[QUOTE="yahoomail"] I simply believes one ideals of a abstract nature should be consladated by oneself. Finding meaning to something that is not fact is in and of itself playing god. You take controll away from the very the your creating. You create the idea of god in a persons mind, then you play the role of what you have created by forming the wrold thru these religous ideas. Your word is the word of god is the word of you. It can be in good reason, but its still man telling man how to think about what man cannot comprhend....which is wrong IMO.
FrozenLiquid
See your predisposition leans towards believing all Ideas of God stem from the imagination of the human mind. That's very superficial, and uninformative.
Most of the general ideas of God have stemmed from what is allegedly divine revelation, inspiration etc. Prophets. Jesus. Mohammed.From any religion, anytime. And no, the argument of "Oh I can create a religion and deem it true" doesn't work. Most likely your one would be vastly different from all other major religions in the world. And there are other sources you would not immediately think of: the collective, subconcious way in which humans think. That is one of the most fascinating arguments for the Idea of God. It's quite complex, but it's awesome.
But I'm sorry, I've seen your arguments before, and in fact I've used them in my own Philsophy, Spirituality and Theology classes. And may I just say from personal experience it's just the easy way out. It's the "I don't want to think too much because it doesn't affect me" way, which couldn't be further from the truth. Because I'm willing to bet that those who just live life for the sake of living are going to end up in a mid life crisis.
So you believe that the ideas of god, while this may infact be true, have been brought up through the revleations made had about said god? Most of the time a revelation that in some form or manner contredects a different, sometimes older religoin? So, get me stright,...the idea of ONE man, Of god, that are based on similar ideals of other men, creats the common concept of god? Thus, as i said, God is only possible in ones mind, and the shared ideals thru man has brought forth religion. THUS, couldn't one say that religon is merly agreing to believe soly in a predetermed imagenation rooting back to a original sorce? Powerful symbolism such as the death of jesus later spawn christianity, but only because it brought forth new idea for the table of spiritual thought. Some people used thier understand of the world around them to build a new reason for god existence and his effect on us all. So mans only "revelation" is that man creates god in mans own image. A image of himsel, except exponentionly better. God is man, made by man, without mans limits. Which is rediculous, if something did create all there is, how could we ever put our minds around it? We are all wrong, and organising to try and understand it is like getting together to see what your best friend sees in his mind when he read the same book you are. It doesn't matter, you can never see it, read the book yourself, have your own ideas. For the record i believe in god, my mother is catholic, my father is jewish.
Log in to comment