[QUOTE="dhyce"]
[QUOTE="magnax1"]
Conclusions lead to a belief. So you either have not concluded and Don't believe in anything, or have concluded that you believe there is no god. There is no other category other then belief in God. Who really cares what the definition is? It doesn't matter what I'm saying is that you can't not have a lack of belief and not be in the category of what people generally call agnostic whether or not its the dictionary definiton of agnostic or not.
magnax1
Stop failing at language. A belief in the context you mean it is not identical to the conclusion I am representing. The belief you mean is something unsubstantiated, faith-based. A religious belief is not a logical conclusion based on tangible evidence and all that is known of the physical world. A 'belief' does not mean what you want it to mean, it does not equate to atheism's implication. As I've said, countless dictionary entries I'll be happy to post oppose your claim.
Agnosticism is a belief that god is unknowable.
Atheism is a lack of any theistic beliefs. Strong atheists say there is no god, this is only because no evidence to the contrary is presented. OBVIOUSLY if this was not the case, all atheists would change their position. I am a strong atheist, I say there is no god and to say it's a belief would be laughed at in a scientific realm. The evidence points this way, plainly, clearly. I have no belief in any deities, so . . . I believe there are no deities? No, let me refer you back to a previous point: if not believing in god is a belief, then not collecting stamps is a hobby. Your reasoning is flawed.
What I am saying, for the ten thousandth time is that you are either agnostic, atheist or theist. If you are saying that agnostic is a belief that god is unknowable, and atheism is a lack of belief (which is really what agnostic is) then there is a fourth category. Also what Im saying is these stupid dictionary definitions don't matter. I'm saying by societies definition you are agnostic, if you don't want to be called agnostic, you'll have to get over it because thats what people call it.
So
if you have no beliefs you are agnostic
if you believe there is no god you are atheist
if you believe there is a god you are theist
Isn't that simple enough?
Eh, I've been doing some research into the definitions of the words themselves, and it appears that some definitions of atheism state that it is a braoder term used to describe one who does not believe in a diety. Oxford still exclusively define atheism as the belief in the lack of a diety. Agnostic is unquestionabley defined as the lack of belief in a higher power or a belief in the lack thereof.
Log in to comment