who do you think is the most overrated filmmaker?

[QUOTE="iwilson1296"]

Peter Jackson

this

You have to cut Jackson some slack. I think he's just trying to find his footing after LoTR. Those films made people expect way too much of him.

You have to cut Jackson some slack. I think he's just trying to find his footing after LoTR. Those films made people expect way too much of him.

MarioRPGer

[QUOTE="raven_squad"][QUOTE="kidsmelly"]

this

Aspen706

You have to cut Jackson some slack. I think he's just trying to find his footing after LoTR. Those films made people expect way too much of him.

[QUOTE="raven_squad"][QUOTE="MarioRPGer"]

You have to cut Jackson some slack. I think he's just trying to find his footing after LoTR. Those films made people expect way too much of him.

MarioRPGer

[QUOTE="MarioRPGer"][QUOTE="raven_squad"] I didn't like those either. :(Aspen706

[QUOTE="Aspen706"][QUOTE="MarioRPGer"] Me neither, but most people did and lets face it buddy, we are not most people. :PMarioRPGer

Clint Eastwood
Quentin Tarantino
Alfonso Cuaron (don't hate me)

sammyjenkis898

To be honest, Alfonso Cuaron was the last person I'd expect to see listed in this thread. Overrated, you know, any director considered to be good has at least a few memorable movie sunder his/her belt, so it's hard to think of any that revieve undeserving praise.

Im_single

Clint Eastwood.

This man

JK :P

Tim Burton or James Cameron

M. Night...

[QUOTE="MarioRPGer"][QUOTE="Aspen706"] The LOTR movies used to be some of my faves but when i try to watch them now their not watchable.raven_squad

The movie wouldn't make sense if it was shorter.

James Cameron. Praised for Avatar, Titanic and Aliens... but everyone seems to forget about the massive turd that was True Lies. I personally haven't really liked any of his films besides the Alien films, and find his epic level praise to be mind-boggling and suffocating sometimes. He isn't brilliant... just a step above Michael Bay.

Quentin Tarantinojuden41

Michael Bay

Steven Spielberg

Peter Jackson

Tim Burton

All those used to be good directors now they suck, except for Michael Bay, he always sucked.

Steven Spielberg kuraimen

[QUOTE="kuraimen"] Steven Spielberg MrEnvelope

I don't think any movie director is over-rated, I've seen a lot of people get excited for movies because of the director but it's rare that you see someone try to defend that movie if it comes out and turns out to be crap. Like I love Robert Rodriguez but if Predators comes out and is crap I'm not going to defend it just because I like the director. Most people will agree that George Lucas hasn't had a great film since the original Star Wars trilogy.bobbetybob

Well Robert Rodriguez isn't directing Predators so you don't have to worry about that:P

[QUOTE="bobbetybob"]I don't think any movie director is over-rated, I've seen a lot of people get excited for movies because of the director but it's rare that you see someone try to defend that movie if it comes out and turns out to be crap. Like I love Robert Rodriguez but if Predators comes out and is crap I'm not going to defend it just because I like the director. Most people will agree that George Lucas hasn't had a great film since the original Star Wars trilogy.Film-Guy

Well Robert Rodriguez isn't directing Predators so you don't have to worry about that:P

[QUOTE="bobbetybob"]I don't think any movie director is over-rated, I've seen a lot of people get excited for movies because of the director but it's rare that you see someone try to defend that movie if it comes out and turns out to be crap. Like I love Robert Rodriguez but if Predators comes out and is crap I'm not going to defend it just because I like the director. Most people will agree that George Lucas hasn't had a great film since the original Star Wars trilogy.Film-Guy

Well Robert Rodriguez isn't directing Predators so you don't have to worry about that:P

You doubt Miyazaki, this means war

:P

Though I think James Cameron

Peter Jackson

how he does not share at least some of the criticism Michael Bay gets is beyond me.

[QUOTE="MrEnvelope"][QUOTE="Rhazakna"] They are. Memento was perhaps the most gimmicky movie I've ever seen,imaps3fanboy

Tim Burtonmarkop2003

Peter Jackson

how he does not share at least some of the criticism Michael Bay gets is beyond me.

mrbojangles25

James Cameron, James Cameron and again I say...James Cameron...

[QUOTE="imaps3fanboy"][QUOTE="MrEnvelope"] The Prestige was way too much and I don't want to start with The Dark Knight. His movies aren't bad, it's just that they are way to gimmicky. :)yourmajesty90

I disliked the fact that he tried to implement those "deep" monologues and I really disliked those long Michael Caine speeches. Seriously every time he opened his mouth he gave a long speech about the psychology of Batman. One more thing, the running time was just ridiculous, way to long for so little plot. :

James Cameron and Michael Bay.

Uwe boll!imaps3fanboy

[QUOTE="mrbojangles25"]

Peter Jackson

how he does not share at least some of the criticism Michael Bay gets is beyond me.

jubino

Not any more

*swearing

Everytime there is a thread which includes criticizing it turns into a hot topic!

People just love to be Critic'S!

As a matter of fact, so do i (sometimes) ;)

[QUOTE="yourmajesty90"]

[QUOTE="imaps3fanboy"] Dark knight was terrible.. imoMrEnvelope

I disliked the fact that he tried to implement those "deep" monologues and I really disliked those long Michael Caine speeches. Seriously every time he opened his mouth he gave a long speech about the psychology of Batman. One more thing, the running time was just ridiculous, way to long for so little plot. :

I need to add the fact that people are like: "OMG THE DARK KNIGHT BEST FILM EV4H!!!1! THE JOKER BEST CHARACTER EVAH!!!!" His performance was good, still prefer Jack Nicholson's. I know Heath Ledger is dead, fact is that his passing away made the film more hyped.

James Cameron and Michael Bay.

Brawl578

[QUOTE="Brawl578"]

James Cameron and Michael Bay.

ShAbInAtOr