Gears 3 will retro lancer Uncharted 3 in the ***

[QUOTE="ShadowNinja87"]360 fans are the only ones wanting Uncharted 3 to fail because it's a ps3 exclusive and Uncharted 2 got a crap load of awards. And they don't want it to be better than their exclusive because Gear 3 is the only exclusive they all this WHOLE year. LOL while Sony has 7 exclusives this year. mztazmz

Very true, I was wondering why the lems seem to be hyping Gears3 to hell and back. Yeah it's prewtty much all that's left as far as shooter games for 360. If it doesn't outscore U3, system wars is gonna be full of very angry people:)

Uncharted 3 looks boss

Gears looks CEO

I liked the part where you point out where Gears 3 keeping it pure. No killstreaks, perks, kickbacks or any of that nonsense. If only they would take it one step further and make a playlist with no power weapons or the ability to plant frags. I'm no longer going to partake in these UC3 vs Gears 3 threads. I know I'll spend 5 times the amount of time in Gears 3 mp than UC3's, It's just people try say that part of the simplicity of Gears is a negative lol. Gears 3 is staying the way it is because it's always been popular online where UC2 was a graveayrd after 2 months so ND had to change it into CoD and give us real players a sub playlist.

I liked the part where you point out where Gears 3 keeping it pure. No killstreaks, perks, kickbacks or any of that nonsense. If only they would take it one step further and make a playlist with no power weapons or the ability to plant frags. I'm no longer going to partake in these UC3 vs Gears 3 threads. I know I'll spend 5 times the amount of time in Gears 3 mp than UC3's, It's just people try say that part of the simplicity of Gears is a negative lol. Gears 3 is staying the way it is because it's always been popular online where UC2 was a graveayrd after 2 months so ND had to change it into CoD and give us real players a sub playlist.

Grawse

[QUOTE="Grawse"]

I liked the part where you point out where Gears 3 keeping it pure. No killstreaks, perks, kickbacks or any of that nonsense. If only they would take it one step further and make a playlist with no power weapons or the ability to plant frags. I'm no longer going to partake in these UC3 vs Gears 3 threads. I know I'll spend 5 times the amount of time in Gears 3 mp than UC3's, It's just people try say that part of the simplicity of Gears is a negative lol. Gears 3 is staying the way it is because it's always been popular online where UC2 was a graveayrd after 2 months so ND had to change it into CoD and give us real players a sub playlist.

TrapJak

grawse was over doing it but he did hit the nail. stll fun tho

All aboard the Uncharted 3 hate train!

First stop, 360 fantasy land.

15strong

[QUOTE="lightleggy"][QUOTE="slarkyslark"] hahahhaha no. It will be lucky to have 1/4 of the population of gears :Dslarkyslark

"cover is mostly used only to regain health. You rarely shoot from cover. And if you do, you'd end up screwed by someone from a high vantage point, or a stealth kill. It's cumbersome and too slow to detach yourself from cover (especially when a grenade is thrown your way, they blow within 2 seconds!). Too slow to pop out and aim compared to Gears. It's simply more responsive and snappier in Gears 3. Cover in Gears 3 feels like a true component to the game and a necessary mechanic to win a match. Most of the firefights in Uncharted 3 are just chumps standing in front of each other while ADS. Don't believe me? Watch the top plays of the week. Oh, and the detestable melee system. It's almost like Halo (except Reach's melee system actually works). People ignore cover, run up to one another shooting from the hip, followed by a gun butt (which has a laughable, goofy animation to begin with). The lunging is sometimes as bad as COD."

So much truth in this portion of your post that noone itt has even attempted to argue otherwise,:lol:

MFDOOM1983

Treal must be angry because he got his neck snapped one to many times it's okay I understand not everyone is good at UC3 multiplayer!!! :D All kidding a side while their are some definite issues with the melee that need to be sorted out by ND by no means is it detestable. What do you think beta's are for to sort out the problems and bugs before the game launches. As for using cover I never really had a problem with it and it has saved my ass quite a lot. I used cover to blind fire or take out an opponent by popping out a lot in the beta. Is the mutiplayer perfect yet? No but it still has a while to get straightend out and while it had issue's it also had a lot of good things happening too!

Campaign will be better in UC3. Co-op will be better in Gears 3. Multiplayer will be better in Gears 3. Graphics will be much better in UC3 (gears uses the same BS engine, why even hyping thing game for its graphics... we aren't in 06). True story.silversix_

FYI U3 uses an Updated U2 engine which is a modified U1 engine

:lol: You posted this in system wars!

:P

Anyways I agree. I enjoyed the UC3 beta but I just had more fun with the Gears 3 beta. I did like Adventure mode though. :3

Calling it now...

Gears 3 = 9.0

Uncharted = 8.5

yeah, just that like I said: it most likely wont be better than the 2nd one. and I dont really like how UC is turning out to ridiculousness...in that boat e3 gameplay we saw, drake was crushed by a boat part that was definitly over 1 ton, and it fell from like 10 meters, it should have squashed him like a cockroach yet the guy doesnt even falls unconscious...

I'm buying both on day 1. Because that is what a job allows you to do ;)

yeah, just that like I said: it most likely wont be better than the 2nd one. and I dont really like how UC is turning out to ridiculousness...in that boat e3 gameplay we saw, drake was crushed by a boat part that was definitly over 1 ton, and it fell from like 10 meters, it should have squashed him like a cockroach yet the guy doesnt even falls unconscious...

LikeI care, they both more than qualify for a day one for me, and both will most likely score AAA.

Anyways, I view Uncharted 3 more as an action/adventure, where Gears 3 is shooter.

This is Treal lashing out for the severe pwnage dished out by Hype a few nights ago, so its best to let this thread slide, it was made in anger:P

[QUOTE="TREAL_Since"]

Syk0_k03r

Nice opinion though.

I really haven't been impressed with either of them.

Wasdie

Not even the water man? NOT even the water!!!?

I think that area has a good gameplay opportunity in using the sixasis to keep drake balanced...i doubt it will happen though.

"cover is mostly used only to regain health. You rarely shoot from cover. And if you do, you'd end up screwed by someone from a high vantage point, or a stealth kill. It's cumbersome and too slow to detach yourself from cover (especially when a grenade is thrown your way, they blow within 2 seconds!). Too slow to pop out and aim compared to Gears. It's simply more responsive and snappier in Gears 3. Cover in Gears 3 feels like a true component to the game and a necessary mechanic to win a match. Most of the firefights in Uncharted 3 are just chumps standing in front of each other while ADS. Don't believe me? Watch the top plays of the week. Oh, and the detestable melee system. It's almost like Halo (except Reach's melee system actually works). People ignore cover, run up to one another shooting from the hip, followed by a gun butt (which has a laughable, goofy animation to begin with). The lunging is sometimes as bad as COD."

So much truth in this portion of your post that noone itt has even attempted to argue otherwise,:lol:

MFDOOM1983

I highly doubt Gears 3 will outscore Uncharted 3. Nonstop-Madness

Ya i agree maybe duke nukem but not uncharted. uncharted to recieve 10 and gears to recieve 8

Why are either of these games being compared to each other anyway? Uncharted is an adventure game with shooter elements, and Gears of War is a straight up shooter. So if Uncharted had better gunplay, it'd pretty much do the following:

1. Make Gears of War look hilarious in that a game that IS a shooter has worse gunplay than one that isn't.

2. Make Uncharted look like it's going in the wrong direction, because having active reload and laser cannons isn't for the type of game it is.

Seriously, the only reason I can think of that these games are being compared is because their both in 3rd person. It's just like arguing Mirrors Edge vs. COD4 because they both have guns and are in 1st person.

[QUOTE="slarkyslark"][QUOTE="lightleggy"] ok how is the population of an online game definer of its quality? and why do people always say like "LOL THIS GAME SUCKS ONLY 200K PEOPLE PLAYING ONLINE WHILE THERE ARE 5 MILLIONS IN COD!!" even with 500 players you'd be able to find a game in less than 10 seconds.tormentos

LOL why no mention that Gears 1 outscored, no destroyed UC1 at Meta and here and UC2 outscored Gears 2 by .5 here and .3 at Meta. Oh yeah it's because you don't like the fact Gears is a AAA series Uncharted not so much.

This is Treal lashing out for the severe pwnage dished out by Hype a few nights ago, so its best to let this thread slide, it was made in anger:P

Zaibach

I do agree that Uncharted does need another year. I felt it needed a lot more polish in the beta. But then again, it is a beta.

Probably the beta didnt help I havent played it but, going by ppl feedback, its not that impressive. Everyone knows it will be a great singleplayer experience anyway.PAL360

:lol:

I find it funny that people are taking this guy's posts seriously. He's obviously just doing it for the lulz...

LOL why no mention that Gears 1 outscored, no destroyed UC1 at Meta and here and UC2 outscored Gears 2 by .5 here and .3 at Meta. Oh yeah it's because you don't like the fact Gears is a AAA series Uncharted not so much.Ultra_Combo

[QUOTE="Ultra_Combo"]LOL why no mention that Gears 1 outscored, no destroyed UC1 at Meta and here and UC2 outscored Gears 2 by .5 here and .3 at Meta. Oh yeah it's because you don't like the fact Gears is a AAA series Uncharted not so much.tormentos

My argument was Gears is a AAA series Uncharted is not , there's not reason to argue you about unless you have a problem with facts. And Gears outscored UC1 by 1.6 here thats what I called getting destroyed.

[QUOTE="tormentos"][QUOTE="Ultra_Combo"]LOL why no mention that Gears 1 outscored, no destroyed UC1 at Meta and here and UC2 outscored Gears 2 by .5 here and .3 at Meta. Oh yeah it's because you don't like the fact Gears is a AAA series Uncharted not so much.Ultra_Combo

My argument was Gears is a AAA series Uncharted is not , there's not reason to argue you about unless you have a problem with facts. And Gears outscored UC1 by 1.6 here thats what I called getting destroyed.

Argh Treal!

Gears 3 MP looks clunky just like the first 2. COGS still move like Arnold when they are'nt rolling.

I'll leave the graphics alone for now.

Do beware of my Hermit power! I'm prepared to punish my brethren!

have you seen the gameplay for both games? all you do in gears is hide behind a rock ALL game. uncharted you jump buildings, zipline on ropes while shooting, snap necks, climb walls, and do epic kills. and i know gears of war will have more sales because its the ONLY thing coming for the xbox in the past 3 years LOL.

NEXT!!!

Um, isnt TREAL the same guy who hyped the UC3 beta and liked it?

Joke topic guys :D.

[QUOTE="15strong"]

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

I think no one denies that Uncharted 3 had a better E3 presentation than Gears 3.

PAL360

Somehow Uncharetd has become an automatic flop around here. And I can't figure out why.

Probably the beta didnt help! I havent played it but, going by ppl feedback, it´s not that impressive. Everyone knows it will be a great singleplayer experience anyway.

[QUOTE="Ultra_Combo"]

[QUOTE="tormentos"] How can a game that doesn't even have a full point over another game destroy it.? Uncharted 1 scored 88% Gears 94% let me tell you this,Uncharted 1 did not had multiplaying,and even so landed 88%. lol. Uncharted 2 is higher score on Gameranking and Meta than Any xbox 360 exclusive,Halo 3,Halo Reach,Forza,Gears you name them not a single 360 exclusive is higher rated than Uncharted 2,beats your whole argument of not been AAA so much.tormentos

My argument was Gears is a AAA series Uncharted is not , there's not reason to argue you about unless you have a problem with facts. And Gears outscored UC1 by 1.6 here thats what I called getting destroyed.

Were are we oh yeah GAMESPOT where Gears 1 beat uncharted by 1.6 points , you wanna use Meta that fine it still beat UC1. Again my argument was Gears is a better series , Mad ? Deal with it.

[QUOTE="tormentos"][QUOTE="Ultra_Combo"]

My argument was Gears is a AAA series Uncharted is not , there's not reason to argue you about unless you have a problem with facts. And Gears outscored UC1 by 1.6 here thats what I called getting destroyed.

Ultra_Combo

Were are we oh yeah GAMESPOT where Gears 1 beat uncharted by 1.6 points , you wanna use Meta that fine it still beat UC1. Again my argument was Gears is a better series , Mad ? Deal with it.

Um, isnt TREAL the same guy who hyped the UC3 beta and liked it?

Joke topic guys :D.

TrapJak

[QUOTE="Ultra_Combo"]

[QUOTE="tormentos"] No it did not. Uncharted 89.70% Gears of War 93.89% Not even .5 dude even less 1.6. http://www.gamerankings.com/ Again waiting for you to find me a 360 game which ever you like exclusive higher rated than Uncharted 2 on 360 good voyage.1stPlaceWinner

Were are we oh yeah GAMESPOT where Gears 1 beat uncharted by 1.6 points , you wanna use Meta that fine it still beat UC1. Again my argument was Gears is a better series , Mad ? Deal with it.

Do you know that the word "SERIES" means LOL , trying to sweep UC1 under the rug like like Tormentos :lol: UC2 has a .3 higher average then Gears 1 wow such a clearcut domination. The Gears of war SERIES is a more critically acclaimed SERIES then the UC SERIES, and is AAA UC Series is not it must hurt , or maybe you didn't see I said SERIES so I highlighted it for easy viewing thanks. :)

In addition, it boggles me how some people try to describe Uncharted's gun play as clunky and slow and then use Gears of War for their comparison LOL...

It's like people here grasp for straws here ALL THE TIME. I just don't get it. This is coming from someone who played both betas. Uncharted 3 definitely got me more hooked and I think that it comes down nothing more than the variety of the game and the personality. By variety I just mean that there are so many ways to own people in the game and there's more than you can do other than running into cover and hiding. You have to remember that this is a third person shooter/platformer/cover based all in one.

And yes even though TREAL feels that cover is pointless, he must be using it in the wrong situations. I popped in and out of cover to get kills before plenty of times. I've blind fired plenty of times. That aspect of the game is there and it's used, just not to the extent of Gears of War, which is all that you do in that game.

I mentioned personality and I got a lot of that from the Beta of UC3 due to the whole customization aspect, treasure collecting, Unchated TV (to see awesome plays), the characters, the beautiful and varied maps, the sound effects and music, and of course the fact you can choose like 12 different taunts AND high five your buddy. It's all really great and nothing seems out of place.

The argument that TREAL made about the replay value comparison between Uncharted 3 and Gears of War 3 is a joke. Uncharted 3 is the game with all the leveling, varied game modes that involve a ton of platforming and teamwork (see plunder), and tons of collecting for customizating your character. Also there's Uncharted TV integrated into it and I'm sure people will be aiming to get their clip up there for plays of the week. I'm leaving some other things out, but you really think that GeoW 3 will actually stomp Uncharted 3 in multiplayer replay value? The main things that Gears of War 3 has that helps it is 4 player campaign mode (which will most likely not even touch Uncharted 3's single player, let's be honest here guys, lol). Still, that's awesome and Gears of War is able to be designed around that. The other thing are the bots you can play against. To me that, is not enough reason for GeoW 3 to kill UC3 in multiplayer replay value when you consider the fact that Uncharted 3 has taken the CoD route with all the unlockables and customization plus pretty creative game modes and innovate multiplayer ideas like powerplays, etc.

In addition, it boggles me how some people try to describe Uncharted's gun play as clunky and slow and then use Gears of War for their comparison LOL...

It's like people here grasp for straws here ALL THE TIME. I just don't get it. This is coming from someone who played both betas. Uncharted 3 definitely got me more hooked and I think that it comes down nothing more than the variety of the game and the personality. By variety I just mean that there are so many ways to own people in the game and there's more than you can do other than running into cover and hiding. You have to remember that this is a third person shooter/platformer/cover based all in one.

And yes even though TREAL feels that cover is pointless, he must be using it in the wrong situations. I popped in and out of cover to get kills before plenty of times. I've blind fired plenty of times. That aspect of the game is there and it's used, just not to the extent of Gears of War, which is all that you do in that game.

I mentioned personality and I got a lot of that from the Beta of UC3 due to the whole customization aspect, treasure collecting, Unchated TV (to see awesome plays), the characters, the beautiful and varied maps, the sound effects and music, and of course the fact you can choose like 12 different taunts AND high five your buddy. It's all really great and nothing seems out of place.

The argument that TREAL made about the replay value comparison between Uncharted 3 and Gears of War 3 is a joke. Uncharted 3 is the game with all the leveling, varied game modes that involve a ton of platforming and teamwork (see plunder), and tons of collecting for customizating your character. Also there's Uncharted TV integrated into it and I'm sure people will be aiming to get their clip up there for plays of the week. I'm leaving some other things out, but you really think that GeoW 3 will actually stomp Uncharted 3 in multiplayer replay value? The main things that Gears of War 3 has that helps it is 4 player campaign mode (which will most likely not even touch Uncharted 3's single player, let's be honest here guys, lol). Still, that's awesome and Gears of War is able to be designed around that. The other thing are the bots you can play against. To me that, is not enough reason for GeoW 3 to kill UC3 in multiplayer replay value when you consider the fact that Uncharted 3 has taken the CoD route with all the unlockables and customization plus pretty creative game modes and innovate multiplayer ideas like powerplays, etc.

mD-

Yes that's what we need more games trying to be COD which seems like what PS3 Devs are trying to do ie KZ3 , UC3. No thanks if I want to jump and platform I wil Play COD not a game that tries to rip it off.

[QUOTE="mD-"]

In addition, it boggles me how some people try to describe Uncharted's gun play as clunky and slow and then use Gears of War for their comparison LOL...

It's like people here grasp for straws here ALL THE TIME. I just don't get it. This is coming from someone who played both betas. Uncharted 3 definitely got me more hooked and I think that it comes down nothing more than the variety of the game and the personality. By variety I just mean that there are so many ways to own people in the game and there's more than you can do other than running into cover and hiding. You have to remember that this is a third person shooter/platformer/cover based all in one.

And yes even though TREAL feels that cover is pointless, he must be using it in the wrong situations. I popped in and out of cover to get kills before plenty of times. I've blind fired plenty of times. That aspect of the game is there and it's used, just not to the extent of Gears of War, which is all that you do in that game.

I mentioned personality and I got a lot of that from the Beta of UC3 due to the whole customization aspect, treasure collecting, Unchated TV (to see awesome plays), the characters, the beautiful and varied maps, the sound effects and music, and of course the fact you can choose like 12 different taunts AND high five your buddy. It's all really great and nothing seems out of place.

The argument that TREAL made about the replay value comparison between Uncharted 3 and Gears of War 3 is a joke. Uncharted 3 is the game with all the leveling, varied game modes that involve a ton of platforming and teamwork (see plunder), and tons of collecting for customizating your character. Also there's Uncharted TV integrated into it and I'm sure people will be aiming to get their clip up there for plays of the week. I'm leaving some other things out, but you really think that GeoW 3 will actually stomp Uncharted 3 in multiplayer replay value? The main things that Gears of War 3 has that helps it is 4 player campaign mode (which will most likely not even touch Uncharted 3's single player, let's be honest here guys, lol). Still, that's awesome and Gears of War is able to be designed around that. The other thing are the bots you can play against. To me that, is not enough reason for GeoW 3 to kill UC3 in multiplayer replay value when you consider the fact that Uncharted 3 has taken the CoD route with all the unlockables and customization plus pretty creative game modes and innovate multiplayer ideas like powerplays, etc.

Ultra_Combo

Yes that's what we need more games trying to be COD which seems like what PS3 Devs are trying to do ie KZ3 , UC3. No thanks if I want to jump and platform I wil Play COD not a game that tries to rip it off.

Are you really being serious with this post? Um if you would have played the beta you wouldn't have made this post. ND did what they're best at doing. Polishing up great games that bring in elements from other games that we've seen before. I know this might be shocking for you, but the whole treasure collecting aspect really integrates well into a game like Uncharted. It adds to replay value and it adds more personality to the game.

Multiplayer wise, Uncharted is to Gears what Super Smash Bros Brawl is to Street Fighter 3 First Strike. Even then, perhaps I'm being generous because I doubt the longevity of UC's multiplayer. Uncharted's multiplayer is fun & has its perks, but Gears of War is not only fun, but balanced & very strategic if you have two good sides. If past games are anything to go by, it also has a very strong online community; but that is the norm for most big 360 exclusives.