Greenburg: Halo 3 has outsold Resistance 1 + 2, Uncharted 1+2, Killzone 2 and G

[QUOTE="djsifer01"]Still dosent change the fact that Halo3 is a boring overrated FPS. KZ2, R1 and R2 are better games. UC1 and UC2 blow Halo3 out of the water in every way possible.Cloud567kar

Nice opinion.

GUFU is just an elitist group of fanb- Oh, I see what you did thar.Indie_Hitman

[QUOTE="HAZE-Unit"]

[QUOTE="AdobeArtist"]

OK, I knew Halo 3 outsold each individually... but it actually sold more than SIX major games, COMBINED???
Sure, he's being arrogant, but how many other games can stake this claim? Well???

genaroll

It's not rocket science, I can nitpick just like him :?

Last time I checked Halo 3 outsold Fable 2, Splinter Cell Conviction, Mass Effect 1+2, Alan Wake and Left 4 Dead too!!!

All he have is sales which is pathetic, that's the last resort someone can get with an argument.

And it is not the only game that stake this claim buddy, I mean GTA san andrews sold 20M, Wii sports sold more than 40M, CODMW2 sold 18M, just imagine how many games Wiisports outsold? 20 games? 30 games?

>It's not rocket science, I can nitpick just like him :?

Last time I checked Halo 3 outsold Fable 2, Splinter Cell Conviction, Mass Effect 1+2, Alan Wake and Left 4 Dead too!!!

All he have is sales which is pathetic, that's the last resort someone can get with an argument.

And it is not the only game that stake this claim buddy, I mean GTA san andrews sold 20M, Wii sports sold more than 40M, CODMW2 sold 18M, just imagine how many games Wiisports outsold? 20 games? 30 games?

HAZE-Unit

[QUOTE="crusadernm"]

[QUOTE="djsifer01"]Still dosent change the fact that Halo3 is a boring overrated FPS. KZ2, R1 and R2 are better games. UC1 and UC2 blow Halo3 out of the water in every way possible.ActicEdge

hahaha ...this gotta be sarcasm.

Resistance 1 is such a **** FPS. R2 I don't find amazing but w/e floats his boat. His opinion of KZ2 being better is fair (regardless of whther or not we agree)

[QUOTE="HAZE-Unit"]>It's not rocket science, I can nitpick just like him :?

Last time I checked Halo 3 outsold Fable 2, Splinter Cell Conviction, Mass Effect 1+2, Alan Wake and Left 4 Dead too!!!

All he have is sales which is pathetic, that's the last resort someone can get with an argument.

And it is not the only game that stake this claim buddy, I mean GTA san andrews sold 20M, Wii sports sold more than 40M, CODMW2 sold 18M, just imagine how many games Wiisports outsold? 20 games? 30 games?

Giancar

oh thanks buddy.

you are awesome too.

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

[QUOTE="crusadernm"]

hahaha ...this gotta be sarcasm.

Ringx55

Resistance 1 is such a **** FPS. R2 I don't find amazing but w/e floats his boat. His opinion of KZ2 being better is fair (regardless of whther or not we agree)

I hated it, it was boring, itwas kinda ugly frankly, the mp maps weren't very fun, didn't like the weapons. Wasn't a fun experience to me.

It also outsold most 360 games plus their sequels so what's his point. He's just singling out PS3 so no biggy.

[QUOTE="HAZE-Unit"]

[QUOTE="AdobeArtist"]

OK, I knew Halo 3 outsold each individually... but it actually sold more than SIX major games, COMBINED???
Sure, he's being arrogant, but how many other games can stake this claim? Well???

genaroll

It's not rocket science, I can nitpick just like him :?

Last time I checked Halo 3 outsold Fable 2, Splinter Cell Conviction, Mass Effect 1+2, Alan Wake and Left 4 Dead too!!!

All he have is sales which is pathetic, that's the last resort someone can get with an argument.

And it is not the only game that stake this claim buddy, I mean GTA san andrews sold 20M, Wii sports sold more than 40M, CODMW2 sold 18M, just imagine how many games Wiisports outsold? 20 games? 30 games?

Im MAD because genaroll said so...FACT!!

[QUOTE="genaroll"][QUOTE="HAZE-Unit"]

It's not rocket science, I can nitpick just like him :?

Last time I checked Halo 3 outsold Fable 2, Splinter Cell Conviction, Mass Effect 1+2, Alan Wake and Left 4 Dead too!!!

All he have is sales which is pathetic, that's the last resort someone can get with an argument.

And it is not the only game that stake this claim buddy, I mean GTA san andrews sold 20M, Wii sports sold more than 40M, CODMW2 sold 18M, just imagine how many games Wiisports outsold? 20 games? 30 games?

HAZE-Unit

Im MAD because genaroll said so...FACT!!

Oh, cool. Halo has sold a lot, hasn't it?

Yeah and Gran turismo 1-3 has sold more than the entire halo series combined, meaning Halo1,2 3, odst and wars. Who cares? -.-Roushrsh

He's at least talking about sales from the same gen, with comparable user bases. You are not. I don't even care about sales, but can still see the obvious flaw in your argument.

[QUOTE="Roushrsh"]Yeah and Gran turismo 1-3 has sold more than the entire halo series combined, meaning Halo1,2 3, odst and wars. Who cares? -.-tempest91

He's at least talking about sales from the same gen, with comparable user bases. You are not. I don't even care about sales, but can still see the obvious flaw in your argument.

You see, while Halo 3 is an awesome game, PS3 gamers have far more exclusives to play and pay for; thus PS3 exclusives will never get Halo 3 numbers. 360 has Halo, Gears, Fable, Forza, Alan Wake, PGR, Crackdown, and a few Rare titles while the the PS3 had\s MGS, Uncharted, Killzone, Resistance, Gran Turismo, Ratchet and Clank, Demon Souls, 3D Dot Game Heroes, Yakuza, Valkyria Chronicles, LittleBigPlanet, MAG, iFamous, God Of War, MOD Nation Racers, and Socom. See the difference in numbers and variety?AcidSoldner

PS3 has the a similar number of exclusives as the 360 :?

Unless you're referring to a shorter timeframe of the last couple years (easy out for you).

Just one game.

Wake me up when Gears, Alan Wake, Viva Pinta, Conviction, Banjo, Crackdown and others sell more.

A user on that link summed it up best.

"It's only because PS3 owners have more than 1 good game to spend their money on :) "

Mister__Awesome

That doesn't sum up anything at all. :|

A user on that link summed it up best. "It's only because PS3 owners have more than 1 good game to spend their money on :) " Anyways, the amount sold doesn't make it a better game. Although Halo to this day is still active online.Mister__Awesome

I never knew Halo 3 was the only game on the 360.

I guess all these games I've played were just a mere figment of my imagination :?

[QUOTE="KevinButlerVP"]yeah NPD is the only one in their favor, he's made numerous statments like this the catch is its NPD not WWAnimal-Mother

Facts are facts. Thats a mighty impressive figure.wolverine4262

Agreed... why are fanboys getting so bent out of shape over someone giving sales numbers?

[QUOTE="tempest91"]

[QUOTE="Roushrsh"]Yeah and Gran turismo 1-3 has sold more than the entire halo series combined, meaning Halo1,2 3, odst and wars. Who cares? -.-Mestitia

He's at least talking about sales from the same gen, with comparable user bases. You are not. I don't even care about sales, but can still see the obvious flaw in your argument.

I don't really think he's spinning the fact that Halo has sold so much, it's true. What I think he's really doing though, is spelling out how much MS relies on that franchise though.

it mite have outsold it but story wise

Killzone>>>>>>>>Uncharted>>>>R1(not 2)>>>Halo

had to put my opinion somewhere :P

Still dosent change the fact that Halo3 is a boring overrated FPS. KZ2, R1 and R2 are better games. UC1 and UC2 blow Halo3 out of the water in every way possible.djsifer01

Jesus Christ. Why the hell don't people on SW know the difference between an opinion and a fact? It's surreal.

Just one game.

Wake me up when Gears, Alan Wake, Viva Pinta, Conviction, Banjo, Crackdown and others sell more.

Ninten007

[QUOTE="Ninten007"]

Just one game.

Wake me up when Gears, Alan Wake, Viva Pinta, Conviction, Banjo, Crackdown and others sell more.

Ravensmash

Wake me up when Alan Wake starts outselling Infamous, UC2 and the likehood. And he is only going by USA numbers.

Wii Sports, WiiFit, Mario Kart and many other Wii titles outsold Halo 3. I am sure Halo 3 is also inferior to them gameplay wise.

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

[QUOTE="crusadernm"]

hahaha ...this gotta be sarcasm.

Ringx55

Resistance 1 is such a **** FPS. R2 I don't find amazing but w/e floats his boat. His opinion of KZ2 being better is fair (regardless of whther or not we agree)

I don't even think it was fantastic for its time. The only reason it even got noticed at all was because there was nothing else to play. It's the Perfect Dark Zero of the PS3 IMO.

it mite have outsold it but story wise

Killzone>>>>>>>>Uncharted>>>>R1(not 2)>>>Halo

had to put my opinion somewhere :P

Quaker-w00ts

I know this is all opinion, but how exactly does Killzone 2 have a better story than either of the Uncharted games?

Although I don't find UC's story to be much more than an amusing summer popcorn adventure with well-voiced lively B movie archetypes, I still think it's way better than all three of those **** FPS storylines.

Just one game.

Wake me up when Gears, Alan Wake, Viva Pinta, Conviction, Banjo, Crackdown and others sell more.

Ninten007

[QUOTE="Ringx55"][QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

Resistance 1 is such a **** FPS. R2 I don't find amazing but w/e floats his boat. His opinion of KZ2 being better is fair (regardless of whther or not we agree)

GreySeal9

I don't even think it was fantastic for its time. The only reason it even got noticed at all was because there was nothing else to play. It's the Perfect Dark Zero of the PS3 IMO.

[QUOTE="Animal-Mother"][QUOTE="KevinButlerVP"]yeah NPD is the only one in their favor, he's made numerous statments like this the catch is its NPD not WWChutebox

Is this the new "foliage."

[QUOTE="Ninten007"]

Just one game.

Wake me up when Gears, Alan Wake, Viva Pinta, Conviction, Banjo, Crackdown and others sell more.

Ravensmash

I'm sure American Idol has better ratings than Firefly did, but we all know which one was better :)

halo was an incredible game,

and what's wrong with NPD's? Americans are the biggest electronics consumers on the planet.

[QUOTE="Ravensmash"][QUOTE="Ninten007"]

Just one game.

Wake me up when Gears, Alan Wake, Viva Pinta, Conviction, Banjo, Crackdown and others sell more.

FIipMode

You should be banned for not knowing

Sales = Better game...

Bah, I expected nothing more from a spokesperson...

It's like he's saying Transformers: Revenge of the Fallen is better then Shawshank Redemption for having a box office revenue of 800 million, while Shawshank's revenue was a mere 28 million.

More revenue =/= a better product. It just implies that more people were exposed to it.

Link, wow how arrogant, sad thing is he is only using NPD.

1stPlaceWinner

Ah, he's using just North American NPD region data, that's cool

Greenburg has a point, who would want to play Resistance 1 &2, Uncharted 1 & 2, Killzone 2, and God of War III?...when we can just play Halo 3 for 5+ years continuously? That's all we need anyways, just the one game. Go sales! :P

I have also noticed that when more people buy my favorite game, it makes the game better, have you guys noticed that too?

Wii Fit for instance, which has outsold Halo 3, and is far more expensive than Halo 3, is the most fun game I've ever played...partially because, I know more people bought it.

Greenburg makes a great point. :P

[QUOTE="FIipMode"][QUOTE="Ravensmash"] Yep just one game. And it's outsold all of those others. Wake me up when a PS3 exclusive matches Halo 3 please.Modern_Unit

You should be banned for not knowing

Sales = Better game...

[QUOTE="1stPlaceWinner"]

Link, wow how arrogant, sad thing is he is only using NPD.

SolidTy

Ah, he's using just North American NPD region data, that's cool

Greenburg has a point, who would want to play Resistance 1 &2, Uncharted 1 & 2, Killzone 2, and God of War III?...when we can just play Halo 3 for 5+ years continuously? That's all we need anyways, just the one game. Go sales! :P

I have also noticed that when more people buy my favorite game, it makes the game better, have you guys noticed that too?

Wii Fit for instance, which has outsold Halo 3, and is far more expensive than Halo 3, is the most fun game I've ever played...partially because, I know more people bought it.

Greenburg makes a great point. :P

[QUOTE="Episode_Eve"] :) Uncharted 2 won more AWARDS than Halo 3, Gears 2, Fable 2, Too Human, and Forza COMBINED. :)"Giancar

AHAHHA. LOL.

Owned..

Sales don't mean anything to the gamer.

[QUOTE="SolidTy"]

[QUOTE="1stPlaceWinner"]

Link, wow how arrogant, sad thing is he is only using NPD.

genaroll

Ah, he's using just North American NPD region data, that's cool

Greenburg has a point, who would want to play Resistance 1 &2, Uncharted 1 & 2, Killzone 2, and God of War III?...when we can just play Halo 3 for 5+ years continuously? That's all we need anyways, just the one game. Go sales! :P

I have also noticed that when more people buy my favorite game, it makes the game better, have you guys noticed that too?

Wii Fit for instance, which has outsold Halo 3, and is far more expensive than Halo 3, is the most fun game I've ever played...partially because, I know more people bought it.

Greenburg makes a great point. :P

Yeah, too bad! :(...I guess I will be forced to continue to play a ton of high quality fantastic games instead of watching the sales...oh, the horror.

[QUOTE="genaroll"][QUOTE="SolidTy"]

Ah, he's using just North American NPD region data, that's cool

Greenburg has a point, who would want to play Resistance 1 &2, Uncharted 1 & 2, Killzone 2, and God of War III?...when we can just play Halo 3 for 5+ years continuously? That's all we need anyways, just the one game. Go sales! :P

I have also noticed that when more people buy my favorite game, it makes the game better, have you guys noticed that too?

Wii Fit for instance, which has outsold Halo 3, and is far more expensive than Halo 3, is the most fun game I've ever played...partially because, I know more people bought it.

Greenburg makes a great point. :P

SolidTy

Yeah, too bad! :(...I guess I will be forced to continue to play a ton of high quality fantastic games instead of watching the sales...oh, the horror.

[QUOTE="Episode_Eve"] :) Uncharted 2 won more AWARDS than Halo 3, Gears 2, Fable 2, Too Human, and Forza COMBINED. :)"Giancar

WRONG! It's a Platinum! :P

> ;)

[QUOTE="SolidTy"]

Ah, he's using just North American NPD region data, that's cool

Greenburg has a point, who would want to play Resistance 1 &2, Uncharted 1 & 2, Killzone 2, and God of War III?...when we can just play Halo 3 for 5+ years continuously? That's all we need anyways, just the one game. Go sales!

I have also noticed that when more people buy my favorite game, it makes the game better, have you guys noticed that too?

Wii Fit for instance, which has outsold Halo 3, and is far more expensive than Halo 3, is the most fun game I've ever played...partially because, I know more people bought it.

Greenburg makes a great point.

---------------

genaroll - "Really impressive for the wii,too bad you can't say the same for the ps3."

---------------

Yeah, too bad! :(...I guess I will be forced to continue to play a ton of high quality fantastic games instead of watching the sales...oh, the horror.

genaroll

You mean 6 Games? In my book, 6 High Quality Games > 1 High Quality Game. So keep bringing the games for me to play! :P I'm kind of strange, I love actually playing games more than studying sales, so please forgive me. :P

Here is the Six games I mentioned above :

1. Resistance 1
   
2. Resistance 2
   
3. Uncharted 1
   
4. Uncharted 2
   
5. Killzone 2
   
6. God of War III

That being said, I own 2 360's, lol, and I have over 100,000+ Gamerscore which proves I do play my 360 more than most gamers in SW. :P