Based on what I saw from the demo, it's safe to say that Dead Space obliterates it, and if one want to accuse Dead Space of being a rip-off of something - at least do it properly, because it is, but not there where you point it.
Dead Space is an outstanding game...perhaps even my best game of 08...I can't say that it's better than Resident Evil 5 since I haven't played RE5 yet...but I'm pretty sure that comparing these two games is a bit of a stretch...sure they might be in the same genre but one focuses too much on "cool action sequences" over the other. so it really does depend on the gamer and what they find enjoyable.
I'm probably gonna like RE5 better then, considering how much of a failure Dead Space was in atmosphere and horror.Vandalvideo
Then Resident Evil 5 is failure quadrupled in these departments (at least what was presented in the demo), and it's not convincing at all as an action game itself.
I absolutely loved Dead Space, I really think it raised my expectations for RE5. Haven't played the RE5 demo yet so I can't say how I feel about it yet, but DeadSpace is top notch. I only bought it because I found a deal where it was buy two games get one free and to think my last choice was Dead Space, it was the Best surprise of 2008 for me.
Then Resident Evil 5 is failure quadrupled in these departments (at least what was presented in the demo), and it's not convincing at all as an action game itself.Salt_The_Fries
Resident Evil stopped trying to be scary back with four. Atleast they're not trying and totally failing like Dead Space was. Talk about superficial atmosphere.
Is there any question that this is the case. It's obvious to anyone who played both. What is killing RE5 is that it's out in the open so you should be able to move faster. They should have kept it indoors with more horror then it could have been great. Right now I give it high scores in graphics only. Other than that it's a 7.0 game for me.
I agree, even though, I think Resident Evil 5 will be a good game, Capcom's willingness to just make a game for the sake of making another game is getting on my nerves. There's absolutely no change in controls over Resident Evil 4, besides the optional ability to strafe, and real-time weapon switching. That's very disappointing for me, it feels like they're putting even less innovation into this, than in Devil May Cry 4, and that's extremely sad in it's own right.
[QUOTE="Vandalvideo"]I'm probably gonna like RE5 better then, considering how much of a failure Dead Space was in atmosphere and horror.Salt_The_Fries
Then Resident Evil 5 is failure quadrupled in these departments (at least what was presented in the demo), and it's not convincing at all as an action game itself. I gotta disagree. It was a triple quadruple failure.
[QUOTE="dr-venkman"]Since Res4 still blows Dead Space into... Space. I'll take a true sequel instead of a ripoff. Animal-Mother
Dead Space is far from a "ripoff".
honestly i know you dont like yahtzee and in his review he mentions how it rips off Event horizon, have you seen it?
Yes, I have Event Horizon. Event Horizon was never made into a game, so that's not a concern of mine if people think Dead Space ripped it off. I like to call it "inspirations" instead.
honestly i know you dont like yahtzee and in his review he mentions how it rips off Event horizon, have you seen it?
Yes, I have Event Horizon. Event Horizon was never made into a game, so that's not a concern of mine if people think Dead Space ripped it off. I like to call it "inspirations" instead.
Ya but Dead space is event horizon with an alien infestiation in essence the evil dimension is just the marker
Ok I wouldnt say inspiration but heavily borrowed, have you seen Dead space downfall as well?
[QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"][QUOTE="Animal-Mother"] honestly i know you dont like yahtzee and in his review he mentions how it rips off Event horizon, have you seen it?Animal-Mother
Yes, I have Event Horizon. Event Horizon was never made into a game, so that's not a concern of mine if people think Dead Space ripped it off. I like to call it "inspirations" instead.
Ya but Dead space is event horizon with an alien infestiation in essence the evil dimension is just the marker
Ok I wouldnt say inspiration but heavily borrowed, have you seen Dead space downfall as well?
But there was teh conspiracy involved111111111! Oh well, Dead Space heavily borrowed from System Shock 1 and 2 in means of narration devices and some techniques used in the plot, and that didn't stop me from enjoying and appreciating it.
Yes, I have Event Horizon. Event Horizon was never made into a game, so that's not a concern of mine if people think Dead Space ripped it off. I like to call it "inspirations" instead.
Salt_The_Fries
Ya but Dead space is event horizon with an alien infestiation in essence the evil dimension is just the marker
Ok I wouldnt say inspiration but heavily borrowed, have you seen Dead space downfall as well?
But there was teh conspiracy involved111111111! Oh well, Dead Space heavily borrowed from System Shock 1 and 2 in means of narration devices and some techniques used in the plot, and that didn't stop me from enjoying and appreciating it.
oh by no means am i bashing dead space im just saying what it was derived from, definatly a great game hope theres a sequel
Ya but Dead space is event horizon with an alien infestiation in essence the evil dimension is just the marker
Ok I wouldnt say inspiration but heavily borrowed, have you seen Dead space downfall as well?
Animal-Mother
Animal-mother - Can you help me out? I just bought Deadspace Downfall, but haven't watched it yet. It's not the same as the animated comics that you can download for free from PSN is it?
[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"] Ya but Dead space is event horizon with an alien infestiation in essence the evil dimension is just the marker
Ok I wouldnt say inspiration but heavily borrowed, have you seen Dead space downfall as well?
EmperorSupreme
Animal-mother - Can you help me out? I just bought Deadspace Downfall, but haven't watched it yet. It's not the same as the animated comics that you can download for free from PSN is it? no the comics were a seperate thing. They lead upto the events of dead space downfall
I didn't read them, My friend did says its no biggie, and the movie fills in enough voids as is
[QUOTE="EmperorSupreme"][QUOTE="Animal-Mother"] Ya but Dead space is event horizon with an alien infestiation in essence the evil dimension is just the marker
Ok I wouldnt say inspiration but heavily borrowed, have you seen Dead space downfall as well?
Animal-Mother
Animal-mother - Can you help me out? I just bought Deadspace Downfall, but haven't watched it yet. It's not the same as the animated comics that you can download for free from PSN is it? no the comics were a seperate thing. They lead upto the events of dead space downfall **phew** I was "scared" to open it. (no pun intended)
[QUOTE="REforever101"][QUOTE="Vandalvideo"]I'm probably gonna like RE5 better then, considering how much of a failure Dead Space was in atmosphere and horror.EmperorSupreme
dead space had a PERFECT atmosphere me too, I just thought he was being sarcastic wat? you thought so too?
[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"][QUOTE="EmperorSupreme"] Animal-mother - Can you help me out? I just bought Deadspace Downfall, but haven't watched it yet. It's not the same as the animated comics that you can download for free from PSN is it?EmperorSupreme
no the comics were a seperate thing. They lead upto the events of dead space downfall **phew** I was "scared" to open it. (no pun intended) yeah the movies great I enjoyed it I mean there are more things they could have explained, but it's a solid piece, the only thing I wish was the animation was more anime like it was supposed to be
Based on what I saw from the demo, it's safe to say that Dead Space obliterates it, and if one want to accuse Dead Space of being a rip-off of something - at least do it properly, because it is, but not there where you point it.Salt_The_Fries
I, for one, was actually happy to finally see a decent System Shock 2 ripoff rather than an underwhelming "spiritual successor" :P
[QUOTE="Salt_The_Fries"]Based on what I saw from the demo, it's safe to say that Dead Space obliterates it, and if one want to accuse Dead Space of being a rip-off of something - at least do it properly, because it is, but not there where you point it.thepwninator
I, for one, was actually happy to finally see a decent System Shock 2 ripoff rather than an underwhelming "spiritual successor" :P
Hey, that's so not funny, Mister! :evil: :P BioShock is better than Dead Space and the RE5 demo. ;)
I'm surprised how much hate Resident Evil 5 gets, especially after how well number 4 did. I haven't played 5 yet; just 4. I played the demo of Dead Space, and if Resident Evil 5 is anything like 4, then it blows Dead Space away, in my opinion.
[QUOTE="Salt_The_Fries"] Then Resident Evil 5 is failure quadrupled in these departments (at least what was presented in the demo), and it's not convincing at all as an action game itself.Vandalvideo
Resident Evil stopped trying to be scary back with four. Atleast they're not trying and totally failing like Dead Space was. Talk about superficial atmosphere.
Dead space had better atmosphere then RE4 and by the looks of it has better then RE5.
[QUOTE="Salt_The_Fries"]Based on what I saw from the demo, it's safe to say that Dead Space obliterates it, and if one want to accuse Dead Space of being a rip-off of something - at least do it properly, because it is, but not there where you point it.thepwninator
I, for one, was actually happy to finally see a decent System Shock 2 ripoff rather than an underwhelming "spiritual successor" :P Yeah, I c wut u did thar :D
[QUOTE="DeathScape666"]I'm surprised how much hate Resident Evil 5 gets, especially after how well number 4 did. I haven't played 5 yet; just 4. I played the demo of Dead Space, and if Resident Evil 5 is anything like 4, then it blows Dead Space away, in my opinion. I have deja-vu right now.
Dead space had better atmosphere then RE4 and by the looks of it has better then RE5.finalfantasy94
[QUOTE="thepwninator"][QUOTE="Salt_The_Fries"]Based on what I saw from the demo, it's safe to say that Dead Space obliterates it, and if one want to accuse Dead Space of being a rip-off of something - at least do it properly, because it is, but not there where you point it.BioShockOwnz
I, for one, was actually happy to finally see a decent System Shock 2 ripoff rather than an underwhelming "spiritual successor" :P
Hey, that's so not funny, Mister! :evil: :P BioShock is better than Dead Space and the RE5 demo. ;)
RE5 demo? Sure, no doubt about it :P I'm not so sure about Dead Space though-Dead Space, in my opinion, captured the essence of System Shock 2 more accurately than Bioshock, even though it wasn't marketed as being related to it in any way whatsoever (and I loves mah System Shock ;) ) :P
[QUOTE="thepwninator"][QUOTE="Salt_The_Fries"]Based on what I saw from the demo, it's safe to say that Dead Space obliterates it, and if one want to accuse Dead Space of being a rip-off of something - at least do it properly, because it is, but not there where you point it.BioShockOwnz
I, for one, was actually happy to finally see a decent System Shock 2 ripoff rather than an underwhelming "spiritual successor" :P
Hey, that's so not funny, Mister! :evil: :P BioShock is better than Dead Space and the RE5 demo. ;)
RE5 demo? Sure, no doubt about it :P I'm not so sure about Dead Space though-Dead Space, in my opinion, captured the essence of System Shock 2 more accurately than Bioshock, even though it wasn't marketed as being related to it in any way whatsoever (and I loves mah System Shock ;) ) :Pthepwninator
Dead Space didn't have SHODAN, so instant fail! SHODAN > Andrew Ryan > That crazy religious guy on the ship. Fact! :evil:
Log in to comment