[QUOTE="Brendissimo35"][QUOTE="Nibroc420"] Do you honestly think that if people went out and remade the EXACT game with better graphics, using Valve's new engine. That Valve wont go "Wait... hold on." and they'll just let it slide? Oooh, there goes... All of HL's potential sales, however small they may be. Not going to happen, Valve wont let this go... I bet that they just expect this mod to crash and burn, then valve can come along and make it.Nibroc420
We'll have to wait and see who's right, of course, but I've never known valve to act in that fashion, and such an act would be an unprecedented act of aggression towards modders everywhere from a very mod friendly dev. It wouldn't make sense on any level for valve to pull such a stunt.
So you're saying if i rewrote WoW's code, then re-released it under "Land of Warcraft" and charged $5 a month instead of $15 a month. That Blizzard wont/shouldn't go "Wait, what do you think you're doing?" the makers of Black Mesa, Stole the Storyline, and all Valve's ideas from the first halflife, which Valve still sells today.. then using Valve's engine, they remade it and they're re-releasing it? Thats direct competition, and stealing of intellectual property. It's like if you took your old Tapes, put all the songs onto a CD(the new format) and gave them away... People own those songs. Just like Valve owns Half life.First off, remaking an old game as a new one in a new engine as a mod is NOT a new phenomenon. I can only assume those who think otherwise are new to modding. Furthermore, if you charge money for a mod, it's not a mod anymore, by definition. So yes, blizzard would be pissed if you charged $5 a month for a WoW mod because it would be ILLEGAL.
Edit:
BM uses entirely new assets for most everything in the game. Sounds, models, textures, even voice acting. This is work they did for free, and it is high quality. However, even if a mod only changes minor portions of a game, it is completely legal and encouraged by most good devs as long as it is free and requires the original game to run.
Log in to comment