How much should Brawl's score suffer because it doesn't use the waggle?

I think it can use three different controllers. Does the Wii remote use motion sensing at all?

Either way, it will be great.

I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)-RPGamer-

[QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)-D3MO-

aren't there around four ways to control this game?

I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)-RPGamer-

Agreed.

[QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)-D3MO-

So if a 360 or PS3 game isn't graphically up to par, but everything else is great including the most important aspect of any game, gameplay, should a point be deducted from its score? I don't necessarily think so. I don't agree with forced waggle, if they think GC controls are best, then that's that. Who cares.

[QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)-D3MO-

[QUOTE="-D3MO-"][QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)Always-Honest

aren't there around four ways to control this game?

Wii mote

Classic

GC controller (which I am gonna use)

Dunno what's the forth if there is even one.

[QUOTE="-D3MO-"][QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)Coldplay07

So if a 360 or PS3 game isn't graphically up to par, but everything else is great including the most important aspect of any game, gameplay, should a point be deducted from its score? I don't necessarily think so. I don't agree with forced waggle, if they think GC controls are best, then that's that. Who cares.

Why should it suffer at all? Motion controlls would be horrible for this style of game,sort of like how RTSs are horrible with dual analog. A game should be judged by how well the controll scheme works with the game,not by how well it conforms to the standard controll schemes of the platform.HeliumFear

[QUOTE="HeliumFear"]Why should it suffer at all? Motion controlls would be horrible for this style of game,sort of like how RTSs are horrible with dual analog. A game should be judged by how well the controll scheme works with the game,not by how well it conforms to the standard controll schemes of the platform.-D3MO-

[QUOTE="Always-Honest"]

[QUOTE="-D3MO-"][QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)jangojay

aren't there around four ways to control this game?

Wii mote

Classic

GC controller (which I am gonna use)

Dunno what's the forth if there is even one.

i'm guessing it will get points for having multiple options.

Should it be affected because it chooses not to use certain features of the system. No, of course not.

Should people raise an eyebrow to the fact that what will be one of the biggest games on the Wii doesn't embody the commpany's philosophy at all...hmm...

[QUOTE="HeliumFear"]Why should it suffer at all? Motion controlls would be horrible for this style of game,sort of like how RTSs are horrible with dual analog. A game should be judged by how well the controll scheme works with the game,not by how well it conforms to the standard controll schemes of the platform.-D3MO-

Do all PS3 games use the sixaxis as it's main point of play? if not then points should be minused

[QUOTE="-D3MO-"][QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)footfoe2

Of course, they all gave Halo AAA, and it was the same game repeated.

[QUOTE="Always-Honest"]

[QUOTE="-D3MO-"][QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)jangojay

aren't there around four ways to control this game?

Wii mote

Classic

GC controller (which I am gonna use)

Dunno what's the forth if there is even one.

Wiimote + nunchuck

also, you can custimize button setups.

Who needs innovation to make a game get reviewed well? Halo is just a plain shooter with some sprinkles on top but all three got reviewed well.

It has like 4 control schemes that are customizable.
Should get more points for that imo, next to the single PS3/360 control schemes.Sgt_Crow

and i think it will...

how much should a score suffer for not using rumble?
how much should a score suffer for not using all the face buttons (coughfable2cough)
how much should a score suffer for not using sixaxis tilt?
how much should a score suffer for not having online functionality?

If you use the standard Wiimote and Nunchuk controller setup, then it does use "waggle" or whatever you want to call it.

[QUOTE="-D3MO-"][QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)Coldplay07

So if a 360 or PS3 game isn't graphically up to par, but everything else is great including the most important aspect of any game, gameplay, should a point be deducted from its score? I don't necessarily think so. I don't agree with forced waggle, if they think GC controls are best, then that's that. Who cares.

but then without the wii remote, couldnt they have just made this for the GC aswell. as there is nothing really graphically superior about this game. and if using an OLD controller is the best method to play this game is shud get points deducted. Although Ive never personally played it yet so I cant judge just yet which control method will be the best.

Straight from the Dojo:

FOUR CONTROLLER TYPES:

With the Wii-Remote and Nunchuck, you have the option of enabling "Shake Smash", which lets you quickly tap the control stick in the desired direction and shake the remote to perform a smash attack. You can also use motion sensing for navigating through menus, of course.

Sakurai himself has stated that the best ways to play Brawl are with the GameCube controller and ****c Controller for hardcore players, but the other two methods work just as well. I personally will be using the Wii Remote on its side.

[QUOTE="Coldplay07"]

[QUOTE="-D3MO-"][QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)HULKMANIA_001

So if a 360 or PS3 game isn't graphically up to par, but everything else is great including the most important aspect of any game, gameplay, should a point be deducted from its score? I don't necessarily think so. I don't agree with forced waggle, if they think GC controls are best, then that's that. Who cares.

but then without the wii remote, couldnt they have just made this for the GC aswell. as there is nothing really graphically superior about this game. and if using an OLD controller is the best method to play this game is shud get points deducted. Although Ive never personally played it yet so I cant judge just yet which control method will be the best.

I don't understand why people call it "waggle" in alot of games its damn good.. Resident Evil 4 showed how brilliant the controls are.. Its far off then a cheap gimmick if it made the game far more enjoyable.. But its also odvious that in some games it just doesn't belong.. Such as the Marvel Ultimate Alliance game..

And that being said they already said there will be 4 different choices.. Wii mote, Wimote + Nunchuck, GC controler, and the Wiis standard gamepad.. People who tried all of them said they were all well down control schemes.

Christ, guys, look at my above post... Brawl supports Waggle.

[QUOTE="HeliumFear"]Why should it suffer at all? Motion controlls would be horrible for this style of game,sort of like how RTSs are horrible with dual analog. A game should be judged by how well the controll scheme works with the game,not by how well it conforms to the standard controll schemes of the platform.-D3MO-

By that logic Halo 3 should have lost a point for being upscaled to HD.

[QUOTE="HULKMANIA_001"][QUOTE="Coldplay07"]

[QUOTE="-D3MO-"][QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)omarguy01

So if a 360 or PS3 game isn't graphically up to par, but everything else is great including the most important aspect of any game, gameplay, should a point be deducted from its score? I don't necessarily think so. I don't agree with forced waggle, if they think GC controls are best, then that's that. Who cares.

but then without the wii remote, couldnt they have just made this for the GC aswell. as there is nothing really graphically superior about this game. and if using an OLD controller is the best method to play this game is shud get points deducted. Although Ive never personally played it yet so I cant judge just yet which control method will be the best.

this game couldnt play on the GC, first off its WAYY too big, its the first wii game to use the double layer discs, the music alone wouldnt fit on a GC disc, then the new havock physics engine, and etc.

i heard that brawl will use the regular gc controller...instead of waggle. Since Wii is riding on the Waggle as its main thing it brings to the table this gen...how much should Brawl's score suffer? I mean the game won't be using the innovation, nor will it be on par graphically with other titles... so...I'm thinking like 1.0 should be deducted (if in fact the brawl doesn't use waggle)-D3MO-

Ha. ha. ha.

Oh well. I should have expected this. All the haters who have nothing to do but complain will do it no matter what--it would be either "Why is waggle in every game?" or "What, why doesn't this game use waggle?" And of course, you're quite uninformed, because the Wiimote does support motion to execute smash attacks. Four types of control--but clearly you've just heard about one, decided it was the only way, and started throwing up facetious fanboy complaints.

It's obvious that you really don't care, because if Brawl was a waggle-fest, I'm sure you'd be whining about how it is casual trash.

[QUOTE="-D3MO-"][QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)Coldplay07

So if a 360 or PS3 game isn't graphically up to par, but everything else is great including the most important aspect of any game, gameplay, should a point be deducted from its score? I don't necessarily think so. I don't agree with forced waggle, if they think GC controls are best, then that's that. Who cares.

are you trying to say that the only thing the xbox and the ps3 have are graphics? if that's the case you're a big hater

[QUOTE="Coldplay07"]

[QUOTE="-D3MO-"][QUOTE="-RPGamer-"]I think it should get perks for not forcing the gimmick. So +2. :)sambalimbo

So if a 360 or PS3 game isn't graphically up to par, but everything else is great including the most important aspect of any game, gameplay, should a point be deducted from its score? I don't necessarily think so. I don't agree with forced waggle, if they think GC controls are best, then that's that. Who cares.

are you trying to say that the only thing the xbox and the ps3 have are graphics? if that's the case you're a big hater

pretty much, everthing else is last gen compatible.

won't hurt score but will definetly hurts it's image. kinda like SMGRagashahs

galaxy has been praised for its wiimote functionality though :?

1. it does use a bit of motion in the Remote/nunchuck setup

2. it uses 4 different controlers, gamecube is just one of them

3. does every PS3 game need teh cell, does every 360 game need to be an FPS thanks to the fps first controler...why should every wii game need motion scencing, hopefuly brawl will set the standered so motion is either not used or integrated right.