GT5 Could Be The Highest Selling And Highest Rated Game In The Franchise

[QUOTE="SilverChimera"]oh yeah, developers can't improve games. i forgot. :roll:

foxhound_fox

[QUOTE="foxhound_fox"]

[QUOTE="SilverChimera"]oh yeah, developers can't improve games. i forgot. :roll:

Rikusaki

[QUOTE="Rikusaki"]

[QUOTE="foxhound_fox"]
Well, lets see. The first Uncharted scored 8.0 on Gamespot. For the second, they've added multiplayer and a new singleplayer campaign. Talking as if Uncharted 2 is a "sure AAA" is means to disaster. Twilight Princess was "guaranteed AAA/AAAA." Now look at it... living down the most stringent of criticism on this website to date.

And based on the NFS:S review, if the same guy reviews GT5, I am almost certain he'll pan the game for not having a cockpit view in every car and (from what is known so far) an inferior online to Forza 3. A 7.0 for a game receiving a solid AA from almost everywhere else? Anything is possible on Gamespot. I thought Twilight Princess would have taught us this already.

You can doubt me all you like, but I've been here long enough to know how Gamespot reviews games, and can pretty accurately predict what score they are going to get. When Uncharted 2 and GT5 get 8.5'd, you don't have to worry about me saying "I told you so." There is never any guarantee, and based on their current standards, I highly doubt either game will score AAA.

navyguy21

The online isn't half baked....

It will have:

• An Open Lobby
• Text / Voice Chat
• Private rooms
• Online Photo Album
• Online Replay Album
• YouTube replay output

And the demo we saw at GamesCon was an early build of the game. Wait for TGS. We may see this "major advancement" Kazunori is talking about.

[QUOTE="navyguy21"]

[QUOTE="Rikusaki"] I highly doubt GT5 will get only 1 point higher than Prologue when it offers SO much more.

Rikusaki

The online isn't half baked....

It will have:

• An Open Lobby
• Text / Voice Chat
• Private rooms
• Online Photo Album
• Online Replay Album
• YouTube replay output

And the demo we saw at GamesCon was an early build of the game. Wait for TGS. We may see this "major advancement" Kazunori is talking about.

The online mode alone will ensure GT5 gets AAA.

I highly doubt GT5 will get only 1 point higher than Prologue when it offers SO much more.

Rikusaki

According to gamerankings, the first iteration of every gen is always higher rated, than the second iteration that gen.TheArmyGuy48

fox your still around complaining..........your opinion on gt5 is like a racist opinion on the the million man march..........shouldnt be taken at all

The online mode alone will ensure GT5 gets AAA.

Rikusaki

[QUOTE="Rikusaki"]I highly doubt GT5 will get only 1 point higher than Prologue when it offers SO much more.

foxhound_fox

No, no... not content. Quantity in gameplay features.

Rikusaki

[QUOTE="Rikusaki"] No, no... not content. Quantity in gameplay features.

foxhound_fox

[QUOTE="Rikusaki"] No, no... not content. Quantity in gameplay features.

foxhound_fox

Yeah, but Forza 3 doesn't let you change the oil in your car or wash it.

Really now? Can you give me a list? I'm sure it's about the same.

Rikusaki

[QUOTE="Rikusaki"]Really now? Can you give me a list? I'm sure it's about the same.

foxhound_fox

ok lets get down to business, im not a big fan of halo but i respect it for bringing the fps genre to consoles and GT brought the racing sim game to consoles as well so they are both seen in a light of being the FIRST to do it on consoles, forza is great im sure and so is GT, i wouldnt be surprised if they both scored a 9 on Gamespot i guess

ok lets get down to business, im not a big fan of halo but i respect it for bringing the fps genre to consoles and GT brought the racing sim game to consoles as well so they are both seen in a light of being the FIRST to do it on consoles, forza is great im sure and so is GT, i wouldnt be surprised if they both scored a 9 on Gamespot i guessClassic24

GT5 should sell 8-12 million. But 25+ million compared to wiifit and 98% gameranking score? Lol

nhh18

you have nothing to support ur OPINION at all, the way i see it, the more it's delayed, the more the fans will disappointed wz it when it comes out.

i hope so. but then i hope every game turns out to be great

Considering both games are yet to be released i cannot understand how people can ASSUME one game will be better than the other... Noticed people bash GT series AI, but surely we havent seen yet the AI for GT5, lets not conclude it will suck until some detailed previews start coming out..

I plan to get both games, looking forward to F3 considering it has an official release date and its coming out in a few weeks.. But am also looking forward to GT5 considering it has loads of content and so many cars to choose from..

Thesad part in all these GT5 vs Forza3 threads is that both fanboy factions who just own 1 console and can only play one of these two games will be missing out on the other title they cannot play..

Everything you said was purely speculation with the exception of past sales :( Halo has had more of an impact on its respective genre than GT has - Games that aren't even FPS games are copying online features that Halo 3 debuted on consoles. Also, GT5P wasn't a demo and the fact that Forza 2 still sold millions on a console where the attach rate was twice as high as other consoles is impressive. That means people spent more money and went more out of their way to own the big titles on 360 than on other platforms :) Since you like to recite numbers, here are a couple from Gamerankings: GT1: 28 Reviews; 94.71% GT2: 25 Reviews; 92.52% GT3: 88 Reviews; 94.29% GT4: 88 Reviews; 89.19% GT5P: 70 Reviews; 79.84% -- Halo CE: 82 reviews; 95.45% Halo 2: 102 reviews; 94.45% Halo 3: 91 reviews; 93.37% --- GT series: 59.8 reviews; 90.1% Halo series: 91.6 reviews; 94.2% Well would you look'y here... Looks like the Halo series was not only judged more harshly but has a higher average than the GT series; And if we include the spin-offs, the gap gets that much larger. Forza series: 81 reviews; 91.19% Looks like the Forza series is judged more harshly and is a higher quality series than GT as well...Wow TC, your examples backfired on you. LulzVadamee

those become muted points when you look at the amount of games in both series GT has bout 7 or 8 im sure Forza has 3 the probability of Forza having a higher rating is more likely as theres less games out :P not trying to spin but to be honest its the truth.More games = bigger numbers to divide by in essence the spinoffs really do bring down the average to be honest if were talking sheer numbers here you wouldnt deny that the same could happen to Forza if they were to proceed in such a manner.

Im pretty sure going by what i've see in my eyes GT5's a triple A same with Forza.Both have diffrent strengths and weaknesses.Oh yeah you cant really say hah forza looks better aswell due to the fact im pretty sure Polyphony never gave out estimates of carmodel polygon builds.

Considering both games are yet to be released i cannot understand how people can ASSUME one game will be better than the other... Noticed people bash GT series AI, but surely we havent seen yet the AI for GT5, lets not conclude it will suck until some detailed previews start coming out.Malta_1980

[QUOTE="Vadamee"]Everything you said was purely speculation with the exception of past sales :( Halo has had more of an impact on its respective genre than GT has - Games that aren't even FPS games are copying online features that Halo 3 debuted on consoles. Also, GT5P wasn't a demo and the fact that Forza 2 still sold millions on a console where the attach rate was twice as high as other consoles is impressive. That means people spent more money and went more out of their way to own the big titles on 360 than on other platforms :) Since you like to recite numbers, here are a couple from Gamerankings: GT1: 28 Reviews; 94.71% GT2: 25 Reviews; 92.52% GT3: 88 Reviews; 94.29% GT4: 88 Reviews; 89.19% GT5P: 70 Reviews; 79.84% -- Halo CE: 82 reviews; 95.45% Halo 2: 102 reviews; 94.45% Halo 3: 91 reviews; 93.37% --- GT series: 59.8 reviews; 90.1% Halo series: 91.6 reviews; 94.2% Well would you look'y here... Looks like the Halo series was not only judged more harshly but has a higher average than the GT series; And if we include the spin-offs, the gap gets that much larger. Forza series: 81 reviews; 91.19% Looks like the Forza series is judged more harshly and is a higher quality series than GT as well...Wow TC, your examples backfired on you. Lulzrazgriz_101

those become muted points when you look at the amount of games in both series GT has bout 7 or 8 im sure Forza has 3 the probability of Forza having a higher rating is more likely as theres less games out :P not trying to spin but to be honest its the truth.More games = bigger numbers to divide by in essence the spinoffs really do bring down the average to be honest if were talking sheer numbers here you wouldnt deny that the same could happen to Forza if they were to proceed in such a manner.

Im pretty sure going by what i've see in my eyes GT5's a triple A same with Forza.Both have diffrent strengths and weaknesses.Oh yeah you cant really say hah forza looks better aswell due to the fact im pretty sure Polyphony never gave out estimates of carmodel polygon builds.

[QUOTE="nhh18"]

GT5 should sell 8-12 million. But 25+ million compared to wiifit and 98% gameranking score? Lol

blackace

[QUOTE="blackace"][QUOTE="nhh18"]

GT5 should sell 8-12 million. But 25+ million compared to wiifit and 98% gameranking score? Lol

nhh18

it still won't outsell recent mariokarts :lol:Ontain

[QUOTE="nhh18"]

[QUOTE="blackace"] I doubt it. I don't even think GT5 will make it out this year. GT5 Prologue did get a good rating and if GT5 is pretty close to that demo, people aren't going to buy it like they did with the other GT games on the PS2. GT5 Prologu sold just over 3 million worldwide and it took them awhile to get to that point. So don't expect GT5 to sell anywhere near GT3. Forza 3 is leaps ahead of it in features, AI, online features and realism. Prologue played similar to GT4 with better graphics. djestar

[QUOTE="djestar"][QUOTE="nhh18"]GT5 has a 1000 cars, 3 game modes, etc. It is leaps and bounds more features than gt5 p. It is going to sell 4 million first month most likely. Anyone who is saying this isn't goign to sell 8-12 million I think is insane. You need to get off this idea like cows believing X game is going to sell more than halo. This is the halo for PS3. It is goign to sell 3times as much as forza 3 at least. And the features aren't that much different between the 2 games. Outside of more user generated content and one more mode. I would say everything else is towards gt5. GT5 has 600 more cars, 80 tracks versus 50, 3 different racing games (WRC, Nascar, and tournament mode) and better graphics. I have no idea abuot physics and I doubt you do too about which one is better. So how could anyone say realism is different (and graphics are an aspect of this). I

nhh18

GT5's 1000 cars are more like 1 car with 20 variations.

it still won't outsell recent mariokarts :lol:Ontain

[QUOTE="nhh18"]

Forza 3 has over 100 tracks.djestar

GT5's 1000 cars are more like 1 car with 20 variations.

[QUOTE="Ontain"]it still won't outsell recent mariokarts :lol:GSuser123

[QUOTE="Ontain"]it still won't outsell recent mariokarts :lol:Rikusaki

[QUOTE="GSuser123"][QUOTE="Ontain"]it still won't outsell recent mariokarts :lol:Ontain

Sure about that? I bet it will. Sales don't really matter that much anyway..Rikusaki

[QUOTE="Rikusaki"] Sure about that? I bet it will. Sales don't really matter that much anyway..foxhound_fox

94% on GR makes it a good game, sales usually follow good games. GSuser123

[QUOTE="GSuser123"]94% on GR makes it a good game, sales usually follow good games. foxhound_fox

[...] sales and reviews dont matter to you the only thing you have to base everything you say is from your personal opinion and nothing more. [...]GSuser123

LOL, GT5 will not save the ps3. Nobody cares about rally cars in 2009 or 2010 or 2011, hmm when is GT5 coming out again? It will be a bigger flop than driver 2.

Yeah, GT5 will sell alot!! For sure PS3 owners are starved for a good exclusive racing game :P

[QUOTE="nhh18"]

[QUOTE="blackace"] I doubt it. I don't even think GT5 will make it out this year. GT5 Prologue did get a good rating and if GT5 is pretty close to that demo, people aren't going to buy it like they did with the other GT games on the PS2. GT5 Prologu sold just over 3 million worldwide and it took them awhile to get to that point. So don't expect GT5 to sell anywhere near GT3. Forza 3 is leaps ahead of it in features, AI, online features and realism. Prologue played similar to GT4 with better graphics. djestar

100 tracks :S wouldnt you be meaning all the layouts in the track complexes? 100 tracks just seems too much to be true in my eyes.But 100 diffrent tracks is unlikely where as that would be more layouts wouldnt it?