Web 17. Transformers: The Movie 16. Grave of the Fireflies 15. Dumbo 14. Shrek 13. The Lion King 12. Toy Story 11. The Little Mermaid 10. Beauty and the Beast 9. Aladdin 8. Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs 7. The Incredibles 6. Spirited Away 5. The Nightmare Before Christmas 4. Finding Nemo 3. South Park: Bigger, Longer and Uncut 2. Iron Giant 1. Toy Story 2 Still have South Park on :s Oh well, that list was slightly worse than I thought then.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment