Okay, I see what you mean. Yeah, the Yuan/Mongols wiped the floor with the Japanese samurai at Tsushima and Iki before the kamikaze storm. However, the game does show the Mongols initially defeating the Japanese at Tsushima. So not sure where the historical inaccuracy is?
The inaccuracy comes with the resistance being the reason why they kicked them off the island instead of the invasion of Japan itself being a failure. The Khan character in the game is total fiction as well.
So they don't show the kamikaze storm later in the game? If not, then that would be historically inaccurate. The only reason the Mongol invasion failed is because Yuan ships got wrecked by the storms, not because of effective Japanese resistance. The samurai were still in their infancy at the time, so they were no match for an experienced Mongol horde that had conquered most of Eurasia. If it wasn't for the kamikaze storms, Japanese history would've turned out very different.
That's not true.
Japanese repelled the Mongol invasions in two key battles:the Battle of Bun'ei (1274) and the Battle of Kōan (1281)
They Samurai defeated them and sent them back to their ships that got wiped out by a storm. If the samurai resistance was a failure there would have been no need for the Mongols to retreat back to their ships.
The English Wikipedia articles aren't citing reliable sources and are only giving one side of the story (the Japanese perspective). In contrast, the Japanese Wikipedia articles on those same campaigns are citing reliable sources and, ironically, giving both the Japanese and Mongol sides of the story:
According to Chinese sources documenting the Mongol/Yuan perspective, the main reason the Mongols retreated was because they came poorly prepared and ran out of arrows, so they retreated to stockpile on arrows before storms wrecked their ships.
According to Japanese sources, samurai ambushed the Mongols and that forced the Mongols to retreat back to their ships where kamikaze storms wrecked their ships.
It's up to you guys which side of the story to believe (kind of like the Akira Kurosawa movie Rashomon). But I'm more inclined to believe the Mongol/Chinese side of the story. After all, we're talking about an experienced Mongol army that conquered most of Eurasia from Korea to Poland. And 13th-century samurai weren't as experienced or well-equipped as later samurai of the 16th and 17th centuries.
Or maybe both sides of the story are true. It could be the case that the Mongols running out of arrows is the reason the samurai were able to give some pushback to the Mongols prior to the kamikaze storm.
Log in to comment