Did MS Moneyhat TR Because They're Scared of Uncharted?

Pretty sure Gran Turismo series are playstation number seller!

no they are scared of their sales numbers

gonna need to see that 110% evidence

Where did I say it wasn't good? I said it was average and frankly it's game play was average. If it were a movie then I'd rate it higher for it's "voice acting, story, music and graphics" but it's a game. Gameplay>>>>>>>>graphics & acting

Except gameplay and gameplay is more important.

What's the point in saying that? TLOU's gameplay isn't all that great either. TLOU is another game that has average gameplay with exceptional "story, acting, music and graphics".

Of course, all of this is my opinion.

@ni6htmare01

Ah Yes... Cars are better anyway. :)

@kingtito The Last of Us game play is good as if not better than TR so it's natural to mention it especially when the people behind it are the same from UC.

@kingtito: good thing that you know that this is just your opinion which not only i and millions disagree with it but scores and awards too ....and Uncharted took nothing from Old Tomb Raider games unless in your mind you think Tomb raider invented 3rd person shooters and platforming and puzzles lol and even then they look no where near close to each other in gameplay ....the only thing they share in common is going after the gold and both are made after indiana jones that's fucking it...on the other hand Tomb Raider 2013 is pretty much uncharted but with a girl as the main character

Phil Spencer ✔ @XboxP3Follow

@TallDwarfSocial Happy 2 partner w/ SE/CD to publish RotTR similiar 2 what we did on Dead Rising. See: http://bit.ly/Y8oDhs @kezamacdonald

So according to Spencer's tweet, MS is publishing Rise of the TR.

i prefer the new Tomb Raider over Uncharted. I've not played Uncharted 2 or 3. I will be getting the next Tomb Raider when its released on the PS3 or PS4. I do hope it's good if not better than the 1st Tomb Raider, i really enjoyed it, although, i've still not completed it yet lol -.-

As long as YOU know that millions of opinions don't make it fact. Awards are pretty much meaningless so again nothing more than opinions from everyone.

So the whole treasure hunting, exploring ruins and the Indiana Jones/ Laura Croft like protagonist wasn't taken from TR? Ummm ok if you say so.

I didn't think so and it was pretty much Uncharted in a zombie apocalypse setting. It was so uninspiring and dull (IMO) that I stopped playing it for weeks and only finished it because I wanted to give it back.

And being 5 million + behind current gen 8 leader SONY and the PS4.

Expect a lot more of this from Microsoft.

Microsoft motto: "You're losing or can't beat them. You buy them."

This is tiny... Compared to what Microsoft is going to do.

You do realize this is Microsoft? Plenty of history here to go by.

like i said most gamers would disagree with you and on top of that there is the awards and scores that back it up

also let me get this right ....you are saying old Tomb Raider invented Treasure hunting ?!lolXD ...also i just said that both TR and UC took inspiration from Indiana Jones and that's it .....they share nothing in commen other that

what a complete BS ...i didn't know uncharted have health bar,scare ammo,Mele Combat as fucking brutal or tense as TLOU combat,Weapons like Pipe/Shiv/Molotov/Machete/Smoke Bombs/Nail Bombs etc,Craft System,Brutal Gunplay,didn't know you can make enemies beg for their life in uncharted or hold them as shield ,didn't know Uncharted have enemies that flank you and attack you from behind etc ,Gameplay options to avoid enemies or stealth them or kill them, didn't know Joel can jump like Drake,Exploring,etc

Uncharted pretty much share nothing in commen with Uncharted other than being made by Naughty Dog...there is even alot of gamers who hate Uncharted but in love with TLOU which show how different they are

i see you defend Microsoft all the time so every thing make sense now reading your comment

And as I said awards are meaningless and others opinions doesn't make what YOU say fact, no matter how many agree.

1st off you haven't gotten anything right, 2nd where did I say TR invented anything? I said Uncharted was inspired/copied from TR as well as Indiana Jones since that was also TRs inspiration. Don't recall ever saying TR invented anything but you go on reading what you want to read.

That is all that's needed. Uncharted is all about presentation and story while it's gameplay is mediocre at best. Pretty much what I've been saying. I don't buy and play games just to see how pretty the graphics are. I watch movies for that. Graphics and story are very nice to have, don't get me wrong but if the gameplay is average then the game is just meh for me. Uncharted is pretty much all graphics and those graphics are made to look like it was bathing is wesson oil.

and again you fail to point what Uncharted share iin commen with old tomb raider games other than Treasure hunting which uncharted took from Indiana Jones not Tomb Raider

and i never said my opinion is a fact also maybe awards and scores are meaningless to you but they are still point out that gamers and critcs view uncharted games as the best as for your opinion on uncharted gameplay ...well, just like you said it's your opinion which i disagree with i think it have better gameplay than tomb raider 2013 which is a copy of uncharted games

Think what you want kid, I've played and completed both games. Seemed very similar to me and for a second I thought Joel was the older version of Nathan Drake.

You seem to be drinking the TLOU Uncharted kool-aid awfully hard kid. I can see how biased you are. I see no point in further discussions about either game. You have your opinion and I have mine.

I defend MS yet I've owned all PS consoles and play most of their games. Yeah perhaps you should see what I'm actually posting about. I don't care about MS nor do I care about Sony. What I respond to are the trolling cows with biased agendas. Those irrational fanboys that can justify anything their company of choice does. You seem to be borderline with your comments about TLOU and Uncharted.

Treasure hunting and exploring ruins is what Uncharted is all about. The devs took that from TR and TR took that from Indian Jones. You seriously are trying to say Uncharted has nothing in common with TR.

Scores and awards don't say anything other than that review or panel happened to like the game. That doesn't mean their opinion means more than anyone else's. Stop acting like you speak for ALL gamers. You have no idea what all gamers think about Uncharted. BTW scores can be bought so you really should stop trying to use that to bolster your argument.

Uncharted IMO == ok. Not great, not spectacular and most definitely NOT better than the old TR games. You want to say they're better, go right ahead so let's just agree to disagree.

lol, someone's mad

1. again Uncharted took nothing from old Tomb Raider and only took Treasure hunting and exploring ruins from Indian Jones and that's it

2.i don't need to speak for ALL gamers ...they vote with their reviews and money also Prove that Sony bought the scores for uncharted games...i will wait

3.yeah let's agree to disagree then

@lostrib: why ?!....why don't you post something useful for once other than "oh he's mad"

No. well not exactly.

Crystal Dynamics and SE ALLOWED MS to money hat them because THEY are afraid to compete directly with Uncharted.

MS just money hatted Tomb Raider (probably any 3rd party they could convince) because they don't have any exclusives worth buying their system for.

The only reason why this happened is because Crystal Dynamics and SE had a mutual interest in not directly competing with Uncharted so the deal fell through.

MS would probably have taken anyone who would agree, but most don't see the benefit in such an agreement as you can understand 10mil > 5 mil plus pay off

You know if they were afraid of Uncharted they would have just moved their game release. smh

1. Playing the def, dumb and blind bit I see. Ok nothing further to discuss

2. I said game score can be bought, I didn't Sony bought TLOU or Uncharted though I wouldn't put it past them to "nudge" the reviewers a certain way. Proof incoming...you continue waiting

Right the kid calling was out of line my bad.

There's nothing to prove really. I played both TLOU and Uncharted and as I've said, they seemed similar. Nothing you throw at me is going to sway my opinion so no need in further conversation regarding that.

@kingtito: it's ok atleast you took back the name calling

oh well, you said your opinion which i disagree with completely ...let's leave it at that then

lol think about that for a second, they did move their game release...THEY DID!

No, they did it to piss off stupid internet fanboys like you TC.

Well I was talking about your correlation to the deal with MS. It doesn't follow necessarily. Kinect the dots man...

It was to take away a common game from PS that PS gamers were used to playing to try and get them to buy an X1. It wont work. It will only make PS gamers dislike Tomb Raider & never buy it in the future.

Well Sony actually made something, not just buy it. That's far more impressive.

You seem angry.

not to mention there's no way they only made the game in response to gears. It launched 1 year later and as talented is ND is, we all know they spend a lot more time than that working on IPs.

Who wouldn't be scared? It's freaking Uncharted...

http://www.nowgamer.com/news/1063301/naughty_dog_gritty_xbox_shooters_shaped_uncharted.html

PC master race.

yup, both MS and SE are scared of Uncharted.

Judging by the size of PS4 vs Xbone install base, Uncharted 4 is going to destroy Halo 5 sale number

Not really. The 1st Uncharted was already in development before the 1st Gears was even announced

Way to miss the point doofus. Why would MS be scared of Uncharted when they already have 2 franchises that are bigger?

yes, seen this before. Not only is gears of war only mentioned merely by way of the author's speculation, but it's as if you forget the 360 wasn't the original xbox. You seriously think they overhauled the entire gameplay based off of a game that had only been out for a year?

Well, Thats one reason. the other is they're to lazy to create/buy their own ip's so they just throw money at 3rd party devs and bribe them for their's.

Neither of those franchises are like Uncharted though (and no, Uncharted isnt a TPS in the vein of a gears of war, its more action adventure)

Irrelevant. Why would MS fear Uncharted if they already have franchises that are bigger?

To catter at people that like these type of games? duh? Just like Sony is pushing Destiny to catter at people who liked Halo? I think its pretty obvious

@cainetao11: Sure, here.

ah huh

@cainetao11: You asked and I delivered.