I think Wind Waker is better than OOT

The game does NOT hold up well today.-PuLse

[QUOTE="-PuLse"]The game does NOT hold up well today.killerfist

I agree, but honesly I think Majoras Mask was the best. An absolutely phenomenal sequel and it was the darkest themed Zelda :)

-Oath

[QUOTE="killerfist"][QUOTE="-PuLse"]The game does NOT hold up well today.110million

i prefer wind waker aswell.. best zelda game since a link to the past if you ask medoll94

[QUOTE="doll94"]i prefer wind waker aswell.. best zelda game since a link to the past if you ask memexicangordo

I agree 100%. Heck, even Majora's Mask blows OoT out of the water. The series has evolved since OoT.

That's why people felt ripped off when they broke the open world format of MM and WW in Twilight Princess. Open world works very well for a zelda game.

[QUOTE="-Oath"]

I agree, but honesly I think Majoras Mask was the best. An absolutely phenomenal sequel and it was the darkest themed Zelda :)

mexicangordo

I'll respect your opinion, but I disagree whole heartedly, no Zelda game will top Ocarina of Time for me. My biggest issues with Wind Waker would be it's difficult as like you said.....but I love WW anyways, but I just like OoT a lot more. CleanPlayer

Wind waker is the easiest 3d zedal game.What the crap are you talking about?The game boy adavnace cable make it easier.

Wind Waker is also my favourite Zelda game as well. I just hate people that complain about its art style it works well for the game and makes it stand out and I felt the combat system was much better than Ocarina of Time.

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

Answer: still great.

JPOBS

PS. I first played OOT in 2007, and I thought that it was an amazing game. So that "Blinded by Nostalgia"argument of yours is Null & Void. What do you think about THAT?

Zelda: MM >>>

[QUOTE="mexicangordo"]

[QUOTE="-Oath"]

I agree, but honesly I think Majoras Mask was the best. An absolutely phenomenal sequel and it was the darkest themed Zelda :)

JebranRush

Yup, hands down my fav to. I just loved MM.

I enjoyed Wind Waker, but the main plot felt a little short for my taste. I enjoyed the sytlistic approach they took, but compared to other Zelda games, it was much too short.

Plus there's that whole "Transition to 3d" you felt when you played OOT. If you played Metroid Prime, its that same sorta feeling. once you've played it the 2nd & 3rd time in 3d "sorry Echos & Corruption", its not as exciting.

I played both years after the release and Wind Waker still holds up very well to the test of time. OoT does not. I enjoyed WW more.

Only counting the 3D Zelda games, here are my favorites: 1. Twilight Princess 2. Majora's Mask 3. Ocarina of Time 4. The Wind Waker 5. Phantom HourglassDeathScape666

PH isn't 3D.....

[QUOTE="DeathScape666"]Only counting the 3D Zelda games, here are my favorites: 1. Twilight Princess 2. Majora's Mask 3. Ocarina of Time 4. The Wind Waker 5. Phantom Hourglass789shadow

PH isn't 3D.....

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

[QUOTE="DeathScape666"]Only counting the 3D Zelda games, here are my favorites: 1. Twilight Princess 2. Majora's Mask 3. Ocarina of Time 4. The Wind Waker 5. Phantom HourglassDeathScape666

PH isn't 3D.....

Yes indeed, WW takes the Cake.

[QUOTE="Trmpt"][QUOTE="-PuLse"]No.

All the 3D Zeldas after OoT surpassed it. The reason people still place OoT on this pedestal is because of one thing...

Nostalgia

The game does NOT hold up well today.

All the 3D Zeldas after OoT surpassed it. The reason people still place OoT on this pedestal is because of one thing...

Nostalgia

The game does NOT hold up well today.

-PuLse

BzzzzZZZZZZZZZZZZzzzzzz

truth son

i find wind waker to be quite boring

[QUOTE="-PuLse"]All the 3D Zeldas after OoT surpassed it. The reason people still place OoT on this pedestal is because of one thing...

Nostalgia

The game does NOT hold up well today.

CaptainHarley

BzzzzZZZZZZZZZZZZzzzzzz

truth son

Agreed. As a game id say Wind Waker is better than OoT, and its one of my top games of all time (as is OoT).

The misconception that Wind Waker is childish because of the art direction is also ridiculous, to the point where I have seen people list the game as their least favorite Zelda just because of the direction.

Also, the "every Zelda is better than the one before it" is absolutely false, imo. That would make TP the best Zelda game of all time and that's just wrong... of course thats imo.

[QUOTE="-PuLse"]

[QUOTE="Trmpt"] Yes it does. /threadenterawesome

It's close for me but in the end I like Wind Waker better too.

you do know theres a five year gap between the two right? And small places, CMON! Hyrule field was huge and still is today... I respect your opinion because they are both good games but imo OOT > WW by a mile

[QUOTE="ChrisSpartan117"]

That's right. I'm serious.

So, you're probably wondering why.

Well, the main reasons for this is the art s t y l e is so awesome, and the entire world is better made.

You see, the main problem I had with OOT was that it felt likeI was in a very small area, and the sidequests...were underwhelming. And Wind Waker's sidequests are at times better than the main quest. And overall, the world felt more alive. And I loved sailing.

There's only two main problems with WW: The main quest is too easy and too short. And that's it. The story is better written than OOT methinks, and the characters were great in general.

So prepare the flame shields now. I'm ready.

Irick_cb

I liked Wind Waker

But saying it is better then OoT is blasphemy.

What annoyed me most about Wind Waker and Twilight Princess did that pushes them below Ocarina of Time is that they showed so much content, which was then cut from the final game, resulting in massive disappointment. Ocarina didnt have that effect, for some reason. Its part of why I want Nintendo to keep all details secret until they have the game pretty much done, then start releasing trailers. Then I wont be wondering where features / dungeons disappeared to.

Twilight Princess and Wind Waker are still fantastic games, but they will always personally be inferior to Ocarina for that reason. Only just, though.

Link To The Past > Ocarina of Time > Majoras Mask = Links Awakening >Wind Waker > Twilight Princess > The Legend of Zelda >>>>>>>> Phantom Hourglass.

Although, to be honest, this all changes depending on my mood. Except for Phantom Hourglass. I really dont like that game. Its the only Zelda where I just really dont care enough to finish it.

I totally agree