If You Could Change The Score of 1 Game On GS!

[QUOTE="theuncharted34"]

Twilight princess to a 10 so people can stop blindly hating on it. i mean, since they seem to agree with the gs review.

foxhound_fox

I found the design of the dungeons some of the best in the entire series. It had a unique, dark art design that was still different than majora, and had very interesting characters. The game was a 50 - 70 hour game if you took your time with it and did everything there was to do. In particular, the water temple, forest temple, the desert prison temple, and skytown as a whole struck me as brilliant. I feel the whole game is 200 pounds of polish on the formula, with unique location, art, and almost as dark as MM whilst still being different. It is horribly underated on this site and forum. The best review I've seen is the gametrailers one.

I found the design of the dungeons some of the best in the entire series. It had a unique, dark art design that was still different than majora, and had very interesting characters. The game was a 50 - 70 hour game if you took your time with it and did everything there was to do. In particular, the water temple, forest temple, the desert prison temple, and skytown as a whole struck me as brilliant. I feel the whole game is 200 pounds of polish on the formula, with unique location, art, and almost as dark as MM whilst still being different. It is horribly underated on this site and forum. The best review I've seen is the gametrailers one.

theuncharted34

Easily Shadow of the Collosus to a 9.5 or MGS3 to a 9.5.:)

SMG2: 8

ODST: 7.5

MGS4: 9

GTA4: 8

ME2: 8.5

Dragon Age: 8.5

I'll just stop there.. Too many to choose from.

[QUOTE="theuncharted34"]

I found the design of the dungeons some of the best in the entire series. It had a unique, dark art design that was still different than majora, and had very interesting characters. The game was a 50 - 70 hour game if you took your time with it and did everything there was to do. In particular, the water temple, forest temple, the desert prison temple, and skytown as a whole struck me as brilliant. I feel the whole game is 200 pounds of polish on the formula, with unique location, art, and almost as dark as MM whilst still being different. It is horribly underated on this site and forum. The best review I've seen is the gametrailers one.

foxhound_fox

well yeah if you rush through it it's going to take 40 hours. Get all the heart pieces, all the optional items like the magic armor, all bottles, spend time fishing and filling that log, taking time to look at the amazing locations, ect. ect. Speed runs are irrelevent because that's not the first time through. The "waggle" as you call it only enhances the game, and the wii version is the better version. All i'm really hearing is senseless hate. Ask yourself this, does a game need to be innovative to be amazing? no, but all of a sudden when twilight princess comes up it's not innovative and that's a dealbraker for high scores :? i'll say it again it's just hate, and not well founded. The GS review is terrible, but your inclined to believe what you want, even if it's someone else's opinion ie gamespot. Twilight princess is not generic. What's ironic is that the gameinformer review is better. (MUCH)

Too Human to a 7.5.

MGS4 to an 11

Shenmue to a 9.7

The Witcher Enhanced Edition, from 8.5 to 9.5

Reason: The EE was free to all owners of the original, and it fixed what was wrong with the first, yet GS gave no numerical credit at all to the extensive reprogramming.

• Wild Arms: Alter Code F - 7.2 to 9.8, docked only a few tenths of a point due to technical problems
• Wild Arms 3 - 7.5 to 10
• Dragon Quest 8 - 9.0 to 10
• Rogue Galaxy - 8.0 to 9.0, fun but does have a lot boring corridor moments throughout and and a little more boring it had to be at times, but overall fun

This thread will probably grow pretty large once GT5 gets scored.

GreySeal9

probably MGS4 from 10 to 8

Mass effect 2 - 10 / 10

DW6 to a 10. Just to see if SW reacts :P

I'd give MGS4 a 4.5.

I would give Lost Winds an 8. I feel the game was well made and docked marksfor unfair reasons. Its biggest problem is its short.

well yeah if you rush through it it's going to take 40 hours. Get all the heart pieces, all the optional items like the magic armor, all bottles, spend time fishing and filling that log, taking time to look at the amazing locations, ect. ect. Speed runs are irrelevent because that's not the first time through. The "waggle" as you call it only enhances the game, and the wii version is the better version. All i'm really hearing is senseless hate. Ask yourself this, does a game need to be innovative to be amazing? no, but all of a sudden when twilight princess comes up it's not innovative and that's a dealbraker for high scores :? i'll say it again it's just hate, and not well founded. The GS review is terrible, but your inclined to believe what you want, even if it's someone else's opinion ie gamespot. Twilight princess is not generic. What's ironic is that the gameinformer review is better. (MUCH)

theuncharted34

[QUOTE="theuncharted34"]

well yeah if you rush through it it's going to take 40 hours. Get all the heart pieces, all the optional items like the magic armor, all bottles, spend time fishing and filling that log, taking time to look at the amazing locations, ect. ect. Speed runs are irrelevent because that's not the first time through. The "waggle" as you call it only enhances the game, and the wii version is the better version. All i'm really hearing is senseless hate. Ask yourself this, does a game need to be innovative to be amazing? no, but all of a sudden when twilight princess comes up it's not innovative and that's a dealbraker for high scores :? i'll say it again it's just hate, and not well founded. The GS review is terrible, but your inclined to believe what you want, even if it's someone else's opinion ie gamespot. Twilight princess is not generic. What's ironic is that the gameinformer review is better. (MUCH)

foxhound_fox

I agree to disagree then. I myself thought it was brilliant. Maybe not WW or MM brilliant, but close. It's a 10/10 for me. I may have come across a bit strongly on the hate part, but I disagree very strongly :P

I'd probably change the score of Black ops to a 7.0. Or i'd increase the score of Metro 2033 to 9.0 on the PC

Lost Planet from an 8 to a 9.

Shadow of Rome, 8.2 to a 9.0.

Lto_thaG

good call, friend-o

[QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

[QUOTE="sandbox3d"]

Well, as for a real answer, I believe MGS4 should be knocked down to an 8.5. Mainly because I love the series so much. It seems misleading for MGS4 to have the highest rating of the series when it is arguably the weakest link.

sandbox3d

If anything...MGS3 was more deserving of that 10.

Absolutely. MGS2 and MGS3 are two of my all time favorite games. MGS4 is just....ugh, I don't even want to get into it. I literally couldn't believe what I was playing when I got that game.

Hell no. MGS4 is my favorite in the series. MGS3 was amazing but it suffered from some not so great mechanics (the food and such was a tad lame) and most importantly Volgan was the lamest MGS character to date. I would say MGS4 > MGS3 = MGS1 > MGS2.

ANYWAY, I would say Baten Kaitos Origins should be a 9 or higher, not a 7.5

Flower should be 9.0 .... what?? nobody played it??hippiesanta

I did play it, and it's an awesome game. Too damn good! :D

GTA IV - from a 10 to a 9.0

GTA IV - from a 10 to a 9.0

MrJack3690

True true...I didnt think of that one! 10's should only be given to true masterpieces that have little wrong with them. GTA IV is great but does not reach MASTERPIECE level.

i would change lost odyssey that game only got a 7.5 i thought that game was great i would give it a 9.0 at least

[QUOTE="MrJack3690"]

GTA IV - from a 10 to a 9.0

NaveedLife

True true...I didnt think of that one! 10's should only be given to true masterpieces that have little wrong with them. GTA IV is great but does not reach MASTERPIECE level.

Exactly!

I'm not like a lot of people who say the game is garbage, it definitely deserved a AAA score. But when you compare it to previous GTA games, as far as things to do, it seems lacking.

It does a great job improving Gunplay, however compared to other games (like Uncharted or Gears of War) the gunplay is pretty weak, Red Dead Redemption improved on the Gunplay so much though when compared to GTA IV.

Also, the online multiplayer is crazy fun with a few friends, however it wasn't handled well. The matchmaking feels sloppy and you have to sit in a Lobby waiting for the party leader to change game settings most of the time. I've spent a lot of time waiting in a lobby to watch player leave while waiting for the leader to start the game.

But the story was handled a lot better, I just wanna see more of the Over the Top Fun, and random moments like from past GTA games...I don't care if it's not realistic to steal a jet from a naval ship...I wanna do it! :D

all three Halo games on 360, starting in order:

halo3 - 7.5

odst -7.0

reach - 8.0

Mass Effect 2 to 10. At least 9.5, 9 is just stupid.

Saints Row 2 actually deservers either 5 or 6. It's fun, but gets boring so fast,

GTA 4 from a 10 to 8.5. That game did not deserved a 10.

I'd raise Metro 2033's 8 on the PC to a solid 9.0, or would lower GTAIV's 10 to a 9.0.

Majora's Mask should have been a 10/10. It is the best 3D zelda game.

New Super Mario Bros Wii- 6.5

So,you can change the score of one game on Gamespot.What game would that be?

You can also name more if you want.
Shadow of Rome,8.2 to a 9.0.

Off-topic:I want Team Buddies on XBL or PSN.

Lto_thaG

CHANGE ACB TO 9.5 !!!

MGS4= 7/10 or MGS3: 9/10

all three Halo games on 360, starting in order:

halo3 - 7.5

odst -7.0

reach - 8.0

Any of the 8.5/10 Wii games, to 8.0 or 9.0, doesn't even matter, just stop 8.5ing everything, it's not fun anymore!

Just one. I'd switch the scored for Ratchet and Clank ACiT and ToD. I'd also give both Gears games a 6.5.

However, in the spirit of giving scores rather than taking them, lets give ToD that 8.5

[QUOTE="ZoomZoom2490"]

all three Halo games on 360, starting in order:

halo3 - 7.5

odst -7.0

reach - 8.0

ms555

Have you seen this guys posting history? You're making unrealistic expectations here.

change kingdom hearts 1 to at least a 9 but imo should be a 9.5