Bioshock - 9. Pirme 3 - 8.5. Killzone 2 - O_O

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation. Halo 3 doesn't look leaps and bounds better than Bioshock, and it certainly isn't more original than either Bioshock or Prime 3.

But if Halo 3 runs the risk of receiving a less than perfect score, why do Cows think that the non-awaited sequel to the miserable Killzone has a chance ?

Individually Bioshock and Prime 3 have scored more show awards than Killzone 2 multiplied by the number Final Fantasy rehashes released by Square Enix. Additionally Killzone 2's Halo Killer status has not been proved by the mediocre tactical strategy spin-off Killzone: Liberation. You would have mad cow disease to think that Killzone 2 stands a chance of scoring AA now.

Metroid Prime and Halo are basically two of the most powerful pedigrees around.

For both of them to flop (and we are half way there) basically gives no game a hope in high hell of getting AAA.

Punishing games for being sequels is just ridiculous.

I don't think it matters anymore what a 360 game scores. If it gets below 9 it's a flop and got what it deserved, if it gets an AAA score then it's overrated.

Jealous fanboys take all the fun out of SW by inundating the boards with cries of Lemmingspot and Overrated. Where they should be saying congrats, we got owned, the 360 has another AAA game to its tally.

Also the double standards are appauling. A few people posted against the score given to Bioshock, but yet you could almost feel the tears when Zelda TP, MP3 and Resistance flopped at GS.

People should just leave SW if they don't agree with GS reviews and SW rules on Flop or Not.

As for KZ2, I think it will be AAA and may even get a 9.5 score. It looks faultless.

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation.

Lilac_Benjie

I stopped reading here.

What was original about MP3?

[QUOTE="Lilac_Benjie"]

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation.

AcidTWister

I stopped reading here.

What was original about MP3?

It makes duel analog seem inferior to the wii remote?

[QUOTE="Lilac_Benjie"]

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation.

AcidTWister

I stopped reading here.

What was original about MP3?

Exactly what I was thinking... MP3 didn't really add anything new to the Metroid Prime trilogy besides new controls.

It'll get a solid 8 to 8.5 , imo.

I've seen the KZ2, vidoes and it doesnt look as Epic as Halo or can intense as Cod4.Just seems like a normal, albeit extremely pretty shooter.

I don't think it matters anymore what a 360 game scores. If it gets below 9 it's a flop and got what it deserved, if it gets an AAA score then it's overrated.

Jealous fanboys take all the fun out of SW by inundating the boards with cries of Lemmingspot and Overrated. Where they should be saying congrats, we got owned, the 360 has another AAA game to its tally.

Also the double standards are appauling. A few people posted against the score given to Bioshock, but yet you could almost feel the tears when Zelda TP, MP3 and Resistance flopped at GS.

People should just leave SW if they don't agree with GS reviews and SW rules on Flop or Not.

SgtWhiskeyjack

I totally agree. All this whining is getting pathetic. If Halo 3 scores AAA all anti-360 fanboys will be screaming over rated and lem spot, etc... If it scores below, the slaughter here will be silly. It is SW and all, but how about some responsibility? Too hard?

[QUOTE="Lilac_Benjie"]

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation.

AcidTWister

I stopped reading here.

What was original about MP3?

Amen to that.

[QUOTE="AcidTWister"][QUOTE="Lilac_Benjie"]

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation.

Shazenab

I stopped reading here.

What was original about MP3?

It makes duel analog seem inferior to the wii remote?

MP didn't really have an option to use one or the other, light gun games aren't original either. Sure it has free movement unlike most light gun games, but it really isn't new.

[QUOTE="Shazenab"][QUOTE="AcidTWister"][QUOTE="Lilac_Benjie"]

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation.

spinecaton

I stopped reading here.

What was original about MP3?

It makes duel analog seem inferior to the wii remote?

MP didn't really have an option to use one or the other, light gun games aren't original either. Sure it has free movement unlike most light gun games, but it really isn't new.

that's a bit unfair, just because the wii-mote is a pointer like a lightgun it doesn't mean its the same. I meant in terms of accuracy and turning speed anyway. the game in itself doesn't do anything new (in terms of a brand spanking new feature)though, I agree with that.

Metroid Prime and Halo are basically two of the most powerful pedigrees around.

For both of them to flop (and we are half way there) basically gives no game a hope in high hell of getting AAA.

Punishing games for being sequels is just ridiculous.

KirbyFan10101

wow this is such a stupid thread. are you saying there will not be a better game than bioshock this gen. if so this gen is over. lol how pathedict. i guess we all should stop gaming or just play bioshock until next gen. metriod prime got a 8.5 because the controls made the game feel to easy and no challenge. omg bioshock got a 9 now killzone has no chance lol at you.GARRYTH

No, what's pathetic here is your grammar. Anyway, I agree with the topic starter. If games like Bio-Shock and Halo 3 don't score high AAA, what makes you think crap like killzone will? :lol:

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation. Halo 3 doesn't look leaps and bounds better than Bioshock, and it certainly isn't more original than either Bioshock or Prime 3.

But if Halo 3 runs the risk of receiving a less than perfect score, why do Cows think that the non-awaited sequel to the miserable Killzone has a chance ?

Individually Bioshock and Prime 3 have scored more show awards than Killzone 2 multiplied by the number Final Fantasy rehashes released by Square Enix. Additionally Killzone 2's Halo Killer status has not been proved by the mediocre tactical strategy spin-off Killzone: Liberation. You would have mad cow disease to think that Killzone 2 stands a chance of scoring AA now.

Lilac_Benjie

[QUOTE="AcidTWister"][QUOTE="Lilac_Benjie"]

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation.

spinecaton

I stopped reading here.

What was original about MP3?

Exactly what I was thinking... MP3 didn't really add anything new to the Metroid Prime trilogy besides new controls.

There'sahellofalotmoreoriginalityinMP3thanHalo.

after GS prime review the world has been laughing at it while everywhere alse gave it nines and editors choice the gave it a 8.5 for being to easy and being a sequel this is ridiculus to the point where i want to leve GS cuz they are so biased against the wii.wiirdawgs

Play it first and see if it is too easy or you are getting your backside handed to you, and then slag GS off. Also remember, gamers play games to escape and have fun, reviewers scrutinise a game to look at what's good and what's bad.

[QUOTE="Lilac_Benjie"]

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation. Halo 3 doesn't look leaps and bounds better than Bioshock, and it certainly isn't more original than either Bioshock or Prime 3.

But if Halo 3 runs the risk of receiving a less than perfect score, why do Cows think that the non-awaited sequel to the miserable Killzone has a chance ?

Individually Bioshock and Prime 3 have scored more show awards than Killzone 2 multiplied by the number Final Fantasy rehashes released by Square Enix. Additionally Killzone 2's Halo Killer status has not been proved by the mediocre tactical strategy spin-off Killzone: Liberation. You would have mad cow disease to think that Killzone 2 stands a chance of scoring AA now.

SiiSsy

1. You do NOT have a crystalball.

2. Latest Halo3 vids blew my mind and the funny thing is... I HATE Halo, confusing I know:P

3. MP3 flopped, MOVE ON!

4. All your threads are basically the same thing.

5. Dont try take everyone's attention away from MP3's floppage by making useless threads about PS3 games(other sheep are doing this to and it's PATHETIC.)

You know what's funny? when Wii/360 games flop the PS3 get's bashed:lol:

Killzone 2 will score 7.9 and thats too much.-wii60-

Have you played the game? Didnt think so, so how in the hell can you give it a score? Go away fanboy, just go away. And btw it will be either 8.0 or 7.5 here by what you are saying.

i think KZ2 will end up AA.

[QUOTE="Lilac_Benjie"]

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation. Halo 3 doesn't look leaps and bounds better than Bioshock, and it certainly isn't more original than either Bioshock or Prime 3.

But if Halo 3 runs the risk of receiving a less than perfect score, why do Cows think that the non-awaited sequel to the miserable Killzone has a chance ?

Individually Bioshock and Prime 3 have scored more show awards than Killzone 2 multiplied by the number Final Fantasy rehashes released by Square Enix. Additionally Killzone 2's Halo Killer status has not been proved by the mediocre tactical strategy spin-off Killzone: Liberation. You would have mad cow disease to think that Killzone 2 stands a chance of scoring AA now.

SiiSsy

:? I don't know that and neither does anyone else.

[QUOTE="spinecaton"][QUOTE="AcidTWister"][QUOTE="Lilac_Benjie"]

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation.

wapahala

I stopped reading here.

What was original about MP3?

Exactly what I was thinking... MP3 didn't really add anything new to the Metroid Prime trilogy besides new controls.

There's a hell of a lot more originality in MP3 than Halo.

Really? Tell me the difference between the two. Halo isn't just finishing a story like MP3 did. It is adding new features to the game to seperate it from Halo 2 and Halo CE

[QUOTE="wiirdawgs"]after GS prime review the world has been laughing at it while everywhere alse gave it nines and editors choice the gave it a 8.5 for being to easy and being a sequel this is ridiculus to the point where i want to leve GS cuz they are so biased against the wii.SgtWhiskeyjack

Play it first and see if it is too easy or you are getting your backside handed to you, and then slag GS off. Also remember, gamers play games to escape and have fun, reviewers scrutinise a game to look at what's good and what's bad.

it's pretty obvious that gamespot is biased aginst the wii cuz all of it's games aren't getting AAA and every where else gave MP3 at least a 9.0 or in the case of gamespy a 4.5/5

[QUOTE="-wii60-"]Killzone 2 will score 7.9 and thats too much.WSP87

Have you played the game? Didnt think so, so how in the hell can you give it a score? Go away fanboy, just go away. And btw it will be either 8.0 or 7.5 here by what you are saying.

i think KZ2 will end up AA.

[QUOTE="GARRYTH"]wow this is such a stupid thread. are you saying there will not be a better game than bioshock this gen. if so this gen is over. lol how pathedict. i guess we all should stop gaming or just play bioshock until next gen. metriod prime got a 8.5 because the controls made the game feel to easy and no challenge. omg bioshock got a 9 now killzone has no chance lol at you.V_Isle

No, what's pathetic here is your grammar. Anyway, I agree with the topic starter. If games like Bio-Shock and Halo 3 don't score high AAA, what makes you think crap like killzone will? :lol:

[QUOTE="wapahala"][QUOTE="spinecaton"][QUOTE="AcidTWister"][QUOTE="Lilac_Benjie"]

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation.

spinecaton

I stopped reading here.

What was original about MP3?

Exactly what I was thinking... MP3 didn't really add anything new to the Metroid Prime trilogy besides new controls.

There's a hell of a lot more originality in MP3 than Halo.

Really? Tell me the difference between the two. Halo isn't just finishing a story like MP3 did. It is adding new features to the game to seperate it from Halo 2 and Halo CE

I agree with that. It will be interesting to see if thesefeatures that are new to the Halo seriesare all they seem to be cracked up to be, and if they are able to make the game AAA. Personally I think they will deliver.

[QUOTE="SiiSsy"][QUOTE="Lilac_Benjie"]

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation. Halo 3 doesn't look leaps and bounds better than Bioshock, and it certainly isn't more original than either Bioshock or Prime 3.

But if Halo 3 runs the risk of receiving a less than perfect score, why do Cows think that the non-awaited sequel to the miserable Killzone has a chance ?

Individually Bioshock and Prime 3 have scored more show awards than Killzone 2 multiplied by the number Final Fantasy rehashes released by Square Enix. Additionally Killzone 2's Halo Killer status has not been proved by the mediocre tactical strategy spin-off Killzone: Liberation. You would have mad cow disease to think that Killzone 2 stands a chance of scoring AA now.

-wii60-

The same thing could be said about you:|

How about waiting until the game comes out huh? Did you ever think of that? No you are a blind PS3 hater, of course you didn't.

The same thing could be said about you:|

How about waiting until the game comes out huh? Did you ever think of that? No you are a blind PS3 hater, of course you didn't.

no_submission

I think Halo 3 still has a good chance to score high. There's one major thing Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 were missing MULTIPLAYER! A game with no multiplayer doesn't deserve more than a 9.0! I'm glad Gamespot saw past the hype of MP3 and gave it the score it deserves (but don't get me wrong I'm still loving this game).EdiD

Yeah, its too bad MP3 didn't have multiplayer but I blame Nintendo for that. They still don't seem to know what they are doing with online (although Mario Strikers Charged online is a blast).

Flop or not, I'm still getting Halo 3, just can't beat the co-op!!

MP3? Original?

Halo 3 is doing more for the Halo series than MP3 did for the Metroid series. New Meta game mode, Forge, saved films feature may not all be original, but they arent seen very often in console land, and will certainly make the Halo experience alot better.

Flop or not, I'm still getting Halo 3, just can't beat the co-op!!

Hermitkermit

Co-op is the only way I play the Halo campaigns :D

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation. Halo 3 doesn't look leaps and bounds better than Bioshock, and it certainly isn't more original than either Bioshock or Prime 3.

But if Halo 3 runs the risk of receiving a less than perfect score, why do Cows think that the non-awaited sequel to the miserable Killzone has a chance ?

Individually Bioshock and Prime 3 have scored more show awards than Killzone 2 multiplied by the number Final Fantasy rehashes released by Square Enix. Additionally Killzone 2's Halo Killer status has not been proved by the mediocre tactical strategy spin-off Killzone: Liberation. You would have mad cow disease to think that Killzone 2 stands a chance of scoring AA now.

Lilac_Benjie

[QUOTE="Lilac_Benjie"]

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation. Halo 3 doesn't look leaps and bounds better than Bioshock, and it certainly isn't more original than either Bioshock or Prime 3.

But if Halo 3 runs the risk of receiving a less than perfect score, why do Cows think that the non-awaited sequel to the miserable Killzone has a chance ?

Individually Bioshock and Prime 3 have scored more show awards than Killzone 2 multiplied by the number Final Fantasy rehashes released by Square Enix. Additionally Killzone 2's Halo Killer status has not been proved by the mediocre tactical strategy spin-off Killzone: Liberation. You would have mad cow disease to think that Killzone 2 stands a chance of scoring AA now.

-InsrtNameHere-

[QUOTE="Lilac_Benjie"]

To place things into perspective, Halo 3 might not surpass 8.5 now. Bioshock and Metroid Prime 3 where the most original anticipated shooters this generation.

AcidTWister

What was original about MP3?

Is this a joke of a question? The Prime series is a unique series in its entirety.

Metroid better than Halo? that's a joke:lol:No_Talent_Dev

As I recall, Metroid Prime is the only game between the two series to receive GOTY here.