Who would win: Gandalf and Dumbledore?

Gandalf for sure. Basically in the Tolkien's world Gandalf isn't even a wizard he isan Angel and he doesn't do magic he performs miracles (yes that is splitting hairs)so this isn't a fair fight to begin with.

Gandalf... he killed a Balrog and came back from the dead, and if I remember correctly from the book **spoiler** killed the Witch King.

Dumbledore... just throwing that in for lols

Gandalf... he killed a Balrog and came back from the dead, and if I remember correctly from the book **spoiler** killed the Witch King.

Dumbledore... just throwing that in for lols

gamer_10001

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"][QUOTE="Teenaged"]Frodo has the Ring and huge blue eyes.

Harry would fall in love with him.... :P

Theokhoth

And then Frodo will throw the Ring into Mount Doom anyway, because he's just that badass.

If he was truly badass he would have just flown an eagle over Mt. Doom and just dropped the ring into it while giving the Great Eye the Great Finger, while yelling "Yippey-Kai-Ay-Mother-***"

Oh yeah, and Frodo also has Sting.

[QUOTE="Theokhoth"]

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"] and he could be all like "Yo, Sauron. If you don't kill Harry, I'll throw this ring in Mount Doom" Sauron will kill Harry! :xgamer_10001

And then Frodo will throw the Ring into Mount Doom anyway, because he's just that badass.

If he was truly badass he would have just flown an eagle over Mt. Doom and just dropped the ring into it while giving the Great Eye the Great Finger, while yelling "Yippey-Kai-Ay-Mother-***"

Oh yeah, and Frodo also has Sting.

Oh well many people have expressed this. :P

[QUOTE="gamer_10001"]

Gandalf... he killed a Balrog and came back from the dead, and if I remember correctly from the book **spoiler** killed the Witch King.

Dumbledore... just throwing that in for lols

Teenaged

Looked it up, he just prevents him from entering the city... haven't read the books in a long time.

Any self respecting person would say Gandalf. Probably because Harry Potter is the worst series ever. EXCEPTION: Twilight.

albus would win he is cleverer than that average person so he will find a way

We need to get Deadliest Warrior to solve our problems here :)

Predicted result:

Gandalf: 786

Dumbledore: 214

albus would win he is cleverer than that average person so he will find a way

muller39

Gandalf.

What ironic is that South Park is playing a Lord of the Rings thing. And there Harry Potter kids and Lord of the Rings kids.

Any self respecting person would say Gandalf. Probably because Harry Potter is the worst series ever. EXCEPTION: Twilight.

cubeCAT13

Actually, I've found something worse than Twilight (possible? Apparently so).

What's bad about it? Read the one-star reviews.

Vampires that sparkle are nothing compared to Angels with laboratories.

Gandalf.........as others have said he killed a Balrog which is a fallen maia, so Gandalf pretty much killed a fallen angel............What's Dumbeldore again? oh yeah,just a man.

Any self respecting person would say Gandalf. Probably because Harry Potter is the worst series ever. EXCEPTION: Twilight.

cubeCAT13

Gandalf because he's a classic wizard.

[spoiler] and because he didn't die when someone threw a spell at him. [/spoiler]