So since multiplats,Wii and PC games are excluded...
God of War beat Alan Wake and Heavy Rain? Wow what an accomplishment...
This topic is locked from further discussion.
So since multiplats,Wii and PC games are excluded...
God of War beat Alan Wake and Heavy Rain? Wow what an accomplishment...
lol. How can we narrow it down any further than that? Hmm. Best selling HD exclusive with nine characters in it's title that holds a mature rating that launched specifically on March 16th, 2010? :PIts also the best selling HD exclusive that launched on March 16th 2010.
Fizzman
this. nothing special. not much "HD excluvies" out anywaySo they put exclusive so they can ignore RDR beating it, then put HD so they can ignore NSMB beating it. LOL
It won't last either way, Halo Reach is coming.
cloudff7tm
A fantastic game with great sales, bring it on. I personally dont see why people are buying the game though, as it screams weekend rental to me (not an insult to the game quality, I think the same thing about Alan Wake). designer-Its certainly good enough to keep in your collection, but I bought it, beat it and loved every minute of it, and Goozex'd it with the intent of getting it again cheap and used down the line.
Can someone explain why NSBM is on the list?SuperNecroIt's a popular franchise, and it's a great game. :|
So is Gran Turismo 5...So they put exclusive so they can ignore RDR beating it, then put HD so they can ignore NSMB beating it. LOL
It won't last either way, Halo Reach is coming.
cloudff7tm
Can someone explain why NSBM is on the list?SuperNecro
It's a Wii game, starring Mario, and has quality. :|
And lol @ best selling HD exclusive. You're trying to ignore the Wii and at the same time call on 360 for not having a top-selling exclusive.
System Wars
So they put exclusive so they can ignore RDR beating it, then put HD so they can ignore NSMB beating it. LOL
It won't last either way, Halo Reach is coming.
Kinda reminds me of the "if you ignore the Wii and 360, the PS3 is leading" :P Also reminds me of "If you ignore the PC, it's a 360 exclusive" :PSo is Gran Turismo 5...[QUOTE="cloudff7tm"]
So they put exclusive so they can ignore RDR beating it, then put HD so they can ignore NSMB beating it. LOL
It won't last either way, Halo Reach is coming.
blazinpuertoroc
Yeah, I have been told that about 16 times already. Why do you guys keep telling me this? GT5, Halo Reach, and Starcraft 2 are all contenders foe best selling exclusive of 2010 ignoring the Wii. :roll:
HD exclusive, huh what? A blockbuster selling more in a month when no other blockbusters were released, news at 11.
[QUOTE="Sp4rtan_3"][QUOTE="TintedEyes"] and there it is, "exclusive fps", specific like hd exclusive yet people only laugh at hd exclusiveTintedEyesNever answerd my question and this person narrows it down further to the 1st half of 2010 which is even more pathetic. Halo 3 is the best selling console FPS this ENTIRE generation no narrowing it down there :wink: its saying for the year so far just like halo 3 is the best selling console fps so far this gen so it is narrowing Um no.
Saying a game is the best selling ALL gen is way different then saying The game is best selling HD EXCLUSIVE game IN THE 1ST HALF. Because Halo 3 is the TOP seller THIS GEN while GoW3 is the top seller of nothing. Nothing will outsell halo 3 this gen except ANOTHER Halo (that will probably be reach)
Still waiting on my answer btw :wink:
[QUOTE="TintedEyes"][QUOTE="Sp4rtan_3"] Never answerd my question and this person narrows it down further to the 1st half of 2010 which is even more pathetic. Halo 3 is the best selling console FPS this ENTIRE generation no narrowing it down there :wink:Sp4rtan_3its saying for the year so far just like halo 3 is the best selling console fps so far this gen so it is narrowing Um no. Saying a game is the best selling ALL gen is way different then saying The game is best selling HD EXCLUSIVE game IN THE 1ST HALF. Because Halo 3 is the TOP seller THIS GEN while GoW3 is the top seller of nothing. Still waiting on my answer btw :wink: actually halo 3 isnt the best selling game this gen so what are you talking about?
[QUOTE="Sp4rtan_3"][QUOTE="TintedEyes"] its saying for the year so far just like halo 3 is the best selling console fps so far this gen so it is narrowingTintedEyesUm no. Saying a game is the best selling ALL gen is way different then saying The game is best selling HD EXCLUSIVE game IN THE 1ST HALF. Because Halo 3 is the TOP seller THIS GEN while GoW3 is the top seller of nothing. Still waiting on my answer btw :wink: actually halo 3 isnt the best selling game this gen so what are you talking about? When it comes to exclusive Console FPS Halo 3 is the best selling this entire generation, you know exactly what im talking about. And im still waiting on my original question that you conveniently haven't answered :roll:
[QUOTE="TintedEyes"][QUOTE="Sp4rtan_3"] When it comes to exclusive Console FPS Halo 3 is the best selling this entire generation, you know exactly what im talking about. Sp4rtan_3"exclusive console fps" ah it seems you are narrowing it down like this guy is, your no better, and theres my point, thanks It seems you dont understand that a game being the BEST the entire generation is different then a game not being the best at anything. :roll: :lol: You can dodge and try and make excuses all you want, it still doesn't answer the question I asked you 2 pages back (that you haven't answered ) actually god of war3 is the best selling hd exclusive this year, see its the best if you narrow just like you did :)
Crackdown 2 is the best selling HD exclusive sandbox game this year. And its been out for less than a month!!!
see how easy it is to make any game look like a huge success if you narrow the category enough.
[QUOTE="nervmeister"]And that's what matters most, right? :roll:[QUOTE="finalstar2007"]the chart also states that not a single 360 exclusive made it to the top 10. djsifer01
Seriously, was that even necessary to include?
Its system wars, why would he not include it?Jesus Christ. Just because the board is called System Wars doesn't mean one has to play the SW "game" in every post.
[QUOTE="Sp4rtan_3"][QUOTE="TintedEyes"] "exclusive console fps" ah it seems you are narrowing it down like this guy is, your no better, and theres my point, thanksTintedEyesIt seems you dont understand that a game being the BEST the entire generation is different then a game not being the best at anything. :roll: :lol: You can dodge and try and make excuses all you want, it still doesn't answer the question I asked you 2 pages back (that you haven't answered ) actually god of war3 is the best selling hd exclusive this year, see its the best if you narrow just like you did :) And how is that important ? When in 2 months its going to get trampled by Halo: Reach. (which has a chance of dethroning Halo 3 as the Console FPS king)
This is the most ridiculous fanboy logic ive seen to try and make GoW look better then it actually it :lol:. Lets throw HD in their so the Wii wont apply :roll: Lets throw Exclusive in their so the PC and 360 dont apply and also Multiplats that have sold better then it dont apply as well :lol:
[QUOTE="Sp4rtan_3"][QUOTE="TintedEyes"] "exclusive console fps" ah it seems you are narrowing it down like this guy is, your no better, and theres my point, thanksTintedEyesIt seems you dont understand that a game being the BEST the entire generation is different then a game not being the best at anything. :roll: :lol: You can dodge and try and make excuses all you want, it still doesn't answer the question I asked you 2 pages back (that you haven't answered ) actually god of war3 is the best selling hd exclusive this year, see its the best if you narrow just like you did :)
Why does it matter if other people narrow it down too? I mean, it seriously seems like you are just trying to distract people from poking fun of the TC by saying "lemmings do it too!" Yeah, they probably do, but why does it matter?
Agreed, so much. Putting all these exemptions in to make GoW3, truthfully, the FOURTH highest selling game so far in a class by itself in an industry where a non HD exclusive outscored and out sold it, no matter what. I love GoW the series and 3 was awesome, but come on TC, was it that important to create a thread and use adjectives to put GoW3 in it's own class? And for opinions sake, I enjoyed Mass Effect 2 more anyway.Lmao trying to ignore Super Mario Galaxy 2 by saying "HD" exclusive , lol wow
MassiveKaos
and using exclusive fps is also graping at straws when you have to narrow down so much. guess they are both pathetic fanboy logicTintedEyes
I already explained the reasoning behind Halo 3.
Pointing out the best selling game of each genre is common practice.
Pointing out it is on a single platform is understandable (since comparing sales of a game on multiple systems versus a game on a single one is usually unfair).
Being specific about Halo 3 serves the purpose of rising the question "how much would it have sold if it were on multiple systems". It helps keeping things in perspective.
Pointing out resolution is neither common practice nor serves any purpose.
It's like saying "PoP is the best selling cell-shaded game". Pointless.
IronBass
There's no reasoning behind this.
Yes, Halo 3 is still a narrowed example, but it makes some (albeit little) sense.
This makes no sense at all.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment