HDR + Atmos is more quantifiable than FPS and Higher Settings

and receiver + sub , not just Speakers

Resident Evil 7

No Atmos

Nope

Digital Foundry had the following to say about Witcher 3’s HDR implementation

“HDR is a night and day upgrade to SDR”

”This is how it always should have looked”

”HDR is a truer more correct representation of the artwork”

”SDR suddenly looked dull by comparison”

”Gives consoles a very tangible advantage”

”HDR leaves it with a distinct advantage, over even PC”

And yet they still gave the edge to PC

All those quotes came after the “xbox one x vs PS4 pro analysis“ video

these quotes confirm the Xbox one x version LOOKS better

"For our money, the 4K mode on Xbox One X gives the smoothest, best-looking take on The Witcher 3 outside of the PC space."

Hahaha

McDonalds also gives you a cheeseburger for a dollar.

“Smoothest + Best looking”

Strictly best looking goes to Xbox One X with HDR

Your reading comprehension is shit.

It’s spot on, and the latest quotes regarding HDR prove my reading comprehension is correct.

you’re clearly in denial

@Chutebox: Well, he doesn't know what quantifiable means either, so... I mean... What were you expecting, really?

@The_Stand_In: Seriously haha

You’re trying too hard, it’s a synonym for “measurable“ in its simplest form

@GioVela2010: He's trying too hard?! haha

Tell you what, you can keep the HDR.

I'd love a world of PvE games too. Sadly the world doesnt work that way.

@DragonfireXZ95:

lol lets ignore DF''s primary statement "Xbox One X gives the smoothest, best-looking take on The Witcher 3 outside of the PC space."

I suppose he thinks HDR is more important than fps, texture, and foliage detail. Where is that devilish laugh emoticon?

Let's not forget the fact that HDR may still be coming to the PC version.

I remember back in the day where he claimed the 360 looked better than PC versions because it could be played on a plasma tv vs pc's lcd monitors

As if you couldn't hook up a PC to that same plasma TV. LOL

@04dcarraher said: @DragonfireXZ95 said:I suppose he thinks HDR is more important than fps, texture, and foliage detail. Where is that devilish laugh emoticon?

Let's not forget the fact that HDR may still be coming to the PC version.

I remember back in the day where he claimed the 360 looked better than PC versions because it could be played on a plasma tv vs pc's lcd monitors

THat wasn’t my argument, my argument was that it looked better than a PC game on YOUR Monitor. YOU

That's not really the 4k Scorpio version is it?

@GioVela2010

Using Digital Foundry? Are you stupid? DF's reviews have PC comming out on top nearly all the time. Over 90% of their analysis shows PC as the definitive version with better fps and/or gfx. Video gaming is factually better on PC.

Including Witcher 3,

Yet you ignored that I could hook up my pc to my 50" plasma out in the living room eh? And yet you ignored the fact that the 360 even on a plasma was running those games with graphical settings at or below the lowest pc settings let alone sub HD resolution. So again what is the difference between then and now with your argument..... Nothing at all....

lol this was 4-5 years ago. and Yah your Plasma was bad compared to mine, you should have felt bad

claims to know audio but has hardwood floors in his listening environment. if thats not a rofl, dunno what is.

I am not so sure I could explain that to my wife.

If I come, can we build a fort?

Lol this guy.

its 80% carpet

@GioVela2010 said:

@dxmcat said:

claims to know audio but has hardwood floors in his listening environment. if thats not a rofl, dunno what is.

Lol this guy.

its 80% carpet

how deceptive of a camera angle can you get/ just like every word that comes out of your mouth. just an attention grabbing idiot.

That's the 4k version, albeit in a smaller screen. It's a youtube vid screen, but I was having a hard time finding any actual screenshots online. If someone wants to give us some direct xbox one x screens of The Witcher 3, they are more than welcome.

You lied about the price of your speakers and used a cheap cop out that you forgot a "0" which doesn't freaking add up. In the post you said that you mentioned the 1,000$, you said that you didn't pay much for them which falls right in line with a 1,000$ price tag. You paid freakin' 10K and tried to pull a fast one on us. Unless you think the average dudes we are don't consider 10,000$ a lot of money. That was a lie.

@Juub1990: Yup haha, that's what I said.

If he really has expensive shit, he's lying on purpose so he can show them off, which is another level of sad.

That’s why I said “kinda” :)

Grats, follow up your worthless image with a meme. Keep the train of worthless images going.

@GioVela2010: Why the hell are you using a 12K$ home theater with a piece of shit 500$ console?

The Best HDR support

The best Dolby Atmos Support.

As a Home Theater Enthusiast things like Contrast Ratio, Color Saturation, Color Accuracy, and Audio are more important to me than resolution and fps, even in games.

@GioVela2010: Except Dolby Atmos is supported by like 7 games and HDR is now a common feature of PC games. The list of games supporting both HDR and Dolby Atmos is less than 10. You ain’t really getting your money’s worth with this short ass list.

It’s not used strictly for gaming lol, I get my moneys worth in other ways too, but the support will keep coming and the gap will keep widening.

And PC list has 1 Game, that wouldn't be any better

@GioVela2010: Neither is particularly good though but the thousands of games PC is better at offset the handful of games that have HDR+Dolby Atmos. I also don’t think the gap will widen. Rather it will shrink. PC HDR support is more and more common and newer monitors support HDR as well. Dolby Atmos will also see more frequent adoption on the PC space.

Agree to disagree, and if I’m wrong I’ll build another PC

@GioVela2010: So you think PC HDR support will shrink when it’s currently growing?

No i don’t think it’ll shrink, I think X1X HDR Support will grow at a faster rate

@GioVela2010: Possible but I doubt it. Aside from retroactive upgrades on consoles, I believe most high-profile games will feature HDR support on all platforms. Most recent example being AC:Origins.

He's on the record saying controller > kbm/m FOR FPS INCLUDING Unreal and Quake. 24 fps > 60 fps due to cinematic reasons. His TV makes Xbox superior to PC. His TV makes Xbox360 superior to PC. His mind is stuck in an alternate dimension.

It's like politics and how Republicans think Global Warming is fake even though facts state otherwise.

Team mentality over rationality. He's always said consoles have had better gfx, no matter how extreme the gap. He is essentially using that same failed laughing stock debate in this thread. But objectively, it's worthless. These games ARE better played on PC, objectively. They look better. They run better. End of discussion.

He's linked Digital Foundry, which explicitly states PC holds a better experience for as significant majority of current gen games. Including Witcher 3. Multiple tech sites have videos showing the same results. He knows this, he's commented on them.

TLDR: Extreme and long held fanboyism.

Xbox has like 30 more HDR games than PC, when we c look back at this a Year from now do you believe the gap will widen or narrow?

Also PC HDR can be a pain in the ass from what I’ve read on more than one occasion.

just a small example

http://www.avsforum.com/forum/465-high-dynamic-range-hdr-wide-color-gamut-wcg/2575889-enable-hdr-pc-2.html

Gee, sounds familiar on another platform.

https://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/211211-assassins-creed-origins/75964078

"For anyone having this issue, Mine was fixed by turning off the ycc 4:4 option or whatever it’s called in the display menu under settings. After this I was able to adjust the hdr sliders in game again"

Fact of the matter is, all the systems can have possible issues. Consoles aren't plug and play, anymore.

We all have opinions. I believe An X1X is better suited for my Setup. Thr PC fanboy reasoning of “144hz bro” does nothing for my Home Theater. But your low level IQ Can’t comprehend this, SAD.

We’re being adults right now and honest, stop being a bitter fanboy over what I prefer for my setup.

PS: The Witcher looks and sounds better on my setup than yours