Could 360 do Uncharted 2 graphics?

I don't think so. In my opinion, the graphics in the Uncharted 2 screenshots look better than any 360 game by a good margin. I think the PS3 is a more graphically capable system.

Opinions?

Uncharted 2 kinda looks like the upcoming 50 Cent video game and that's multiplat, so most likely yes, but who knows.

yes alan wake mass effect and gears 2 look just as goodcoolnessmancool

im pretty sure nobody here has the IQ to really answer that question.lawlessx

Only the makers of Uncharted could answer that and they did by saying no the 360 couldn't do it because they harnessed the Bluray drive's capabilities and the 360 only does DVDs.

[QUOTE="lawlessx"]im pretty sure nobody here has the IQ to really answer that question.patriots7672

Only the makers of Uncharted could answer that and they did by saying no the 360 couldn't do it because they harnessed the Bluray drive's capabilities and the 360 only does DVDs.

Never. The PS3 will always have better graphics from now on.

I know we thought the 360 wouldn't be able to match PS3 graphics when the PS3 launched and were surprised at how well the 360 matched up. We were surprised again in 2007 as the 360 continued to keep pace. And were surprised yet again this 2008 with the new Gears and latest Gamespot comparison. But now there's no way we're going to be surprised again.

Is there?

im pretty sure nobody here has the IQ to really answer that question.lawlessx

[QUOTE="lawlessx"]im pretty sure nobody here has the IQ to really answer that question.patriots7672

Only the makers of Uncharted could answer that and they did by saying no the 360 couldn't do it because they harnessed the Bluray drive's capabilities and the 360 only does DVDs.

[QUOTE="lawlessx"]im pretty sure nobody here has the IQ to really answer that question.BumFluff122

The 360 could make it look about 85-90% as good, but not totally all the way. patriots7672

... Oh, my God.

I'm guessing that if Naughty Dog developed Uncharted for the 360, they could have made it run smoother, have better textures, and just about everything else would be better.

Of course the 360 could. The 360 is capable of higher polycounts and higher res textures than the PS3. Thats why its easier to port games from PS3 to 360 than it is to port games from 360 to PS3. What is apparent is that Sony has contracted some great technical and artistic talent in insomniac and Naughtydog.EG101

Are you sure?

Here's the answer....... http://www.gamestooge.com/2007/11/18/interview-uncharted-drakes-fortune-possible-on-360/

Obli: How hard would it be to port Uncharted to the Xbox 360? I'm not just talking storage constraints (Blu-ray). Could it be faithfully recreated without the use of Cell?

Evan Wells: I won't say that it would be impossible, but it would be very difficult and we most certainly would have to make enough concessions that it would start to feel like a different game

[QUOTE="EG101"]Of course the 360 could. The 360 is capable of higher polycounts and higher res textures than the PS3. Thats why its easier to port games from PS3 to 360 than it is to port games from 360 to PS3. What is apparent is that Sony has contracted some great technical and artistic talent in insomniac and Naughtydog.patriots7672

Are you sure?

Here's the answer....... http://www.gamestooge.com/2007/11/18/interview-uncharted-drakes-fortune-possible-on-360/

Obli: How hard would it be to port Uncharted to the Xbox 360? I'm not just talking storage constraints (Blu-ray). Could it be faithfully recreated without the use of Cell?

Evan Wells: I won't say that it would be impossible, but it would be very difficult and we most certainly would have to make enough concessions that it would start to feel like a different game

[QUOTE="lawlessx"]im pretty sure nobody here has the IQ to really answer that question.patriots7672

Only the makers of Uncharted could answer that and they did by saying no the 360 couldn't do it because they harnessed the Bluray drive's capabilities and the 360 only does DVDs.

[QUOTE="patriots7672"]

[QUOTE="EG101"]Of course the 360 could. The 360 is capable of higher polycounts and higher res textures than the PS3. Thats why its easier to port games from PS3 to 360 than it is to port games from 360 to PS3. What is apparent is that Sony has contracted some great technical and artistic talent in insomniac and Naughtydog.user_nat

Are you sure?

Here's the answer....... http://www.gamestooge.com/2007/11/18/interview-uncharted-drakes-fortune-possible-on-360/

Obli: How hard would it be to port Uncharted to the Xbox 360? I'm not just talking storage constraints (Blu-ray). Could it be faithfully recreated without the use of Cell?

Evan Wells: I won't say that it would be impossible, but it would be very difficult and we most certainly would have to make enough concessions that it would start to feel like a different game

The 360 could make it look about 85-90% as good, but not totally all the way. patriots7672

[QUOTE="patriots7672"]

[QUOTE="lawlessx"]im pretty sure nobody here has the IQ to really answer that question.PSP107

Only the makers of Uncharted could answer that and they did by saying no the 360 couldn't do it because they harnessed the Bluray drive's capabilities and the 360 only does DVDs.

Right the trouble is that the data that needs to be accessed from the disc while playing all needs to be on the disc and is too much data for a dual-layered dvd as with the 360. Bluray is large enough to pull it off and that is why they said they harnessed the capabilities of the Bluray drive to pull it off.

[QUOTE="patriots7672"]

[QUOTE="EG101"]Of course the 360 could. The 360 is capable of higher polycounts and higher res textures than the PS3. Thats why its easier to port games from PS3 to 360 than it is to port games from 360 to PS3. What is apparent is that Sony has contracted some great technical and artistic talent in insomniac and Naughtydog.user_nat

Are you sure?

Here's the answer....... http://www.gamestooge.com/2007/11/18/interview-uncharted-drakes-fortune-possible-on-360/

Obli: How hard would it be to port Uncharted to the Xbox 360? I'm not just talking storage constraints (Blu-ray). Could it be faithfully recreated without the use of Cell?

Evan Wells: I won't say that it would be impossible, but it would be very difficult and we most certainly would have to make enough concessions that it would start to feel like a different game

Are we back to these topics again?????? SERIOUSLY when are you cows going to get it straight that the 360 and PS3 are equal in power. kingtito

Probably when the 360 has more games that look as good as PS3's exclusives:|

[QUOTE="patriots7672"]The 360 could make it look about 85-90% as good, but not totally all the way. wapahala

... Oh, my God.

I'm guessing that if Naughty Dog developed Uncharted for the 360, they could have made it run smoother, have better textures, and just about everything else would be better.

[QUOTE="EG101"]Of course the 360 could. The 360 is capable of higher polycounts and higher res textures than the PS3. Thats why its easier to port games from PS3 to 360 than it is to port games from 360 to PS3. What is apparent is that Sony has contracted some great technical and artistic talent in insomniac and Naughtydog.patriots7672

Are you sure?

Here's the answer....... http://www.gamestooge.com/2007/11/18/interview-uncharted-drakes-fortune-possible-on-360/

Obli: How hard would it be to port Uncharted to the Xbox 360? I'm not just talking storage constraints (Blu-ray). Could it be faithfully recreated without the use of Cell?

Evan Wells: I won't say that it would be impossible, but it would be very difficult and we most certainly would have to make enough concessions that it would start to feel like a different game

[QUOTE="kingtito"]Are we back to these topics again?????? SERIOUSLY when are you cows going to get it straight that the 360 and PS3 are equal in power. Sgt_Hale

Probably when the 360 has more games that look as good as PS3's exclusives:|

[QUOTE="patriots7672"]The 360 could make it look about 85-90% as good, but not totally all the way. wapahala

... Oh, my God.

I'm guessing that if Naughty Dog developed Uncharted for the 360, they could have made it run smoother, have better textures, and just about everything else would be better.

Im willing to bet it could.II_Seraphim_II

Come on!! Not only is it impossible for the X360 to get the same graphics, but it is impossible for it to have the amazing sound the exclusives on the PS3 have. People does'nt think of this much, but the PS3 also runs high resolution sound and that demands a lot of bandwidth and processing power. Not even PC games know what 7.1 PCM sound is. The X360 only runs compressed Dolby Digital, not even DTS.

And the developers also has to make some levels look worser than others as well. They have to use a lot of these tricks to fit the game on one dvd.....admit it.

Come on!! Not only is it impossible for the X360 to get the same graphics, but it is impossible for it to have the amazing sound the exclusives on the PS3 have. People does'nt think of this much, but the PS3 also runs high resolution sound and that demands a lot of bandwidth and processing power. Not even PC games know what 7.1 PCM sound is. The X360 only runs compressed Dolby Digital, not even DTS.

And the developers also has to make some levels look worser than others as well. They have to use a lot of these tricks to fit the game on one dvd.....admit it.

[QUOTE="Martin_G_N"]

Come on!! Not only is it impossible for the X360 to get the same graphics, but it is impossible for it to have the amazing sound the exclusives on the PS3 have. People does'nt think of this much, but the PS3 also runs high resolution sound and that demands a lot of bandwidth and processing power. Not even PC games know what 7.1 PCM sound is. The X360 only runs compressed Dolby Digital, not even DTS.

And the developers also has to make some levels look worser than others as well. They have to use a lot of these tricks to fit the game on one dvd.....admit it.

longshotgir

:lol:

Btw longshot, I would delete the word "idiot", it could get you suspended, trust me.

[QUOTE="Martin_G_N"]

Come on!! Not only is it impossible for the X360 to get the same graphics, but it is impossible for it to have the amazing sound the exclusives on the PS3 have. People does'nt think of this much, but the PS3 also runs high resolution sound and that demands a lot of bandwidth and processing power. Not even PC games know what 7.1 PCM sound is. The X360 only runs compressed Dolby Digital, not even DTS.

And the developers also has to make some levels look worser than others as well. They have to use a lot of these tricks to fit the game on one dvd.....admit it.

longshotgir

Come on!! Not only is it impossible for the X360 to get the same graphics, but it is impossible for it to have the amazing sound the exclusives on the PS3 have. People does'nt think of this much, but the PS3 also runs high resolution sound and that demands a lot of bandwidth and processing power. Not even PC games know what 7.1 PCM sound is. The X360 only runs compressed Dolby Digital, not even DTS.

And the developers also has to make some levels look worser than others as well. They have to use a lot of these tricks to fit the game on one dvd.....admit it.

:lol:

Btw longshot, I would delete the word "idiot", it could get you suspended, trust me.

while i don think that uncharted could run on the 360, i do fell that there'll be limitations. Animations, will be one of them that take a hti on the 360. While gears 2 do hold the console graphics crown right now, (IMHO) gears 2 really didn't look loads better than gears 1, as a matter of fact, i'll argue that the sequel performance transition is greater in Uncharted than it is in Gears. Also, Gears 2 will not hold that crown as long as gears 1 did. I do believe that the 360 is starting to show some age slightly in their graphics because gears was the best looking game that ran the most efficient that the 360 had to offer, until gears 2 came out. On the ps3, Uncharted was top dog of the ps3 (and consoles up until gears 2 came out), while GT5p, MGS4, and Motorstorm: PR (more technical than visual) are all great contenders for a graphics debate, and from the looks of 09, the ps3 visuals are only getting better and better, while the 360 have to rely on multiplats. So while i do think that the game is achievable on the 360, it'll come with limitations.ermacness

[QUOTE="crazy-player"][QUOTE="longshotgir"] 'high resolution sound' :lol: you sir, are and idiot :)longshotgir

:lol:

Btw longshot, I would delete the word "idiot", it could get you suspended, trust me.

It's ok to be called an idiot, is'nt it?:) But the sound on most of the exclusives for the PS3 is pretty good compared other games. Maybe not a BD movie quality, but at least it's dvd quality, which none of the other consoles have.