Gran Turismo 5 vs Forza 3

I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :Daaronmullan

With Polyphonic not giving us any kind of bone to chew on...nothing at the moment.

I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :Daaronmullan

I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :Daaronmullan

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"]I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :DDAZZER7

With Polyphonic not giving us any kind of bone to chew on...nothing at the moment.

I can pretty much garantee that there won't be car customization/paint design.

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"]I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :DThe_Brodeo

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"]I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :DThe_Brodeo

Where these are good points, is anyone outside the US going to care about nascar? Or rally? This is suposed to be 'the ultimate racing simulator', I'll take DIRT/DIRT2 if I want rally.

[QUOTE="DAZZER7"]

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"]I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :Dche5ter666

With Polyphonic not giving us any kind of bone to chew on...nothing at the moment.

I can pretty much garantee that there won't be car customization/paint design.

[QUOTE="DAZZER7"]

I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :Daaronmullan

With Polyphonic not giving us any kind of bone to chew on...nothing at the moment.

I can pretty much garantee that there won't be car customization/paint design.

[QUOTE="The_Brodeo"]

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"]I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :Dche5ter666

Where these are good points, is anyone outside the US going to care about nascar? Or rally? This is suposed to be 'the ultimate racing simulator', I'll take DIRT/DIRT2 if I want rally.

[QUOTE="The_Brodeo"]

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"]I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :Dche5ter666

Where these are good points, is anyone outside the US going to care about nascar? Or rally? This is suposed to be 'the ultimate racing simulator', I'll take DIRT/DIRT2 if I want rally.

With how much content there has been in previous Forza games, it might have it aswell. GT has done rally before but not properly, it was a half baked attempt, sorry guys but it was.

Love your sig Chester :P

[QUOTE="che5ter666"]

[QUOTE="The_Brodeo"]Nascar and Rallisport.

epyonx3

Where these are good points, is anyone outside the US going to care about nascar? Or rally? This is suposed to be 'the ultimate racing simulator', I'll take DIRT/DIRT2 if I want rally.

Thats my point, Who outside the US is going to care? IMO the Nascar and Rally inclusions are just a gimmick to boost sales. If they really wanted to they could have save all that time and space and work on something GT fans have been crying out for, like full collision damage or actual believable engine sounds.

Where I'm a Forza fan, I'm not hiding the fact that I love GT just as much, it just ticks me off that they add in 2 features that we'll probably only use twice and leave out something that's been needed since the first one.

GT5 will feature 1 thing that Forza cant have, F1 racing. Sony owns the rights to the F1 series. Nonstop-Madness

That is amazing news to me. I didn't know that.

I can't wait to play Forza 3 either. It will more than tide me over until GT5 gets released.

GT5 will feature 1 thing that Forza cant have, F1 racing. Sony owns the rights to the F1 series. Nonstop-Madness

Didn't Codemasters buy the rights, they're bringing out a new F1 sim next year.

GT5 will feature 1 thing that Forza cant have, F1 racing. Sony owns the rights to the F1 series.Nonstop-Madness

Not any more they don't. Hasn't been that way since May of 2008.

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"]I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :DThe_Brodeo

I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :Daaronmullan

better graphics, more cars on track, nascar, wrc, f1, weather changes, g25 wheel support

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]GT5 will feature 1 thing that Forza cant have, F1 racing. Sony owns the rights to the F1 series.The_Game21x

Not any more they don't. Hasn't been that way since May of 2008.

Gotta go with FM3.

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]GT5 will feature 1 thing that Forza cant have, F1 racing. Sony owns the rights to the F1 series.The_Game21x

Not any more they don't. Hasn't been that way since May of 2008.

Beat me to it game...I will be shocked if F1 is in Gt5..

Well seehow codeis can do with it..I hope they make the sport proud

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"]I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :Dnyctota

better graphics, more cars on track, nascar, wrc, f1, weather changes, g25 wheel support

There's so much wrong with this. Graphics are on par with Forza, same amount of cars on track, NO F1 apart from the Ferrari F1 car, I'm yet to see evidence about the weather, but who's to say that Forza won't have it - considering PGR4 done it superbly and Forza supports the best wheel suport out there. See how I just dwindled down that list.

the thing about GT5 is, when you start up the game, you will have a variety of different races to choose from. should i play nascar? or wait maybe custom cars? no first ill do a Rally. but after some F1 racing.stylesPS3

GT5 will feature 1 thing that Forza cant have, F1 racing. Sony owns the rights to the F1 series.Nonstop-Madness

Not any more they don't. Hasn't been that way since May of 2008.

[QUOTE="nyctota"]

[QUOTE="aaronmullan"]I have a funnier question: What does GT5 bring that Forza 3 wont have? :Dche5ter666

better graphics, more cars on track, nascar, wrc, f1, weather changes, g25 wheel support

There's so much wrong with this. Graphics are on par with Forza, same amount of cars on track, NO F1 apart from the Ferrari F1 car, I'm yet to see evidence about the weather, but who's to say that Forza won't have it - considering PGR4 done it superbly and Forza supports the best wheel suport out there. See how I just dwindled down that list.

lol....

gt5 graphics is way better

http://www.gametrailers.com/user-movie/gran-turismo-5-vs-forza-3/321268

forza has 8 cars on track gt5 has 16 8=/=16

gt5 still has a f1 car and forza none

google is your friend if you wanna see evidence about weather

we are talking about gt5 vs forza not gt5 vs PGR

g25 wheel >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ms wheel

see i just made my post stronger

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"][QUOTE="The_Game21x"]

Not any more they don't. Hasn't been that way since May of 2008.

KingTuttle

[QUOTE="KingTuttle"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"] well, that sucks. lolNonstop-Madness

[QUOTE="KingTuttle"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"] well, that sucks. lolNonstop-Madness

they never had they always had 1 f1 car

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

[QUOTE="KingTuttle"] Why does that suck? KingTuttle

[QUOTE="che5ter666"]

[QUOTE="nyctota"]

better graphics, more cars on track, nascar, wrc, f1, weather changes, g25 wheel support

nyctota

There's so much wrong with this. Graphics are on par with Forza, same amount of cars on track, NO F1 apart from the Ferrari F1 car, I'm yet to see evidence about the weather, but who's to say that Forza won't have it - considering PGR4 done it superbly and Forza supports the best wheel suport out there. See how I just dwindled down that list.

lol....

gt5 graphics is way better

http://www.gametrailers.com/user-movie/gran-turismo-5-vs-forza-3/321268

forza has 8 cars on track gt5 has 16 8=/=16

gt5 still has a f1 car and forza none

google is your friend if you wanna see evidence about weather

we are talking about gt5 vs forza not gt5 vs PGR

g25 wheel >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ms wheel

see i just made my post stronger

- Ok...maybe not confirmed 16 cars on track but not confirmed 8 either. I would rather have 8 realistic opponents than 16 dumb railtrack ones.

- You can look at all the scans and shots all you want, doesn't change the fact that Forza and GT are going to be battling for who owns in the graphics department.

- 1, only 1 F1 car. AND you said google was my friend and I found out that Forza has Le Mans, something I didn't know and doesn't look like GT will.

- http://www.kotaku.com.au/2009/05/new-forza-3-wheel-showing-at-e3/This looks like it will be just as good as G25 wheel.

- I never made this PGR vs GT about the weather. I was signifying that PGR is exclusive, so if Forza does have weather effects they know first hand how to do it right.

Right back at you! Now if you'll excuse me, I'm out. I'm trying not to totally bash GT5, because I love GT just as much as anyone.

GT5 or Forza 3? Depends on what kind of fanboy you are. I will be getting neither, because racing games suck.

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

[QUOTE="KingTuttle"] Why does that suck? KingTuttle

I agree....but I also disagree..

Sony lost the license because they did nothing with it..,,In addition if they (the License holder) made a solid game and pushed the genre forward..Good for them and they should keep it.

But if you pull a Sony..Do nothing with it..and in essence keep other developers from making an F1 game..Then thats horrible for the fans and counterproductive for the genre..

I hope Codies dont follow the same path Sony did

[QUOTE="che5ter666"]

[QUOTE="nyctota"]

better graphics, more cars on track, nascar, wrc, f1, weather changes, g25 wheel support

nyctota

There's so much wrong with this. Graphics are on par with Forza, same amount of cars on track, NO F1 apart from the Ferrari F1 car, I'm yet to see evidence about the weather, but who's to say that Forza won't have it - considering PGR4 done it superbly and Forza supports the best wheel suport out there. See how I just dwindled down that list.

lol....

gt5 graphics is way better

http://www.gametrailers.com/user-movie/gran-turismo-5-vs-forza-3/321268

forza has 8 cars on track gt5 has 16 8=/=16

gt5 still has a f1 car and forza none

google is your friend if you wanna see evidence about weather

we are talking about gt5 vs forza not gt5 vs PGR

g25 wheel >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ms wheel

see i just made my post stronger

[QUOTE="KingTuttle"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"] sucks that GT5 will probably not have the exclusive rights to F1.

masiisam

I agree....but I also disagree..

Sony lost the license because they did nothing with it..,,In addition if they (the License holder) made a solid game and pushed the genre forward..Good for them and they should keep it.

But if you pull a Sony..Do nothing with it..and in essence keep other developers from making an F1 game..Then thats horrible for the fans and counterproductive for the genre..

I hope Codies dont follow the same path Sony did

I'm sure they won't.

They have the Wii and PSP versions coming out this year (from what I've seen they look good) and 360/PS3 next year. That's if they don't break away, and they better have Silverstone as an unlockable track if it's taking off the calender.

I haven't played Forza but I have seen various gameplay demo's including E3's Forza 3 live demo. I've played Gran Turismo 3, 4 and prologue. Based on what I've seen from the E3 trailer for GT5 I have to say that it beats what I've seen from Forza. There's even a hint of damage finally coming to gt5 which is what many people believe is a fatal flaw of previous GT games. What does Forza 3 bring that GT5 wont?epyonx3

[QUOTE="nyctota"]

[QUOTE="che5ter666"]

There's so much wrong with this. Graphics are on par with Forza, same amount of cars on track, NO F1 apart from the Ferrari F1 car, I'm yet to see evidence about the weather, but who's to say that Forza won't have it - considering PGR4 done it superbly and Forza supports the best wheel suport out there. See how I just dwindled down that list.

che5ter666

lol....

gt5 graphics is way better

http://www.gametrailers.com/user-movie/gran-turismo-5-vs-forza-3/321268

forza has 8 cars on track gt5 has 16 8=/=16

gt5 still has a f1 car and forza none

google is your friend if you wanna see evidence about weather

we are talking about gt5 vs forza not gt5 vs PGR

g25 wheel >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ms wheel

see i just made my post stronger

- Ok...maybe not confirmed 16 cars on track but not confirmed 8 either. I would rather have 8 realistic opponents than 16 dumb railtrack ones.

- You can look at all the scans and shots all you want, doesn't change the fact that Forza and GT are going to be battling for who owns in the graphics department.

- 1, only 1 F1 car. AND you said google was my friend and I found out that Forza has Le Mans, something I didn't know and doesn't look like GT will.

- http://www.kotaku.com.au/2009/05/new-forza-3-wheel-showing-at-e3/This looks like it will be just as good as G25 wheel.

- I never made this PGR vs GT about the weather. I was signifying that PGR is exclusive, so if Forza does have weather effects they know first hand how to do it right.

Right back at you! Now if you'll excuse me, I'm out. I'm trying not to totally bash GT5, because I love GT just as much as anyone.

8 cars confirmed if i want realistic opponents i go online for free

graphicwise there is no contest see my video it should be pretty clear ans that is done with 16 cars on track if not new glasses

Le mans does not mean f1

thats a old porshe wheel g25 beats the crap out of that thing logitech FTW

pgr =/= forza or turn 10 =/= bizarre

[QUOTE="epyonx3"][QUOTE="che5ter666"]

Where these are good points, is anyone outside the US going to care about nascar? Or rally? This is suposed to be 'the ultimate racing simulator', I'll take DIRT/DIRT2 if I want rally.

che5ter666

Thats my point, Who outside the US is going to care? IMO the Nascar and Rally inclusions are just a gimmick to boost sales. If they really wanted to they could have save all that time and space and work on something GT fans have been crying out for, like full collision damage or actual believable engine sounds.

Where I'm a Forza fan, I'm not hiding the fact that I love GT just as much, it just ticks me off that they add in 2 features that we'll probably only use twice and leave out something that's been needed since the first one.

[QUOTE="epyonx3"]I haven't played Forza but I have seen various gameplay demo's including E3's Forza 3 live demo. I've played Gran Turismo 3, 4 and prologue. Based on what I've seen from the E3 trailer for GT5 I have to say that it beats what I've seen from Forza. There's even a hint of damage finally coming to gt5 which is what many people believe is a fatal flaw of previous GT games. What does Forza 3 bring that GT5 wont?heretrix

[QUOTE="heretrix"]

[QUOTE="epyonx3"]I haven't played Forza but I have seen various gameplay demo's including E3's Forza 3 live demo. I've played Gran Turismo 3, 4 and prologue. Based on what I've seen from the E3 trailer for GT5 I have to say that it beats what I've seen from Forza. There's even a hint of damage finally coming to gt5 which is what many people believe is a fatal flaw of previous GT games. What does Forza 3 bring that GT5 wont?KingTuttle

the next one will be an announcement about the announcement that was made about it's release date. The announcement will be about what year it's going to be in

[QUOTE="epyonx3"]I haven't played Forza but I have seen various gameplay demo's including E3's Forza 3 live demo. I've played Gran Turismo 3, 4 and prologue. Based on what I've seen from the E3 trailer for GT5 I have to say that it beats what I've seen from Forza. There's even a hint of damage finally coming to gt5 which is what many people believe is a fatal flaw of previous GT games. What does Forza 3 bring that GT5 wont?heretrix

How about we have comparsions after we have solid info about GT5?

Sadly most of the cool features of GT5 are complete speculation, and forza already has a 1up on proven experience.

Here's my predictions:

GT5 will have a ton more cars, but forza will have a better variety.

GT5 will have more racing, tuning, and player options, but forza will have better damage, AI, customization, and online.

Forza will also sell more copies.

I'm probably going to buy both games anyway.

How about we have comparsions after we have solid info about GT5?

thelastguy

[QUOTE="che5ter666"]

[QUOTE="nyctota"]

lol....

gt5 graphics is way better

http://www.gametrailers.com/user-movie/gran-turismo-5-vs-forza-3/321268

forza has 8 cars on track gt5 has 16 8=/=16

gt5 still has a f1 car and forza none

google is your friend if you wanna see evidence about weather

we are talking about gt5 vs forza not gt5 vs PGR

g25 wheel >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ms wheel

see i just made my post stronger

nyctota

- Ok...maybe not confirmed 16 cars on track but not confirmed 8 either. I would rather have 8 realistic opponents than 16 dumb railtrack ones.

- You can look at all the scans and shots all you want, doesn't change the fact that Forza and GT are going to be battling for who owns in the graphics department.

- 1, only 1 F1 car. AND you said google was my friend and I found out that Forza has Le Mans, something I didn't know and doesn't look like GT will.

- http://www.kotaku.com.au/2009/05/new-forza-3-wheel-showing-at-e3/This looks like it will be just as good as G25 wheel.

- I never made this PGR vs GT about the weather. I was signifying that PGR is exclusive, so if Forza does have weather effects they know first hand how to do it right.

Right back at you! Now if you'll excuse me, I'm out. I'm trying not to totally bash GT5, because I love GT just as much as anyone.

8 cars confirmed if i want realistic opponents i go online for free

graphicwise there is no contest see my video it should be pretty clear ans that is done with 16 cars on track if not new glasses

Le mans does not mean f1

thats a old porshe wheel g25 beats the crap out of that thing logitech FTW

pgr =/= forza or turn 10 =/= bizarre

I never said Le Mans meant F1, you were the one saying 'Gt5 still has an F1 car', I'm just saying that Forza has Le Mans and doesn't look like GT5 will.

Old Porsche wheel? It hasn't even come out yet. :?

And I'm sorry, but that video is pretty pointless, all there is, is a completed GT5 trailer up against an ingame replay video that's no where near completion.

[QUOTE="nyctota"]

[QUOTE="che5ter666"]

There's so much wrong with this. Graphics are on par with Forza, same amount of cars on track, NO F1 apart from the Ferrari F1 car, I'm yet to see evidence about the weather, but who's to say that Forza won't have it - considering PGR4 done it superbly and Forza supports the best wheel suport out there. See how I just dwindled down that list.

EmperorSupreme

lol....

gt5 graphics is way better

http://www.gametrailers.com/user-movie/gran-turismo-5-vs-forza-3/321268

forza has 8 cars on track gt5 has 16 8=/=16

gt5 still has a f1 car and forza none

google is your friend if you wanna see evidence about weather

we are talking about gt5 vs forza not gt5 vs PGR

g25 wheel >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ms wheel

see i just made my post stronger

You already know Fanatec is offering third party support? We have discussed that to death..So are we back to square one:?

[QUOTE="EmperorSupreme"][QUOTE="nyctota"]

lol....

gt5 graphics is way better

http://www.gametrailers.com/user-movie/gran-turismo-5-vs-forza-3/321268

forza has 8 cars on track gt5 has 16 8=/=16

gt5 still has a f1 car and forza none

google is your friend if you wanna see evidence about weather

we are talking about gt5 vs forza not gt5 vs PGR

g25 wheel >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> ms wheel

see i just made my post stronger

masiisam

You already know Fanatec is offering third party support? We have discussed that to death..So are we back to square one:?

im sorry but g25 is the windows in wheel world

there is no wheel that will come closeespecially not from fanatec