Gamesradar: PGR4 looks better than GT5

looks the same as the replay, here's a replay shot from the same guy

see you're a fanboy so you wont think gt5p looks good no matter what shot or vid you watch so there's no point in fighting with you, next

Look at these recent GT5P images from Gamersyde, in full 1080p, so there's no compression issue:

http://images.gamersyde.com/gallery/public/7898/1316_0003.jpg

http://images.gamersyde.com/gallery/public/7898/1316_0005.jpg

It really doesn't look that great. Jaggies (couldn't even smooth out the shadows), color blandness, uneven texturing, uneven lighting.

looks the same as the replay, here's a replay shot from the same guy

see you're a fanboy so you wont think gt5p looks good no matter what shot or vid you watch so there's no point in fighting with you, next

cobragt4

Whats so good looking abotu that?

heres a pic of gt5p with no enhancements and it looks almost like the so called bullshots

there you have it, that shot looks just as good as any press release shots shown so far. you can thank Forsete from the gaming-age boards for this pic

cobragt4

That looks screen is ugly man, here I'll tell you why in point form.

- The trees on the horizon look UGLY

- The trees on teh right look UGLY

- The trees on the left look UGLY

- The shadow on his glove looks UGLY

- Textures on the grass look UGLY

- Game has nice cars but UGLY environment and almost 0 FIZZICKS

- Not impressive.

- *Fanboy off*

lawl

Lemmings really are grasping at straws. GT5 looks far better than anything on the 360 and it always will

[QUOTE="whocares4peace"]

"Conclusion? It looks nice, but a tad sterile.The tracks in the game are very close to their real-life counterparts, just a little cleaner and with a touch of artistic license. We do long for some imperfections, though. PGR4 convincingly dirtied up its tracks over PGR3, whereas GT5P is more like Forza 2 in terms of clean lines. And it has to be said thatGT5Pstill looks very similar to PS2's Gran Turismo 4. To be honest, we were expecting a little more 'wow' from the game's environments, especially when most trees are still made up of two crossed polygons."

Serbiam

LMFAO! WTF....talk about being biased.

How in the blue hell does it look VERY similar to PS2's GT4...are they blind?

sorry, gotta be an idiot to take that seriously, or atleast with a straight face.

they mean the backgrounds, not the cars :roll:

if you read the entire artical

[QUOTE="3picuri3"][QUOTE="Cedmln"]

ITwas comparing PGR 4's environments to GT5 PROLOGUE's environments.

PGR4 also has a an empty clean lifeless track, which is the test track. GO LOOK IT UP.

Comparison failed.

GT 5 WILL have many city tracks.

heretrix

heh - nice try. pgr4 might have one, but GT5p has many lifeless tracks - no damage, screen tearing, no voice on launch, no private matches on launch.

yeah of course - at least one would hope. im talking about gt5p only

lawl

Lemmings really are grasping at straws. GT5 looks far better than anything on the 360 and it always will

the_h_bomb

GT5 final might - but GT5p, no way. jaggies and screen tearing + all the other issues like 2D trees, backdrops make it nowhere close to what you're saying. the cars alone in replay / photo mode maybe... but that's not gameplay is it.

[QUOTE="the_h_bomb"]

lawl

Lemmings really are grasping at straws. GT5 looks far better than anything on the 360 and it always will

3picuri3

GT5 final might - but GT5p, no way. jaggies and screen tearing + all the other issues like 2D trees, backdrops make it nowhere close to what you're saying. the cars alone in replay / photo mode maybe... but that's not gameplay is it.

Try harder.

[QUOTE="3picuri3"][QUOTE="the_h_bomb"]

lawl

Lemmings really are grasping at straws. GT5 looks far better than anything on the 360 and it always will

Super_Swagger

GT5 final might - but GT5p, no way. jaggies and screen tearing + all the other issues like 2D trees, backdrops make it nowhere close to what you're saying. the cars alone in replay / photo mode maybe... but that's not gameplay is it.

Try harder.

i don't need to try to convince you - it's what i know :) sorry, replay mode - you know what i meant. its confirmed to add post-processing such as FSAF FSAA Blur, and more. the in game shots are hardly as impressive - and very comparable to PGR4, which is why people who have previewed the game that aren't fanboys have said so on different websites.

you can tell me forever that it's the best thing in the world and looks better than any 360 game will ever - it'll just make me smile a bit wider :P

btw polly's a parrot. polys are polygons.

looks the same as the replay, here's a replay shot from the same guy

see you're a fanboy so you wont think gt5p looks good no matter what shot or vid you watch so there's no point in fighting with you, next

cobragt4

that looks pretty bad tbh

looks the same as the replay, here's a replay shot from the same guy

see you're a fanboy so you wont think gt5p looks good no matter what shot or vid you watch so there's no point in fighting with you, next

cobragt4

[QUOTE="mingo123"]so I was right after all :|

every cow hated me for this pic :lol:EmperorSupreme

[QUOTE="Super_Swagger"][QUOTE="3picuri3"][QUOTE="the_h_bomb"]

lawl

Lemmings really are grasping at straws. GT5 looks far better than anything on the 360 and it always will

3picuri3

GT5 final might - but GT5p, no way. jaggies and screen tearing + all the other issues like 2D trees, backdrops make it nowhere close to what you're saying. the cars alone in replay / photo mode maybe... but that's not gameplay is it.

Try harder.

i don't need to try to convince you - it's what i know :) sorry, replay mode - you know what i meant. its confirmed to add post-processing such as FSAF FSAA Blur, and more. the in game shots are hardly as impressive - and very comparable to PGR4, which is why people who have previewed the game that aren't fanboys have said so on different websites.

you can tell me forever that it's the best thing in the world and looks better than any 360 game will ever - it'll just make me smile a bit wider :P

btw polly's a parrot. polys are polygons.

Anybody can find low-res pics, that why I laugh at you and that "mingo" kid. He really thinks he's doing something. :lol:

Good day.

[QUOTE="3picuri3"][QUOTE="Super_Swagger"][QUOTE="3picuri3"][QUOTE="the_h_bomb"]

lawl

Lemmings really are grasping at straws. GT5 looks far better than anything on the 360 and it always will

Super_Swagger

GT5 final might - but GT5p, no way. jaggies and screen tearing + all the other issues like 2D trees, backdrops make it nowhere close to what you're saying. the cars alone in replay / photo mode maybe... but that's not gameplay is it.

Try harder.

i don't need to try to convince you - it's what i know :) sorry, replay mode - you know what i meant. its confirmed to add post-processing such as FSAF FSAA Blur, and more. the in game shots are hardly as impressive - and very comparable to PGR4, which is why people who have previewed the game that aren't fanboys have said so on different websites.

you can tell me forever that it's the best thing in the world and looks better than any 360 game will ever - it'll just make me smile a bit wider :P

btw polly's a parrot. polys are polygons.

Anybody can find low-res pics, that why I laugh at you and that "mingo" kid. He really thinks he's doing something. :lol:

Good day.

:lol: show me a high res pic then....and make sure you can see the environment coz i dotn want those shots with awesome car models and totally blureed environment :lol:

"Conclusion? It looks nice, but a tad sterile.The tracks in the game are very close to their real-life counterparts, just a little cleaner and with a touch of artistic license. We do long for some imperfections, though. PGR4 convincingly dirtied up its tracks over PGR3, whereas GT5P is more like Forza 2 in terms of clean lines. And it has to be said thatGT5Pstill looks very similar to PS2's Gran Turismo 4. To be honest, we were expecting a little more 'wow' from the game's environments, especially when most trees are still made up of two crossed polygons."

I dont really agree with them, especially the bolded part.

whocares4peace

Yeah I don't agree with that either.

[QUOTE="3picuri3"]

i don't need to try to convince you - it's what i know :) sorry, replay mode - you know what i meant. its confirmed to add post-processing such as FSAF FSAA Blur, and more. the in game shots are hardly as impressive - and very comparable to PGR4, which is why people who have previewed the game that aren't fanboys have said so on different websites.

you can tell me forever that it's the best thing in the world and looks better than any 360 game will ever - it'll just make me smile a bit wider :P

btw polly's a parrot. polys are polygons.

Super_Swagger

Anybody can find low-res pics, that why I laugh at you and that "mingo" kid. He really thinks he's doing something. :lol:

Good day.

The pics I pasted from gamersyde are in full 1080p resolution. 1920 x 1080. Why do they not look amazing?

http://www.gamersyde.com/news_6119_en.html

Look at the in-game screens, then look at the other screens. All the amazing GT5 images that we've seen aren't in-game, and that lineup of pics basically proves it. The actual in-game images look very different in quality. We've been fed bullshots.

And that picture Mingo pasted is real and is from GT5P. That same car and track is in the split-screen pic in that gamersyde link.

Look at these recent GT5P images from Gamersyde, in full 1080p, so there's no compression issue:

http://images.gamersyde.com/gallery/public/7898/1316_0003.jpg

http://images.gamersyde.com/gallery/public/7898/1316_0005.jpg

It really doesn't look that great. Jaggies (couldn't even smooth out the shadows), color blandness, uneven texturing, uneven lighting.

Zeliard9

Not working links ftl

really gt5p does indeed look like the press release pics that you all consider bullshots, the pics i posted prove it and if you disagree i suggest you go to lenscrafters right nowcobragt4

the pic you posted looks horrible, look at the horrible environment...oh well ur a hardcore hermit and you just have to make GT5 look better then 360 games dont you? geeeezzz why do hermit hates 360 THAT much....

I agree that PGR4 looks better, it's a amazing looking game, best graphics in a racer ever. Plus the motorbikes kick ass.

Best racer this generation. But Mario Kart Wii might be mroe fun :)

[QUOTE="whocares4peace"]

"Conclusion? It looks nice, but a tad sterile.The tracks in the game are very close to their real-life counterparts, just a little cleaner and with a touch of artistic license. We do long for some imperfections, though. PGR4 convincingly dirtied up its tracks over PGR3, whereas GT5P is more like Forza 2 in terms of clean lines. And it has to be said thatGT5Pstill looks very similar to PS2's Gran Turismo 4. To be honest, we were expecting a little more 'wow' from the game's environments, especially when most trees are still made up of two crossed polygons."

I dont really agree with them, especially the bolded part.

Wasdie

Yeah I don't agree with that either.

I totally agree with it, apart from the car upgrades and some minor visual improvements on the tracks (and i mean minor) it really does look at feel the same. keep in mind you never saw GTA4 at 1080p... i was definitely expecting more than the gameplay pics i've seen so far. that's what you get when a company decides its still ok to feed consumers bullshots.

i'm nothing, i dont have a ps3 nor do i have a performance pc. i plan to get a ps3 since i'm a gt fan. look, personally i dont like posting pics since they dont show how good a game really looks. vids are what show us how good a game looks. in motion gt5p looks better than any bullshot out there periodcobragt4

sry theres another cobragt on these forums who is a big hermit so i thought it was u

I agree that PGR4 looks better, it's a amazing looking game, best graphics in a racer ever. Plus the motorbikes kick ass.

Best racer this generation. But Mario Kart Wii might be mroe fun :)

M3tro1d

Indeed, PGR4 looks KILLER !!!!

[QUOTE="M3tro1d"]

I agree that PGR4 looks better, it's a amazing looking game, best graphics in a racer ever. Plus the motorbikes kick ass.

Best racer this generation. But Mario Kart Wii might be mroe fun :)

saolin323

Indeed, PGR4 looks KILLER !!!!

wow, those look as good as GT5! i didn't realize it was that good!

[QUOTE="saolin323"][QUOTE="M3tro1d"]

I agree that PGR4 looks better, it's a amazing looking game, best graphics in a racer ever. Plus the motorbikes kick ass.

Best racer this generation. But Mario Kart Wii might be mroe fun :)

shoeman12

Indeed, PGR4 looks KILLER !!!!

wow, those look as good as GT5! i didn't realize it was that good!

You are being mislead.

[QUOTE="shoeman12"][QUOTE="saolin323"][QUOTE="M3tro1d"]

I agree that PGR4 looks better, it's a amazing looking game, best graphics in a racer ever. Plus the motorbikes kick ass.

Best racer this generation. But Mario Kart Wii might be mroe fun :)

Cedmln

Indeed, PGR4 looks KILLER !!!!

wow, those look as good as GT5! i didn't realize it was that good!

You are being mislead.

yeah he is, this is what GT5P really looks like:

[QUOTE="shoeman12"][QUOTE="saolin323"][QUOTE="M3tro1d"]

I agree that PGR4 looks better, it's a amazing looking game, best graphics in a racer ever. Plus the motorbikes kick ass.

Best racer this generation. But Mario Kart Wii might be mroe fun :)

Cedmln

Indeed, PGR4 looks KILLER !!!!

wow, those look as good as GT5! i didn't realize it was that good!

You are being mislead.

Yep, I own PGR 4 and while it looks good, it doesnt look that good. Off-screen pics for the lose!!

When the weather is clear you can see jaggies, when its rainy you cant see them but sometimes while racing in the rain framerate dips below 20, very noticeable, sometimes unplayable.

gt5p looks too realistic for its own good

pretty close to the bullshots imo

hmm heres a replay shot

thought replays looked better than gameplay since more polys were add and the aa was bumped up, hmmm

all that detail with 16 cars on track and the game running 60fps, madness

is pd serious!

hummm....

GT5 is what...7 months after the release of PGR4..and it looks like that in-game...

thats funny...

Owned.

PGR4 and Fable 2 both look way better than GT5. Now it has been confirmed.

gt5p looks too realistic for its own good

cobragt4

Whoa that umm... that actually looks good.

Impossible! PGR4 is supposed to look better!

Someone please post PGR4 and Fable 2 screens that look better than this!

Somebody! Anybody!

Hurry! I can't look at these any more!

It's just... too... real....

[QUOTE="M3tro1d"]

I agree that PGR4 looks better, it's a amazing looking game, best graphics in a racer ever. Plus the motorbikes kick ass.

Best racer this generation. But Mario Kart Wii might be mroe fun :)

saolin323

Indeed, PGR4 looks KILLER !!!!

Offscreen + Photomode FTL.

Damage conrol the below

When in motion, the game doesn't look as good as Project Gotham Racing 4, as GT5P has the series' usual 'clean' look to it, like the sterile recreation of Monaco in GT3.

GT5 does not even look as good as PGR4 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

And it has to be said that GT5P still looks very similar to PS2's Gran Turismo 4. To be honest, we were expecting a little more 'wow' from the game's environments,especially when most trees are still made up of two crossed polygons.

The ultimate ABSOLUTE ownage is found in this article for PS3 graphics and GT5 !!!!

saolin323

I haven't played prologue on the PS3 but from what I have seen the environments of PGR4 seem to look better, and GT5P has much nicer looking vehicles. What I find impressive in PGR though is the weather changes, does GT have this now?

Saying GT5P looks like GT4 is a bit of an odd statement, but then again it has been said by somebody for nearly every next generation sequel of a game this gen and it probably has more to do with raised expectations from stupid levels of hype.

csliney

Well Said, I look at it as Environments=PGR4 by far, and GT5P=Cars by far(not too far though). And as you said the special effects of PGR are sweet