Dark Souls VS. The Witcher 2

[QUOTE="pcps360"][QUOTE="Chutebox"] Dude, dark and demons souls are much alike in gameplay. You cant argue this....Some-Mist

other than not being able to use a catalyst for fire spells (fire has always been a separate property from the other magic), how did they overhaul the spell combat system??

'hundreds' of new weapons doesn't change the fact that the gameplay is nearly identical. what do you mean by mage c lass?? there was a priest and royal class in demon's souls....both of which were magic classes...not like the c lasses matter anyways with the exception of starting stat distribution and equips.

I get the feeling you haven't played demon's souls....or dark souls... or both. The only point you have is the world structure, but the bonfires act just as a nexus would anyways..consider it a 'moving nexus'.

------

for the record I think dark souls is awesome, and I'm a huge fan of both souls games. just please don't associate or think thatany of these biased posters represent the fans of dark souls as a whole.

[QUOTE="ducati101"]

[QUOTE="pcps360"] ?? what kind statement is this? maybe because I own a ps3 and played it? lol! my feeling to what platform? can you read my name handle? FABLE3??what??? why should I care about fable 3 and when did I made a single comment about it? just so you know I haven't touched my 360 for nearly a year. Jeues, I swear, PC and ps3 fanboys would go riot for any lame reason if they see a "360" anywhere in your context before they care to read anything else. pcps360

Oh give it up, we all now who you are. All these alt accounts aren't fooling anyone! Learn to spell, it's a dead give away ;)

Honey, their is such thing as a typo then their is consistently spelling the same word wrong in 4 different accounts ;)

? FABLE3??what??? why should I care about fable 3 and when did I made a single comment about it? pcps360

Care about it, because it''s better than both Dark souls and The Witcher 2.

I enjoyed both, haven't gotten far in ether of them but love the dark fantasy setting of both, Witcher has a better story though hands down.

your experience clearly sound like someone who give up on demon's soul in the first 20 mins, I clocked 180 hours in demon's soul and 60 hrs in dark soul to know what I'm talking, and I finished beat TW1 and TW2 once and never want go back.pcps360

what a laughable claim, casters for example, almost none of the spells from dark souls are borrowed from Demon, and spell casting time and reach make the mage combat a completely different experience, not to mention the handful changes in melee combat system. if that's not an overhaul then what else is? it's a very complex and well rounded system to begin with anyway. and ask yourself, what TW2 changed from TW1 exactly except the graphic engine and that downgraded combat system LOL! pcps360

you don't seem to know what you are talking about, what made demon's soul so amazing is that the combat animation is always followed by your weapon, there's almost no 2 weapon wield the same way, especially epic weapon, some even give you AOE spell attack like the katana you get from 3rd zone in demon's soul, that's what made the whole experience so rewarding, unlike TW2. pcps360

[QUOTE="pcps360"]? FABLE3??what??? why should I care about fable 3 and when did I made a single comment about it? Badosh

Care about it, because it''s better than both Dark souls and The Witcher 2.

Yeah, but then again, the only harcore action RPG that beats Fable 3 is Sesame Street: Once Upon a Monster.