Russia turns off Europes Gas

[QUOTE="snakes_codec"]in my experience Scots don't want independents they just want a bigger say a referendum wont be successful as most Scots only voted SNP because of there was no one else to vote for.BurnsOfRage

[QUOTE="BurnsOfRage"][QUOTE="snakes_codec"]in my experience Scots don't want independents they just want a bigger say a referendum wont be successful as most Scots only voted SNP because of there was no one else to vote for.Ninja-Hippo

exactly

[QUOTE="Ninja-Hippo"][QUOTE="BurnsOfRage"] Lib dems had power sharing in Scotland and have always been a stronger alternative.. the recent election of the SNP is because of a shift in public opinion... As you can see from the above post I am from Scotland and live in Scotland. It is also my privilege to work with people from all walks of life, and while there is a lot of disagreement about how Scotland should become independent there is general agreement that it should be. snakes_codec

exactly

Also the poll I provided asks the direct question of pulling out of the union.. your one did not.BurnsOfRage

Cool agree to disagree.. but my survey didnt have a loaded question ? dont know where that came from.BurnsOfRage

[QUOTE="Ninja-Hippo"]Um, no. I'm not even scottish and i appear to know more about this than you do. It wasn't a long time ago, it was april of last year. Do you mean to say national opinion has completely changed in that time? "1 in 5 people said they desired scottish independence." http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/alan_cochrane/blog/2008/04/30/scotland_doesnt_want_independence The desire for independence is shared by the majority, you say? :| If scotland where independent, you'd face a social crisis. It's one of the slowest economies in the world.BurnsOfRage

this is a wasted argument if we are going into who economics pure and simply your argument doesn't have a leg to stand on the only sector of the British Economy that makes money theses days is the service sector witch is for the most part based out of London add that with the Population differences where Scotland only has around 4 million people living there England has close to 60 million and rising fast in terms of money the English generate more money into the Economy then Scotland Wales & Norther Ireland twice over .

where Scotland only has around 4 million people living there England has close to 60 million and rising fast in terms of money the English generate more money into the Economy then Scotland Wales Norther Ireland twice over .snakes_codec