GT5 physics = EPIC FAIL

the car act like a bumper car, and PD call it a simulator? even PGR is more realistic...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wOd6o9Fv8TM&feature=player_embedded

Lol that looks pretty hilarious, but the damage has more than likely been turned off.

Looks good to me.

looks like garbage, and still dont have a release date, what a joke, forza 3 is the definitive racer anyway.

they have not finalized internal damage...

and internal damage affects how the car runs.

Gotta admit, the graphics looked nice.

Looks better than Forza 3 to me.

So what does that make Forza 3.

Looks better than Forza 3 to me.

So what does that make Forza 3.

jakehouston88

Looks better than Forza 3 to me.

So what does that make Forza 3.

[QUOTE="jakehouston88"]

Looks better than Forza 3 to me.

So what does that make Forza 3.

SquatsAreAwesom

:lol:

I don't get it...

[QUOTE="SquatsAreAwesom"][QUOTE="bleehum"] The plastic barriers?bleehum

When the car runs through them, you can immediately tell that they aren't even reacting to the free fall effect of gravity. Let alone reacting to the force vectors of the car...

[QUOTE="SquatsAreAwesom"]

[QUOTE="jakehouston88"]

Looks better than Forza 3 to me.

So what does that make Forza 3.

jakehouston88

looks really smooth

now this is Physics http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oamCDuO678g

I wonder if they have implemented the mechanical damage yet. I am going to wait until next year before I judge the game...for all I know, they could have it on a casual setting...but well see.

didnt forza 3 had flying barel roller cars?

[QUOTE="bleehum"][QUOTE="SquatsAreAwesom"] Yes, the plastic barriers... such epic failure on those.SquatsAreAwesom

When the car runs through them, you can immediately tell that they aren't even reacting to the free fall effect of gravity. Let alone reacting to the force vectors of the car...

Didn't they say a few companies didn't want their cars smashed up, so they were only allowed scratches?

Still, it doesn't even look like they had internal damage on that one.

ehh what are you smoking??? this vid is for damage only and not for physics. and forza is not gonna be better than Gt5 . there is the experience factor here. and if forza is better so what? is this gonna make GT5 a bad game , of course not.

[QUOTE="SquatsAreAwesom"]

[QUOTE="bleehum"] What do you except them to do? It's not like they're incredibly heavy or anything.bleehum

When the car runs through them, you can immediately tell that they aren't even reacting to the free fall effect of gravity. Let alone reacting to the force vectors of the car...

now this is Physics http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oamCDuO678g

devilsoultaker2

Dirt 2 and Grid have far better car rolling physics and damage than that.

Didn't they say a few companies didn't want their cars smashed up, so they were only allowed scratches?

Still, it doesn't even look like they had internal damage on that one.

bubbleboyii

ehh what are you smoking??? this vid is for damage only and not for physics. and forza is not gonna be better than Gt5 . there is the experience factor here. and if forza is better so what? is this gonna make GT5 a bad game , of course not.

ioannisdenton

[QUOTE="bleehum"]

[QUOTE="SquatsAreAwesom"] Rewatch the video and tell me they are acting believable by at least a little...

When the car runs through them, you can immediately tell that they aren't even reacting to the free fall effect of gravity. Let alone reacting to the force vectors of the car...

SquatsAreAwesom

[QUOTE="SquatsAreAwesom"][QUOTE="bleehum"] Lol wut? You seriously expect they'd just fall to the ground immediately after they roll over the top of the car? Sadly, this is the only video I could find of someone running through a plastic barrier, (yes I know it's a go kart race, blah blah, but the effects would be multiplied at a higher speed, and it's the same thing only a much smaller vehicle) Go to around 15 seconds, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B8Al295To7Q. After the barriers go over the car, they're not just going to fall to the ground.

bleehum

Let me ask you... do you also believe that physics have nothing to do with damage?

[QUOTE="bleehum"]

[QUOTE="SquatsAreAwesom"] Huh...? Are you suggesting objects don't fall to the ground when there is nothing supporting their weight? Have you taken a physics class? Even the video you used as evidence fails... because it only further proves my point. The GT5 video's gravity is messed up... I'm sorry, but rewatch it a few times. It's blatently obvious. Let alone the force vectors are all messed up.SquatsAreAwesom

Let me ask you... do you also believe that physics have nothing to do with damage?SquatsAreAwesom

looks like garbage, and still dont have a release date, what a joke, forza 3 is the definitive racer anyway.

PrimusGears

[QUOTE="SquatsAreAwesom"][QUOTE="bleehum"]:| *sigh* Ok, let's try this again. First all, let me point out, after the 1st and 2nd barrier, which are stuck in front of the car, the rest end up launching at different angles off of these two. Now, that in itself creates them to go seperate ways. Next, the barriers are moving roughly at the same rate of the car. Once they are caught by the wind (which happens after they move from the front of the car), they aren't simply going to fall to the ground immediately.

bleehum

[QUOTE="bleehum"][QUOTE="SquatsAreAwesom"] Dude... let it go. It looks fake. Trying to reenact the video through words isn't going to change that simple fact.SquatsAreAwesom

[QUOTE="PrimusGears"]

looks like garbage, and still dont have a release date, what a joke, forza 3 is the definitive racer anyway.

Revolution316

Sorry for my English writing, is horrible

I had registered in this site for a long time, because of reviews and article, that I like. But I never wrote here, the issue is that I came by a link up here and saw this thread, and it amused me for physicals. I leave this, the demo forza 3

gif forza 3

are small "bug" that will be corrected in the final version. :P ;)

edit: hups ! gif already had written, sorry

they focused to much on the graphics and not enough on the.... GAMEPLAY!

they focused to much on the graphics and not enough on the.... GAMEPLAY!

Decrate

[QUOTE="SquatsAreAwesom"]

[QUOTE="bleehum"] Nice response.bleehum

this is Cows damage control ? Debug build showing rollovers

SAD

[QUOTE="PrimusGears"]

looks like garbage, and still dont have a release date, what a joke, forza 3 is the definitive racer anyway.

Revolution316

You know that the only reason the car rocked back over on to its wheels is because the game allows you to do that, right? :|

It's not bad physics, it's something the game allows you to do.

btw i love the DC from the ps3 fanboys. is it really that hard for them to admit something so obvious? its pretty clear the physics and damage suck SO FAR, how on earth can they even debate that after watching that video

Dear god i hope it is on casual settings :?

If this is what the final product is gonna look and play like then i guess im gonna have to buy a 360

i hope they put in great damage and physics because i need a top notch racing sim and forza is taking the cake right now

[QUOTE="bleehum"][QUOTE="SquatsAreAwesom"] You reenacting the video with your own commentary. What more did you want?

SquatsAreAwesom

The video I linked definitely doesn't contradict my claim, unless you're blind and can't see the white barrier which is launched into the air. Simple physics is spinning something? I never said it was completely realistic,but it definitely portrays what would happen to the barriers in that situation, of course if they don't weigh too much. And really, the funny thing is, they're not even falling to the ground that slow, if slow at all.

so.. Before it's Graphic, but after demo came out.. tha argument is a failure.... then it was Car Damage, and that was a failure argument too.. Now it's Physics??? gonna beg when F3 comes out.. the argument is a failure too?? trend doesn't look good for you.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DVTJfzk8_7Q

is better damage... and physics o.0

Whats wrong with that gif? When you roll over your car and you can't move, you move your thumbstick left or right too get the car back on its wheels :?.