Could Uncharted have been done on the 360?

I was watching a developer vid on gametrailers about the ps3 power and uncharted being developed on it. They mentioned a lot of talk about shaders, I thought the 360 had better shader capabilities then the ps3? I am wondering if the game would have been possible on the 360, and dont talk about blu-ray..we all know games can use multiple discs. I'm talking about pure graphic and processor power. Of course naughty dog would say no since they are ps3 exclusive (these comments from devs always make me laugh cause it's not like they would even try to develop their game on the competing console).

Without the capatious blu ray drive and supercomputing cell processor god hath deliverth from heaven?

I was watching a developer vid on gametrailers about the ps3 power and uncharted being developed on it. They mentioned a lot of talk about shaders, I thought the 360 had better shader capabilities then the ps3? I am wondering if the game would have been possible on the 360, and dont talk about blu-ray..we all know games can use multiple discs. I'm talking about pure graphic and processor power. Of course naughty dog would say no since they are ps3 exclusive (these comments from devs always make me laugh cause it's not like they would even try to develop their game on the competing console).

3dbullseye

http://www.xboxtoday.ca/11172007/20/ps3_uncharted_possible_on_xbox_360

Ahh, thanks for that, i wasn't really hoping it would get ported, im sure it's a great game and would love to play it but wasn't trying to start any rumors...was just curious about the technicle aspects. Afterall, it is an impressive looking game graphicly. I do wish square would see the light andbring FF 13 to 360 though, that'd make me never even question getting a ps3 :(So the hard drive is the bog down huh, thats a shame.

There is NO WAY the 360 could do uncharted - the 360 doesn't do flopsangryfodder

Mass effect?

Ahh, thanks for that, i wasn't really hoping it would get ported, im sure it's a great game and would love to play it but wasn't trying to start any rumors...was just curious about the technicle aspects. Afterall, it is an impressive looking game graphicly. I do wish square would see the light andbring FF 13 to 360 though, that'd make me never even question getting a ps3 :(So the hard drive is the bog down huh, thats a shame.

3dbullseye

FFXIII cant be done on 360. It isnt powerful enough. Nor has it got hd as standard.

[QUOTE="3dbullseye"]

Ahh, thanks for that, i wasn't really hoping it would get ported, im sure it's a great game and would love to play it but wasn't trying to start any rumors...was just curious about the technicle aspects. Afterall, it is an impressive looking game graphicly. I do wish square would see the light andbring FF 13 to 360 though, that'd make me never even question getting a ps3 :(So the hard drive is the bog down huh, thats a shame.

stefanlek

FFXIII cant be done on 360. It isnt powerful enough. Nor has it got hd as standard.

square say that?

[QUOTE="angryfodder"]There is NO WAY the 360 could do uncharted - the 360 doesn't do flopsjangojay

Mass effect?

I remember somewhere in an interview Naughty Dog (the only Sony developer I really respect honestly) said that the 360 was capiable of doing Uncharted's Graphics. The thing was ps3 has the standard HD, and the larger Blue Ray space, not to mention the complete difference in the archectures. It would have to be completely redone. Reguardless of the graphics, they said the game in a way could be to different from what they have now.Innovazero2000

Blu-ray is not needed, the hard drive DOES make a diffrence

for the last time, the PS3 and 360 are quite evenly matched, Uncharted could be done on the 360, but would have to be redone, as it uses the spu's, but the 360 could do the game the Gpu on the 360 is more powerful

really, arguing graphics between these two system is truely nitpicking, they are both extremely powerful, they just use diffrent methods to get to the same end, the problem with the PS3 is that it uses a totally diffrent method than the PC, so developers have a harder time working wiht the system, and porting games frm PC or 360

[QUOTE="angryfodder"]There is NO WAY the 360 could do uncharted - the 360 doesn't do flopsjangojay

Mass effect?

sigged

[QUOTE="angryfodder"]There is NO WAY the 360 could do uncharted - the 360 doesn't do flopsjangojay

Mass effect?

I'll see your mass effect and raise you lair ;)

you know how we roll

[QUOTE="jangojay"]

[QUOTE="angryfodder"]There is NO WAY the 360 could do uncharted - the 360 doesn't do flopsangryfodder

Mass effect?

I'll see your mass effect and raise you lair ;)

you know how we roll

You know your just proving how much of a fanboy you are, i'v seen your other posts ;)

[QUOTE="stefanlek"][QUOTE="3dbullseye"]

Ahh, thanks for that, i wasn't really hoping it would get ported, im sure it's a great game and would love to play it but wasn't trying to start any rumors...was just curious about the technicle aspects. Afterall, it is an impressive looking game graphicly. I do wish square would see the light andbring FF 13 to 360 though, that'd make me never even question getting a ps3 :(So the hard drive is the bog down huh, thats a shame.

3dbullseye

FFXIII cant be done on 360. It isnt powerful enough. Nor has it got hd as standard.

square say that?

Square said that FF13 will be using the maximum capabilities of the ps3. And as the ps3's maximum capability surpasses that of the 360's, its not possible.

graphically it could easily be done on the 360....there is nothing in that game graphically i havent seen on the 360...well going by the demo anyway im sure it gets better but i dont for one second think of the other things ive seen on tv that it could be done...however the disc space and hdd caching is something different but even that could be got around with more discs and hdd nedded for the game..

its been done before on the 360 where you neede a hdd to play..its was a soccer manager sim..

[QUOTE="3dbullseye"][QUOTE="stefanlek"][QUOTE="3dbullseye"]

Ahh, thanks for that, i wasn't really hoping it would get ported, im sure it's a great game and would love to play it but wasn't trying to start any rumors...was just curious about the technicle aspects. Afterall, it is an impressive looking game graphicly. I do wish square would see the light andbring FF 13 to 360 though, that'd make me never even question getting a ps3 :(So the hard drive is the bog down huh, thats a shame.

mustaf_nur89

FFXIII cant be done on 360. It isnt powerful enough. Nor has it got hd as standard.

square say that?

Square said that FF13 will be using the maximum capabilities of the ps3. And as the ps3's maximum capability surpasses that of the 360's, its not possible.

Fanboy much??????

Please you're going to tell me a FF game is going to use any system to it's fullest???? It's a movie with some gameplay inbetween. The Wii could do a FF13.

Don't believe dev hype, they just want to sell the game.

[QUOTE="angryfodder"][QUOTE="jangojay"]

[QUOTE="angryfodder"]There is NO WAY the 360 could do uncharted - the 360 doesn't do flopsspeedjunkie1992

Mass effect?

I'll see your mass effect and raise you lair ;)

you know how we roll

You know your just proving how much of a fanboy you are, i'v seen your other posts ;)

As in xbox fanboy? I am not a fan boy, I am a PS3 basher. The bashing will stop when playstation gets their act together andmakes their console a worth while purchase.Look at my blog at my console line up dude ;)

Uncharted could be done on the 360 epsecially with the use of the HDD. One problem with the 360 is that MS is holding devs back from fully utilizing the HDD for games. Mass Effect for example would have no framerate issues if Bioware were allowed to completely use the HDD.

The PS3 has more potential. It's just a matter of time for devs to fully utilize the power of the cell. Later this gen we will probably see games that will only be possible on the PS3. It won't be the other way around.

To be honest i think there is no chance that Uncharted would run on 360, only if it would be a complet different game and look different aswell.

Xbox 360 could not run such a detailed game so smooth and especially it won't be as jaggie free as it's on the PS3. There is way to much geometry, fantastic animations and physics for the 360 to run this.

Every single thing in Uncharted is done very good, there is no game except Crysis that has such a graphical/technical detail and deepness.

[QUOTE="mustaf_nur89"][QUOTE="3dbullseye"][QUOTE="stefanlek"][QUOTE="3dbullseye"]

Ahh, thanks for that, i wasn't really hoping it would get ported, im sure it's a great game and would love to play it but wasn't trying to start any rumors...was just curious about the technicle aspects. Afterall, it is an impressive looking game graphicly. I do wish square would see the light andbring FF 13 to 360 though, that'd make me never even question getting a ps3 :(So the hard drive is the bog down huh, thats a shame.

kingtito

FFXIII cant be done on 360. It isnt powerful enough. Nor has it got hd as standard.

square say that?

Square said that FF13 will be using the maximum capabilities of the ps3. And as the ps3's maximum capability surpasses that of the 360's, its not possible.

Fanboy much??????

Please you're going to tell me a FF game is going to use any system to it's fullest???? It's a movie with some gameplay inbetween. The Wii could do a FF13.

Don't believe dev hype, they just want to sell the game.

I'm not being fanboyish, there was a couple threads here showing the article were square said the it would use the ps3 to its fullest....to say the wii could do FF13 like the ps3 can is fanboyish

To be honest i think there is no chance that Uncharted would run on 360, only if it would be a complet different game and look different aswell.

Xbox 360 could not run such a detailed game so smooth and especially it won't be as jaggie free as it's on the PS3. There is way to much geometry, fantastic animations and physics for the 360 to run this.

Every single thing in Uncharted is done very good, there is no game except Crysis that has such a graphical/technical detail and deepness.

skyform

The fanboys on this site never cease to amaze me.

Little news flash for you, ANYTHING the PS3 can do can also be done on the 360.

[QUOTE="kingtito"][QUOTE="mustaf_nur89"][QUOTE="3dbullseye"][QUOTE="stefanlek"][QUOTE="3dbullseye"]

Ahh, thanks for that, i wasn't really hoping it would get ported, im sure it's a great game and would love to play it but wasn't trying to start any rumors...was just curious about the technicle aspects. Afterall, it is an impressive looking game graphicly. I do wish square would see the light andbring FF 13 to 360 though, that'd make me never even question getting a ps3 :(So the hard drive is the bog down huh, thats a shame.

mustaf_nur89

FFXIII cant be done on 360. It isnt powerful enough. Nor has it got hd as standard.

square say that?

Square said that FF13 will be using the maximum capabilities of the ps3. And as the ps3's maximum capability surpasses that of the 360's, its not possible.

Fanboy much??????

Please you're going to tell me a FF game is going to use any system to it's fullest???? It's a movie with some gameplay inbetween. The Wii could do a FF13.

Don't believe dev hype, they just want to sell the game.

I'm not being fanboyish, there was a couple threads here showing the article were square said the it would use the ps3 to its fullest....to say the wii could do FF13 like the ps3 can is fanboyish

You mean to the fullest of it's BR capabilities. Everyone knows it doesn't take much to run a FF game since MOST of the game is all CGI anyway. It's not like Crysis or even Uncharted for that matter. It's an RPG with a simple battle system and nice CGI.

[QUOTE="speedjunkie1992"][QUOTE="angryfodder"][QUOTE="jangojay"]

[QUOTE="angryfodder"]There is NO WAY the 360 could do uncharted - the 360 doesn't do flopsangryfodder

Mass effect?

I'll see your mass effect and raise you lair ;)

you know how we roll

You know your just proving how much of a fanboy you are, i'v seen your other posts ;)

As in xbox fanboy? I am not a fan boy, I am a PS3 basher. The bashing will stop when playstation gets their act together andmakes their console a worth while purchase.Look at my blog at my console line up dude ;)

Well thats what i meant really but oh well ill let you have your 5 minutes glory because im so generous.

i think naughty dog said it could be done but they would have to make major changes and it almost wouldnt be the same game, and it also would have loading screens.

thats the best part of uncharted, it has one loading screen and thats when you start up the game

There is NO WAY the 360 could do uncharted - the 360 doesn't do flopsangryfodder

mass effect 8.5

I remember somewhere in an interview Naughty Dog (the only Sony developer I really respect honestly) said that the 360 was capiable of doing Uncharted's Graphics. The thing was ps3 has the standard HD, and the larger Blue Ray space, not to mention the complete difference in the archectures. It would have to be completely redone. Reguardless of the graphics, they said the game in a way could be to different from what they have now.Innovazero2000

The developers said it could be made for 360 but they would have to make changes to get it to work. There was no clarification if they were referring to simply changing the code, or if they would have to downgrade the game in some way.

So basically, the game could NOT be done on the 360 as it currently runs on the PS3. People can take that however they wish.

[QUOTE="skyform"]

To be honest i think there is no chance that Uncharted would run on 360, only if it would be a complet different game and look different aswell.

Xbox 360 could not run such a detailed game so smooth and especially it won't be as jaggie free as it's on the PS3. There is way to much geometry, fantastic animations and physics for the 360 to run this.

Every single thing in Uncharted is done very good, there is no game except Crysis that has such a graphical/technical detail and deepness.

kingtito

The fanboys on this site never cease to amaze me.

Little news flash for you, ANYTHING the PS3 can do can also be done on the 360.

Yes you are so right im such a fanboy, the bigest PS3 fanboy ever, that's why i have the Xbox 360 since launch and tons of games for it but have the PS3 only for 2 months and 4 games for it :roll:

[QUOTE="Innovazero2000"]I remember somewhere in an interview Naughty Dog (the only Sony developer I really respect honestly) said that the 360 was capiable of doing Uncharted's Graphics. The thing was ps3 has the standard HD, and the larger Blue Ray space, not to mention the complete difference in the archectures. It would have to be completely redone. Reguardless of the graphics, they said the game in a way could be to different from what they have now.ZIMdoom

The developers said it could be made for 360 but they would have to make changes to get it to work. There was no clarification if they were referring to simply changing the code, or if they would have to downgrade the game in some way.

So basically, the game could NOT be done on the 360 as it currently runs on the PS3. People can take that however they wish.

Same thing with 360 exclusive games and such. Halo 3 could NOT be done on the PS3 in its current form. Take that however you wish.

It just amazes me that gamers can be convinced that two console with basically the same specs (3.2GHz CPU, 500MHz GPU, 512MB total RAM) cannot run the same game(s). Or even that one console has much more "potential" than the other.

It's really a testament of how little the gamers know about game development.

It just amazes me that gamers can be convinced that two console with basically the same specs (3.2GHz CPU, 500MHz GPU, 512MB total RAM) cannot run the same game(s). Or even that one console has much more "potential" than the other.

It's really a testament of how little the gamers know about game development.

LosDaddie

Did you know that Mac software didn't used to work on PC's? To top that off, PC software didn't use to work on Macs? OMG! Different Architecture ftw!

[QUOTE="kingtito"][QUOTE="skyform"]

To be honest i think there is no chance that Uncharted would run on 360, only if it would be a complet different game and look different aswell.

Xbox 360 could not run such a detailed game so smooth and especially it won't be as jaggie free as it's on the PS3. There is way to much geometry, fantastic animations and physics for the 360 to run this.

Every single thing in Uncharted is done very good, there is no game except Crysis that has such a graphical/technical detail and deepness.

skyform

The fanboys on this site never cease to amaze me.

Little news flash for you, ANYTHING the PS3 can do can also be done on the 360.

Yes you are so right im such a fanboy, the bigest PS3 fanboy ever, that's why i have the Xbox 360 since launch and tons of games for it but have the PS3 only for 2 months and 4 games for it :roll:

Still doesn't exclude you from being a fanboy. Maybe your parents bought you the 360 last year. I do know going by your post that your are indeed a COW.

[QUOTE="angryfodder"]There is NO WAY the 360 could do uncharted - the 360 doesn't do flopspatrickjw333

mass effect 8.5

Mass Effect Average Ratio ....... 91.8%

Uncharted Average Ratio ........ 88.8%

http://www.gamerankings.com/

I was watching a developer vid on gametrailers about the ps3 power and uncharted being developed on it. They mentioned a lot of talk about shaders, I thought the 360 had better shader capabilities then the ps3? I am wondering if the game would have been possible on the 360, and dont talk about blu-ray..we all know games can use multiple discs. I'm talking about pure graphic and processor power. Of course naughty dog would say no since they are ps3 exclusive (these comments from devs always make me laugh cause it's not like they would even try to develop their game on the competing console).

3dbullseye

Naughty dog said the game could be done on the 360, but they also said in the same interview that the game would be different if they had to do that. How much difference? I don't know, but for one the standard HD on the PS3 allows for no loading times at all, and as far as Shaders, the PS3 has a lot more capability in shaders than the 360. That's what made Oblivion look better on the PS3.

[QUOTE="3dbullseye"]

I was watching a developer vid on gametrailers about the ps3 power and uncharted being developed on it. They mentioned a lot of talk about shaders, I thought the 360 had better shader capabilities then the ps3? I am wondering if the game would have been possible on the 360, and dont talk about blu-ray..we all know games can use multiple discs. I'm talking about pure graphic and processor power. Of course naughty dog would say no since they are ps3 exclusive (these comments from devs always make me laugh cause it's not like they would even try to develop their game on the competing console).

MotoRacer81

Naughty dog said the game could be done on the 360, but they also said in the same interview that the game would be different if they had to do that. How much difference? I don't know, but for one the standard HD on the PS3 allows for no loading times at all, and as far as Shaders, the PS3 has a lot more capability in shaders than the 360. That's what made Oblivion look better on the PS3.

[QUOTE="patrickjw333"]

[QUOTE="angryfodder"]There is NO WAY the 360 could do uncharted - the 360 doesn't do flopsGta3-fan334

mass effect 8.5

Mass Effect Average Ratio ....... 91.8%

Uncharted Average Ratio ........ 88.8%

http://www.gamerankings.com/

yeah, 3 precentage points make all the difference really. the games are too close to call any of them a winner, plus M$ hypes Mass Effect like crazy, and they probably paid websites to have them give it a very impressive score. Just click on the game in gamerankings.com as see for yourself. Official Xbox magazine gave it 10/10 and so did GameSpy. how can you give a game 10/10 when it has all these frame rate issues, bugs...etc. anyone sees anything fishy there?? on the contrary, Uncharted seems to have been given more realistic scores, and of course its lowest score was right here on GS.

[QUOTE="LosDaddie"]

It just amazes me that gamers can be convinced that two console with basically the same specs (3.2GHz CPU, 500MHz GPU, 512MB total RAM) cannot run the same game(s). Or even that one console has much more "potential" than the other.

It's really a testament of how little the gamers know about game development.

Bgrngod

Did you know that Mac software didn't used to work on PC's? To top that off, PC software didn't use to work on Macs? OMG! Different Architecture ftw!

:|

You missed the point or maybe I wasn't clear enough. Both the MAC & PC were capable of running the software, it just needed to be retooled.

[QUOTE="MotoRacer81"][QUOTE="3dbullseye"]

I was watching a developer vid on gametrailers about the ps3 power and uncharted being developed on it. They mentioned a lot of talk about shaders, I thought the 360 had better shader capabilities then the ps3? I am wondering if the game would have been possible on the 360, and dont talk about blu-ray..we all know games can use multiple discs. I'm talking about pure graphic and processor power. Of course naughty dog would say no since they are ps3 exclusive (these comments from devs always make me laugh cause it's not like they would even try to develop their game on the competing console).

Gta3-fan334

Naughty dog said the game could be done on the 360, but they also said in the same interview that the game would be different if they had to do that. How much difference? I don't know, but for one the standard HD on the PS3 allows for no loading times at all, and as far as Shaders, the PS3 has a lot more capability in shaders than the 360. That's what made Oblivion look better on the PS3.

yeah, go ahead and role your eyes. Uncharted does not have any loading times, rather the game flows from start to finish wihout seeing one load screen. If you played it, you would know this.

:lol: unchartered is just all watch and no play, the ai is so dumb my toast (that I'm eating right now) are smarter than them, that there is the animation glitches, omg the game just has a good story and presentation but where gameplay is concerend unchartered is garbage, and yes it is possible on 360, and the gameplay would have been better too.amorbis1001

The game was marked down on Gamespot because the AI was too good(a Gamespot frist) and was praised across many sites eg.edge,ign and 1up.

On topic i think graphically it would be capable but i think it would have to be edited heavily and as such would propably be similar to madden ps3 in quality of portation(ie AWFUL (youve gotta hate madden on the ps3))

[QUOTE="mustaf_nur89"][QUOTE="3dbullseye"][QUOTE="stefanlek"][QUOTE="3dbullseye"]

Ahh, thanks for that, i wasn't really hoping it would get ported, im sure it's a great game and would love to play it but wasn't trying to start any rumors...was just curious about the technicle aspects. Afterall, it is an impressive looking game graphicly. I do wish square would see the light andbring FF 13 to 360 though, that'd make me never even question getting a ps3 :(So the hard drive is the bog down huh, thats a shame.

kingtito

FFXIII cant be done on 360. It isnt powerful enough. Nor has it got hd as standard.

square say that?

Square said that FF13 will be using the maximum capabilities of the ps3. And as the ps3's maximum capability surpasses that of the 360's, its not possible.

Fanboy much??????

Please you're going to tell me a FF game is going to use any system to it's fullest???? It's a movie with some gameplay inbetween. The Wii could do a FF13.

Don't believe dev hype, they just want to sell the game.

lol, wow. You really think thats being a fanboy? If you look on IGN in a interview with nomura on FFXIII exclusity, he says that they are going to use the PS3's capabilities to the max. If they were going to port it, he says they would have had to keep that in mind.

The wii could do a FF13. LMAO, that's a good one. and no its not a movie with gameplay in between. There's hardly been any footage of the game (only one trailer im aware of, please enlighten me if you've seen more). I turn the fanboyism to you, you blind lemming. And just a side note, I own both an XBOX 360 and a PS3.

ummm... yeah i dont know if you got the memo, but you're not suppose to make sense in system wars...

It just amazes me that gamers can be convinced that two console with basically the same specs (3.2GHz CPU, 500MHz GPU, 512MB total RAM) cannot run the same game(s). Or even that one console has much more "potential" than the other.

It's really a testament of how little the gamers know about game development.

LosDaddie

[QUOTE="Bgrngod"][QUOTE="LosDaddie"]

It just amazes me that gamers can be convinced that two console with basically the same specs (3.2GHz CPU, 500MHz GPU, 512MB total RAM) cannot run the same game(s). Or even that one console has much more "potential" than the other.

It's really a testament of how little the gamers know about game development.

LosDaddie

Did you know that Mac software didn't used to work on PC's? To top that off, PC software didn't use to work on Macs? OMG! Different Architecture ftw!

:|

You missed the point or maybe I wasn't clear enough. Both the MAC & PC were capable of running the software, it just needed to be retooled.

You weren't clear. Now you are.