Gametrailers Top 10 FPS of All Time

[QUOTE="Jag85"]

I'm pretty sure MP influenced BioShock and other first-person action games that aren't following COD's lead.

Lucianu

System Shock 2 influenced Bioshock, actually a lot of people have argued that Bioshock is a rip-off of System Shock (note: not carbon copy).

Goldeneye..... CoD4........... Counter Strike............... in the top 3?

LAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAME!!!!!!!!!

No Quake but they put Unreal?

LAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAME!!!!!!!!!

OK list, would but whatever.

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"]

LINK

For the lazy

1. Goldeneye 007
2. Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
3. Counter Strike: Source
4. Half Life 2
5. Halo 3
6. Starseige: Tribes
7. Battlefield 2
8. Team Fortress 2
9. Doom
10. Unreal Tournament

Wasdie

Of all time? Goldeneye is overrated. It wasn't the best when it came out and it is one of the worst aging games ever. Halo 3 beating Halo 2 is a joke. CSS over 1.6, I coudl go either way. CoD 4, BF2, Doom, TF2, are all good choices. Half-LIfe 2 should be replaced by the original Half Life, and UT should be replaced by UT 99 or 2k4.

Goldeneye should be #10 on the list, if it makes it at all.

Tribes should be replaced by Tribes 2.

Heck here's what I would have made it...

1. Half-Life
2. Doom
3. CS:S (I like CSS far more than 1.6, but the argument could be made either way)
4. Tribes 2
5. Unreal Tournament 2k4
6. Battlefield 2
7. TF2
8. Quake 3 Arena (or Quake 1/2, I'm not sure which one so I'll put my favorite)
9. CoD 4
10. Goldeneye

Roughly that. I actually have a list of the top 64 FPSs of all time that I've been prepping for a SWs tourny.

Thank God someone decided to put Quake in. You're a good guy, Wasdie, a good guy. I still wouldn't put Counter Strike in the top 3. Your list needs more Halo though. As in, even if it's only #10 we still need to see Halo there. Preferably Combat Evolved, but Halo 2 and 3 are acceptable as well.

[QUOTE="Lucianu"]

[QUOTE="Jag85"]

I'm pretty sure MP influenced BioShock and other first-person action games that aren't following COD's lead.

PannicAtack

System Shock 2 influenced Bioshock, actually a lot of people have argued that Bioshock is a rip-off of System Shock (note: not carbon copy).

Yeah, I thought they were pretty open about it too.

I guess Killzone, Resistance, or Haze couldn't make the cut. LOL.

jimmypsn

They're not even the best FPS on the PS3 Lol

[QUOTE="Lucianu"]

[QUOTE="Jag85"]

I'm pretty sure MP influenced BioShock and other first-person action games that aren't following COD's lead.

PannicAtack

System Shock 2 influenced Bioshock, actually a lot of people have argued that Bioshock is a rip-off of System Shock (note: not carbon copy).

Man, f*ck. I forgot Bioshock is sort of a spiritual succesor to System Shock. That is what i should have wrote, not a rip-off.

As a former gametrailers community member Before looking at thread. i already know list is full of bad games and guess i was right. Gametrailers's Shane has extremely low standard in gaming. i mean COD4 at no2??? and goldeneye at no1?? WTF??? theres better list 1. STALKER 2. Half life 3. Deus Ex 4. Riddick EFBB 5. Crysis 6. Return to castle wolfenstein 7. Rainbow Six Raven Shield 8. Ghost Recon 9. Metro 2033 10. Team Fortress 2SNIPER4321

This guy. I like this guy.

No Metroid Prime? The f*ck is this?

Master_ShakeXXX

I don't understand how they can put Half Life 2 over the original.

[QUOTE="Master_ShakeXXX"]

No Metroid Prime? The f*ck is this?

dreman999

FPA doesn't make sense. It would imply that the game has no to little action which is false.

No MW2? oh so its that way huh? okay then the list sucks!

[QUOTE="SNIPER4321"]As a former gametrailers community member Before looking at thread. i already know list is full of bad games and guess i was right. Gametrailers's Shane has extremely low standard in gaming. i mean COD4 at no2??? and goldeneye at no1?? WTF??? theres better list 1. STALKER 2. Half life 3. Deus Ex 4. Riddick EFBB 5. Crysis 6. Return to castle wolfenstein 7. Rainbow Six Raven Shield 8. Ghost Recon 9. Metro 2033 10. Team Fortress 2hedgy1

This guy. I like this guy.

I feel sorry for you.

That's.. actually quite a sensible list. It's not my top 10, but it's reasonable.

Not what I expected!

I still have yet to play Goldeneye.

[QUOTE="Master_ShakeXXX"]

No Metroid Prime? The f*ck is this?

dreman999

dafuq is an FPA?

That's not a genre that exists man

[QUOTE="dreman999"][QUOTE="Master_ShakeXXX"]

No Metroid Prime? The f*ck is this?

NeonNinja

dafuq is an FPA?

That's not a genre that exists man

Technically first person point and click adventure games (like Myst and Riven) disprove your point, but whatever! :P

Perfect Dark on N64 is better than Goldeneye 007 in every conceivable way

Goldeneye was great for its time, but once games like Halo hit it was really apparent just how terrible the controls were. I don't think it's appropriate to give it the top spot, but definitely some recognition.

However the key thing to note on this list is that we see Halo 3, and not any other Halo games. It's good to see the Halo game with the greatest multiplayer getting the recognition it deserves.

This is how the list should be:

:x

1. Call of Duty: MW2
2. Call of Duty 4
3. Call of Duty: MW3
4. Call of Duty: Black Ops 2
5. Call of Duty: Black Ops
6. Call of Duty: World At War
7. Counter Strike
8. Killzone 2
9. Killzone 3
10. Crysis

[QUOTE="NeonNinja"]

[QUOTE="dreman999"] It's not an fps. It's a fpa.organic_machine

dafuq is an FPA?

That's not a genre that exists man

Technically first person point and click adventure games (like Myst and Riven) disprove your point, but whatever! :P

Exactly! Whatever! :P

This is how the list should be:

:x

1. Call of Duty: MW2
2. Call of Duty 4
3. Call of Duty: MW3
4. Call of Duty: Black Ops 2
5. Call of Duty: Black Ops
6. Call of Duty: World At War
7. Counter Strike
8. Killzone 2
9. Killzone 3
10. Crysis

finalstar2007

I like this list.

Remove Crysis and Counter Strike though.

Put more Call of Duty on it, like Call of Duty 3 and top it off with the newest Medal of Honor.

That way we can REALLY piss off SNIPER.

Honestly the list is OK. I would have Halo CE in there instead of Halo 3, Half Life 1 instead of 2 etc. I think its to difficult to make a list of absolutes without ignoring the "better" games that come out today.

I think my Top 5 FPS games would be not in a particular order but just games that have effected the industry massively are

1. Half Life (Arguably THE most complete FPS ever which spawned C:SS and TF mods)

2. Halo CE (Probably the most important console exclusive to come out in recent memory)

3. Call of Duty 4 (Birth game to the most popular FPS series ever?)

4. Quake (The Grandad of tournament FPS? that or Unreal, whichever one came first)

5. Battlefield 1942 , (Brought PC the most complete war-fare multiplayer series)

Its difficult because when you make a list you miss out games like Dues X, Doom, etc. So I think ideally you need to concentrate on firstly what the game did, how well it played and then what it brought to the industry. Probably Doom should be up there considering it was the great grandad of FPS games.

This is how the list should be:

:x

1. Call of Duty: MW2
2. Call of Duty 4
3. Call of Duty: MW3
4. Call of Duty: Black Ops 2
5. Call of Duty: Black Ops
6. Call of Duty: World At War
7. Counter Strike
8. Killzone 2
9. Killzone 3
10. Crysis

finalstar2007

Your list is bad and you should feel bad :|

That list is so bad it gave me cancer.

[QUOTE="finalstar2007"]

This is how the list should be:

:x

1. Call of Duty: MW2
2. Call of Duty 4
3. Call of Duty: MW3
4. Call of Duty: Black Ops 2
5. Call of Duty: Black Ops
6. Call of Duty: World At War
7. Counter Strike
8. Killzone 2
9. Killzone 3
10. Crysis

AdobeArtist

Your list is bad and you should feel bad :|

This is how the list should be:

:x

1. Call of Duty: MW2
2. Call of Duty 4
3. Call of Duty: MW3
4. Call of Duty: Black Ops 2
5. Call of Duty: Black Ops
6. Call of Duty: World At War
7. Counter Strike
8. Killzone 2
9. Killzone 3
10. Crysis

finalstar2007

This one is more PG for the kid who modded me for the previous .gif

Problem with the #1 spot is that Goldeneye was great during it's generation, but is awful by todays standards. Games like Halo HL2, and CS:S are all still great by todays standards.

I personally put CS:S or 1.6 up there as #1. What other game is still played with a faithful community this long after release like CS?

Mastershake, your sig is even more terrible than 90% of users here. change your sig. its truely disgustingSNIPER4321

Lets hear your Top 10 FPS heeweeeeee

Pretty sure it was CS 1.6 in the video, not CS:S. Also, Goldeneye is a bit outdated these days, but w/e I can recognize it's impact.

It's not a terrible list. I take issue with a few things, though: Halo 2 should be there over Halo 3. Halo 2 had better maps and pretty much invented FPS multiplayer on consoles. Every console FPS today (and console online in general) owes something to Halo 2. And if we're going by influence, it should be CE because it basically invented the modern console FPS. A Quake game should be on there simply on principle. Quake had a huge impact, like it or not. The list should probably be called "most influential" instead of best. But it's not bad, and they scored mad props for pulling Tribes on there when no one seems to remember that series exists.DarkLink77

I'd say Quake 3 should go there because it's just the most skillful online FPS I have attempted to play.

And yeah, Halo 3 over 2 or 1 is quite baffling, but over all it's a good list that doesn't succumb to listing listing just obvious games or avoiding them entirely.

Not a bad list but Halo 3 needs to get of that list now! Replace it with Perfect Dark or Halo: CE.

No MW2?

finalstar2007

Pretty good list. I like all of those games. c:

[QUOTE="Master_ShakeXXX"]

[QUOTE="SNIPER4321"] my avatar is bestSNIPER4321

I wasn't talking about your avatar. And are you the little son of a b*tch that's been reporting my sigs? I am going out of my way to provide SW with glorious eye candy goodness and you just wanna crap on that because your balls haven't dropped yet? Shame on you.

I played fps before fatal1ty aka johnathan wendel his first game was doom2 which released in 1995 after doom on jaguar in 1994.doominventedfps