FPS battle: Halo 3 Vs Killzone 2 Vs Metroid Prime 3

So SW, which do you think is the best?

Edit: To the below comment, it's still an FPS. You can call it an FPA all you want due to it's 'exploration' element or whatever, but don't deny its an FPS.

So SW, which do you think is the best?

Longcat2

So SW, which do you think is the best?

Killzone 2 FTW! :P

[QUOTE="Dibdibdobdobo"][QUOTE="Longcat2"]

So SW, which do you think is the best?

-Reggaeton-

Halo3. And i really prefer its SP over MP. Its just EPIC :D

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sH3YgNzsXoQ

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cD4oW9GXpo8

graphics wise Killzone2 wins but Halo3 has some of the best textures, water and lightning effects this gen and for some reason ppl like to bash them :?

K, well MP3 isn't a FPS so I'll say Halo 3.

[QUOTE="-Reggaeton-"][QUOTE="Dibdibdobdobo"] MP3 is not a FPS. FPA.Dibdibdobdobo

Killzone 2 for hardcore gamers, halo3 for casual gamers.. Cannot comment for Metroid prime havent played that game.

Killzone 2 for hardcore gamers, halo3 for casual gamers.. Cannot comment for Metroid prime havent played that game.

___gamemaster__

[QUOTE="Dibdibdobdobo"][QUOTE="-Reggaeton-"] FPA? Gimme a break. Its a FPS just like HL or anyother FPS game. Basically every FPS is an adventure in some way.zarshack

[QUOTE="___gamemaster__"]

Killzone 2 for hardcore gamers, halo3 for casual gamers.. Cannot comment for Metroid prime havent played that game.

rybe1025

ohh, tight battle between H3 and KZ2, ill say Killzone 2 today

This thread should be called. What are there more of, 360 fans, PS3 fans, or Wii fans in this forum?

This thread should be called. What are there more of, 360 fans, PS3 fans, or Wii fans in this forum?

TheNextOrder

This thread should be called. What are there more of, 360 fans, PS3 fans, or Wii fans in this forum?

TheNextOrder

We all know the answer for that question :P

[QUOTE="rybe1025"]

[QUOTE="___gamemaster__"]

Killzone 2 for hardcore gamers, halo3 for casual gamers.. Cannot comment for Metroid prime havent played that game.

TheNextOrder

Exactly.. I met many people who gave up KZ2 because they cant adjust to the controls and when played on elite version.. They got used to Resistance even Halo3 noob friendly controls..

[QUOTE="___gamemaster__"]

Killzone 2 for hardcore gamers, halo3 for casual gamers.. Cannot comment for Metroid prime havent played that game.

rybe1025

[QUOTE="TheNextOrder"]

[QUOTE="rybe1025"] How on earth is KZ2 for hardcore gamers? If they truly are "hardcore fps gamers" then it would still Halo 3 because the MP offers so much more then what KZ2 has. Heck Halo is used in gaming tournaments already. The clan and stat tracking is far ahead of KZ2.

___gamemaster__

Exactly.. I met many people who gave up KZ2 because they cant adjust to the controls and when played on elite version.. They got used to Resistance even Halo3 noob friendly controls..

[QUOTE="rybe1025"]

[QUOTE="___gamemaster__"]

Killzone 2 for hardcore gamers, halo3 for casual gamers.. Cannot comment for Metroid prime havent played that game.

zarshack

Major League Gaming

King of the couch by Gamestop

Game on League

Gamer Days

Also Bungie is well known for their community support.

[QUOTE="TheNextOrder"]

[QUOTE="rybe1025"] How on earth is KZ2 for hardcore gamers? If they truly are "hardcore fps gamers" then it would still Halo 3 because the MP offers so much more then what KZ2 has. Heck Halo is used in gaming tournaments already. The clan and stat tracking is far ahead of KZ2.

___gamemaster__

Exactly.. I met many people who gave up KZ2 because they cant adjust to the controls and when played on elite version.. They got used to Resistance even Halo3 noob friendly controls..

Sucky controls = sucky controls. sucky controls =/= hardcore game. Otherwise games like gingerbread man are as hardcore as it gets.

Haven't played MP3 and did'nt like H3 so I'm gonna go with Killzone 2.

Have'nt played KZ2 much either since I also have RE5, Uncharted, Disgaea 3, FF:T, Patapon 2, Crisis Core, SO:SE, Manhunt 2, Resistance: Retribution and Orange Box (pc) to play.. Bought too many games at once :(

Don't like MP3 and Halo 3, KZ2... don't even a PS3.

[QUOTE="___gamemaster__"]

[QUOTE="TheNextOrder"]Killzone 2 is for hardcore gamers because the controls are so bad only a hardcore gamer wouldbe able to adjust to them.

Guybrush_3

Exactly.. I met many people who gave up KZ2 because they cant adjust to the controls and when played on elite version.. They got used to Resistance even Halo3 noob friendly controls..

Sucky controls = sucky controls. sucky controls =/= hardcore game. Otherwise games like gingerbread man are as hardcore as it gets.

Wtf is MP3 doing grouped together with KZ2 and Halo3? That game was a disgrace to the series.

Anywho. Halo 3 is still the FPS king.

Lemmings vs Sheep vs Cows

Why not just ask "which fanboy are you"?

[QUOTE="Guybrush_3"]

[QUOTE="___gamemaster__"]

Exactly.. I met many people who gave up KZ2 because they cant adjust to the controls and when played on elite version.. They got used to Resistance even Halo3 noob friendly controls..

Sucky controls = sucky controls. sucky controls =/= hardcore game. Otherwise games like gingerbread man are as hardcore as it gets.

[QUOTE="Guybrush_3"]

[QUOTE="___gamemaster__"]

Exactly.. I met many people who gave up KZ2 because they cant adjust to the controls and when played on elite version.. They got used to Resistance even Halo3 noob friendly controls..

zarshack

Sucky controls = sucky controls. sucky controls =/= hardcore game. Otherwise games like gingerbread man are as hardcore as it gets.

I hate dual analogue for FPSs in general.

[QUOTE="-Reggaeton-"][QUOTE="Dibdibdobdobo"] MP3 is not a FPS. FPA.Dibdibdobdobo

How the hell is killzone 2 winning? Im disappointed system wars :?

Stringerboy

[QUOTE="Guybrush_3"]

[QUOTE="___gamemaster__"]

Exactly.. I met many people who gave up KZ2 because they cant adjust to the controls and when played on elite version.. They got used to Resistance even Halo3 noob friendly controls..

zarshack

Sucky controls = sucky controls. sucky controls =/= hardcore game. Otherwise games like gingerbread man are as hardcore as it gets.

aiming is sucky in kz2.....and i have played it for more then 10 minutes

[QUOTE="Dibdibdobdobo"][QUOTE="-Reggaeton-"] FPA? Gimme a break. Its a FPS just like HL or anyother FPS game. Basically every FPS is an adventure in some way.JangoWuzHere

Calling MP3 a FPS is like calling Oblivion a hack and slash.

Calling MP3 a FPS is like calling Oblivion a hack and slash.

Guybrush_3

[QUOTE="JangoWuzHere"][QUOTE="Dibdibdobdobo"] So is Fallout a FPS ? Is Bioshock? Is Zelda (You can go into first person view)? The game is about exploration rather than blowing things to oblivion. Yes i will give you a break as you seem not know what you are on about.Dibdibdobdobo

oy whatever FPA.

Theirs no such thing as an FPA. However Future Farmers of America does exist:)

[QUOTE="Guybrush_3"]

Calling MP3 a FPS is like calling Oblivion a hack and slash.

Dibdibdobdobo

Considering I did way more jumping that shooting I would call it a first person platformer. (I went through maybe 10-15 clips and dropped the weapons as soon as I had the chance)

[QUOTE="Dibdibdobdobo"][QUOTE="-Reggaeton-"] FPA? Gimme a break. Its a FPS just like HL or anyother FPS game. Basically every FPS is an adventure in some way.JangoWuzHere

MP games are not pure FPS. There's no need to label every game as just one thing. Some games these days are hybrids. For example, Gamespot calls it Sci-fi FPS, and IGN calls it First-Person Action Adventure. Some sites say Action, some say First Person Adventure.

Wtf is MP3 doing grouped together with KZ2 and Halo3? That game was a disgrace to the series.

Anywho. Halo 3 is still the FPS king.

Samox

This here is the truth. No one can contest the fact that Halo is the most played FPS game. Oh and when it comes to content, geez, I won't even go there. As for Killzone 2, the game will be better in a lot of peoples head b/c of3 reasons. 1) They really suck at Halo 2) B/c the game is newer andthey feel it's better 3) You realy think that any AAA title game isn't going to have it's share of haters

Shouldn't we have some sort of PC representation here?

Anyway, I'll go with Killzone 2...because, no matter what anyone says, Metroid Prime 3 is not a FPS, it's an FPA.

I consider each a FPS (to be clear), despite heavy adventuring in some over others).

I would put them in this order:

1. Halo 3
2. Metroid Prime 3
3. Killzone 2

Killzone, while a great game, for me was not as fun to play as the other titles.