Can we safely say now Xbox 360 is winner of 2011 ?

[QUOTE="UnrealLegend"]

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"] Ok then still lower score than LBP2, which was the whole point. Also KZ3 any day over Gears 3Cow4ever

True, 92 > 91. But also, 9.5 > 9.0. Just Sayin' :)

If it's not a big difference, then why are you bringing it up? :?

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"][QUOTE="UnrealLegend"]

True, 92 > 91. But also, 9.5 > 9.0. Just Sayin' :)

UnrealLegend

If it's not a big difference, then why are you bringing it up? :?

The Dishwasher: Vampire Smile. Released April 6, 2011. 9.0 here at Gamespot. Xbox 360 exclusive. Just sayin'.

[QUOTE="UnrealLegend"]

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"]

Flop of wars 3 only got 91 in metacritic, compared to Little Big Planet 2 that got 92. So PS3 have a higher rated AAAE and also Resistance 3, Infamous 2 and Killzone 3 (which is awesome BTW, definitely AAAE quality) and then we still got Uncharted 3, Journey and Payback the heist.

Cow4ever

Oh wow...

So 91 is a flop? :lol:

If you want to go by scores, Killzone 3 and inFamous 2 both flopped. :)

[QUOTE="UnrealLegend"]

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"] Not a big difference in both cases really. Point is 360 in no way is a winner with only one AAAE when PS3 also has one and 3 really great AAECow4ever

If it's not a big difference, then why are you bringing it up? :?

That's the point I was trying to make; but you were claiming that Gears 3 "flopped" because its MC score is 1% lower than LBP2...

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"][QUOTE="UnrealLegend"]

Oh wow...

So 91 is a flop? :lol:

If you want to go by scores, Killzone 3 and inFamous 2 both flopped. :)

shahilsyed

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"][QUOTE="UnrealLegend"]

If it's not a big difference, then why are you bringing it up? :?

UnrealLegend

That's the point I was trying to make; but you were claiming that Gears 3 "flopped" because its MC score is 1% lower than LBP2...

[QUOTE="soulitane"][QUOTE="Cow4ever"] Ok then still lower score than LBP2, which was the whole point. Also KZ3 any day over Gears 3Cow4ever

The Dishwasher: Vampire Smile. Released April 6, 2011. 9.0 here at Gamespot. Xbox 360 exclusive. Just sayin'.

Twin-Blade

Nope PC and Nintendo win 2011. Can't be the true version of Battlefield 3, Skyward Sword, and Super Mario 3D Land.

ChubbyGuy40

[QUOTE="UnrealLegend"]

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"] As I said both have 1 AAAE, but PS3 also have 3 quality AAE so how can 360 be a winner??Cow4ever

That's the point I was trying to make; but you were claiming that Gears 3 "flopped" because its MC score is 1% lower than LBP2...

Nothing. You can think Gears is a flop if you want.

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"]

[QUOTE="soulitane"] and I guess LBP2 was a flop in comparison to super mario galaxy 1 and 2?soulitane

[QUOTE="soulitane"][QUOTE="Cow4ever"] What?

Cow4ever

[QUOTE="shahilsyed"][QUOTE="Cow4ever"] Yes 91 is a flop, it was hyped to like 95. Considering Gears 1 was 94 and gears 2 was 93. It is a flop. Yes KZ and Infamous flopped but LBP 2 didn't. And KZ3 is the best fps in recent times.Cow4ever

You can't include Halo since its a remake.

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"][QUOTE="UnrealLegend"]

That's the point I was trying to make; but you were claiming that Gears 3 "flopped" because its MC score is 1% lower than LBP2...

UnrealLegend

Nothing. You can think Gears is a flop if you want.

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"][QUOTE="soulitane"] SMG1 and 2 outscored LBP2 so wouldn't that make it a flop?soulitane

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"][QUOTE="soulitane"] SMG1 and 2 outscored LBP2 so wouldn't that make it a flop?soulitane

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"]

Flop of wars 3 only got 91 in metacritic, compared to Little Big Planet 2 that got 92. So PS3 have a higher rated AAAE and also Resistance 3, Infamous 2 and Killzone 3 (which is awesome BTW, definitely AAAE quality) and then we still got Uncharted 3, Journey and Payback the heist.

BloodyFalcon007

Flop of War? LOL! And you're defending LBP2! A game made for casuals and children 5 years old children!

doubting you've played LBP2.

Its an insanely powerful creative tool if you learn how to use it and tbh thats where most of the fun in LBP1 sprang from for me, on top of that LBP1 was a punishing game especially in the latter half of the story mode.

[QUOTE="BloodyFalcon007"]

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"]

Flop of wars 3 only got 91 in metacritic, compared to Little Big Planet 2 that got 92. So PS3 have a higher rated AAAE and also Resistance 3, Infamous 2 and Killzone 3 (which is awesome BTW, definitely AAAE quality) and then we still got Uncharted 3, Journey and Payback the heist.

razgriz_101

Flop of War? LOL! And you're defending LBP2! A game made for casuals and children 5 years old children!

doubting you've played LBP2.

Its an insanely powerful creative tool if you learn how to use it and tbh thats where most of the fun in LBP1 sprang from for me, on top of that LBP1 was a punishing game especially in the latter half of the story mode.

[QUOTE="soulitane"]

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"] They're not the same franchise. Cow4ever

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"][QUOTE="soulitane"] Neither are gears and LBP :?

soulitane

So one game is all takes after 9 barren months?

I see your standards are rock bottom

Zaibach

Lol. PC win every year, as default.C_Rule

Yeah Witcher 2 was great. So was.. Umm.. Those other awesome games.. Like Civilization 5 & Total War! People can't stop talking about them.

[QUOTE="Zaibach"]

So one game is all takes after 9 barren months?

I see your standards are rock bottom

hiryu3

The Dishwasher: Vampire Smile, if we're counting.

[QUOTE="soulitane"][QUOTE="Cow4ever"] All I said was LBP2 had higher score, not that that would make Gears 3 a flop.Cow4ever

[QUOTE="razgriz_101"]

[QUOTE="BloodyFalcon007"]

Flop of War? LOL! And you're defending LBP2! A game made for casuals and children 5 years old children!

shahilsyed

doubting you've played LBP2.

Its an insanely powerful creative tool if you learn how to use it and tbh thats where most of the fun in LBP1 sprang from for me, on top of that LBP1 was a punishing game especially in the latter half of the story mode.

So because GT5 is rated a 3+ and the same with Forza arent hardcore and kiddy games?

The artstlye for LBP might be kiddy but the same could be said for Mario yet its always lauded and paraded around on here :-/ doesnt really compute to be honest.

[QUOTE="soulitane"][QUOTE="Cow4ever"] All I said was LBP2 had higher score, not that that would make Gears 3 a flop.Cow4ever

Current 2011 standings for exclusives are:

360:

• 2 AAAe
• 3 AAe

PS3:

• 1 AAAe
• 5 AAe

PC:

• 1 AAAe (2 counting TW2)
• 8 AAe

So far PC is winning (arguably), though I may have made some mistakes.

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"]

[QUOTE="soulitane"] But you can't compare them because like you said they're not of the same franchise.soulitane

Exactly. Most critics said LBP2 was much better than LBP1. But it's average score is still lower.

[QUOTE="C_Rule"]Lol. PC win every year, as default.Twin-Blade

Yeah Witcher 2 was great. So was.. Umm.. Those other awesome games.. Like Civilization 5 & Total War! People can't stop talking about them.

Current 2011 standings for exclusives are:

360:

• 2 AAAe
• 3 AAe

PS3:

• 1 AAAe
• 5 AAe

PC:

• 2 AAAe (3 counting TW2)
• 8 AAe

So far PC is winning (as usual), though I probably may have made some mistakes.

hypoty

[QUOTE="C_Rule"]Lol. PC win every year, as default.Twin-Blade

Yeah Witcher 2 was great. So was.. Umm.. Those other awesome games.. Like Civilization 5 & Total War! People can't stop talking about them.

System wars doesn't equal the world. CiV will be played for a lot longer than many other 2011 titles.

[QUOTE="hypoty"]

Current 2011 standings for exclusives are:

360:

• 2 AAAe
• 3 AAe

PS3:

• 1 AAAe
• 5 AAe

PC:

• 2 AAAe (3 counting TW2)
• 8 AAe

So far PC is winning (as usual), though I probably may have made some mistakes.

Sollet

Dishwasher: Vampire Smile. I'm counting PSN, XBLA games.

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"]

[QUOTE="soulitane"] But you can't compare them because like you said they're not of the same franchise.shahilsyed

[QUOTE="Sollet"][QUOTE="hypoty"]

Current 2011 standings for exclusives are:

360:

• 2 AAAe
• 3 AAe

PS3:

• 1 AAAe
• 5 AAe

PC:

• 2 AAAe (3 counting TW2)
• 8 AAe

So far PC is winning (as usual), though I probably may have made some mistakes.

hypoty

Dishwasher: Vampire Smile. I'm counting PSN, XBLA games.

[QUOTE="shahilsyed"][QUOTE="Cow4ever"] LBP2 does have a higher score despite them being different franchises. But that doesn't make Gears 3 a flop. But TBH both are flops in one way since they both scored lower than their predecessors

Cow4ever

IGN did but other companies havent, also I love ur sig, what is it?

[QUOTE="Twin-Blade"]

[QUOTE="C_Rule"]Lol. PC win every year, as default.hypoty

Yeah Witcher 2 was great. So was.. Umm.. Those other awesome games.. Like Civilization 5 & Total War! People can't stop talking about them.

System wars doesn't equal the world. CiV will be played for a lot longer than many other 2011 titles.

[QUOTE="hypoty"]

[QUOTE="Sollet"] uhm what is the 2nd AAAE on the 360?Sollet

Dishwasher: Vampire Smile. I'm counting PSN, XBLA games.

Add to it if you want, I don't have the time to sift through the 2011 AA scores on Gamespot. There's a lot of them.

Jesus Christ...:roll:

Zaibach

[QUOTE="hypoty"]

[QUOTE="Twin-Blade"]

Yeah Witcher 2 was great. So was.. Umm.. Those other awesome games.. Like Civilization 5 & Total War! People can't stop talking about them.

Cow4ever

System wars doesn't equal the world. CiV will be played for a lot longer than many other 2011 titles.

It did, my mistake.

[QUOTE="Sollet"][QUOTE="hypoty"]

Current 2011 standings for exclusives are:

360:

• 2 AAAe
• 3 AAe

PS3:

• 1 AAAe
• 5 AAe

PC:

• 2 AAAe (3 counting TW2)
• 8 AAe

So far PC is winning (as usual), though I probably may have made some mistakes.

hypoty

Dishwasher: Vampire Smile. I'm counting PSN, XBLA games.

[QUOTE="hypoty"]

[QUOTE="Sollet"] uhm what is the 2nd AAAE on the 360?Cow4ever

Dishwasher: Vampire Smile. I'm counting PSN, XBLA games.

Last I heard we go by Gamespot scores here. There's too many variables when comparing things on MC and GR.

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"][QUOTE="hypoty"]

Dishwasher: Vampire Smile. I'm counting PSN, XBLA games.

hypoty

Last I heard we go by Gamespot scores here. There's too many variables when comparing things on MC and GR.

We only go by Gamespot scores when it suits the cows. Dishwasher doesn't count.

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"][QUOTE="hypoty"]

Dishwasher: Vampire Smile. I'm counting PSN, XBLA games.

hypoty

Last I heard we go by Gamespot scores here. There's too many variables when comparing things on MC and GR.

[QUOTE="hypoty"]

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"] 81 on MCCow4ever

Last I heard we go by Gamespot scores here. There's too many variables when comparing things on MC and GR.

[QUOTE="hypoty"]

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"] 81 on MCCow4ever

Last I heard we go by Gamespot scores here. There's too many variables when comparing things on MC and GR.

Says everyone. I don't personally agree with it, but this is GameSpot.

[QUOTE="hypoty"]

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"] 81 on MCTwin-Blade

Last I heard we go by Gamespot scores here. There's too many variables when comparing things on MC and GR.

We only go by Gamespot scores when it suits the cows. Dishwasher doesn't count.

[QUOTE="hypoty"]

[QUOTE="Cow4ever"] 81 on MCCow4ever

Last I heard we go by Gamespot scores here. There's too many variables when comparing things on MC and GR.

Casey I guess. I recall that its been tradition here since 2004.