If You Could Change The Score of 1 Game On GS!

Valkyria Chronicles from 8.5 to 9.0

Every CoD game after modern warfare to 6.5shakmaster13

Modern Warfare 2 = 6/10

smg 2 to a 4.10Hamburgher

I think what this guy is trying to say is that SMG2 is really just a "1.5"

Suikoden 1 = from a 6 or what ever it got to a 9 or 9.5/10

Fallout1/2 = 10/10 or 9.5

Elemental = 8 or 9/10, I love this game

Ratchet and Clank = First one on on the ps3 was awesome, but got a 7? 7.5? was much ebtter then that imo

Lost Odyssey = 7.5? This is one of this gens best rpgs (the witcher is better) and a 9/10 imo

Deus Ex = Higher score it deserved

Risen = Deserved 8.5 or 9 imo on pc

Assassins Creed 1/2 = 4/10

Neverhood.

4.9/10 to 8.9/10

Suikoden 1 = from a 6 or what ever it got to a 9 or 9.5/10

Fallout1/2 = 10/10 or 9.5

Elemental = 8 or 9/10, I love this game

Ratchet and Clank = First one on on the ps3 was awesome, but got a 7? 7.5? was much ebtter then that imo

Lost Odyssey = 7.5? This is one of this gens best rpgs (the witcher is better) and a 9/10 imo

Deus Ex = Higher score it deserved

Risen = Deserved 8.5 or 9 imo on pc

Assassins Creed 1/2 = 4/10

kozzy1234

I think I agree with you on everything but the AC stuff...Crack in Time FTW.

[QUOTE="0Hamburgher"]smg 2 to a 4.1kontejner44

I think what this guy is trying to say is that SMG2 is really just a "1.5"

I hope not. the sequel is far more original, imaginative, and brilliant than the first. It clearly showed that the development team were playing it very safe witht the first mario galaxy then let loose in the second and it payed off big time!

I truely feel that the second game was far more varied and original in its concepts:

-Yoshi added a varied way to play (Tongue pointer controls)

-Spin drill allowed you to drill through planets to reach higher areas

-using mario's spin attack to switch panels to jump on

-Cloud Mario allowing you to create your own platforms

-Gravity effects that spin in a never ending circle in Tall Trunk Galaxy

-Running up walls at super speed in high tail falls

-navigating a world that's falling apart from sawblades

-The ever repeating walkways that vanish at the edges in Haunty Halls

-Blocks that appear and disappear to the beat of the music in Beatblock galaxy

-Gravity that shifts acording to your ground pounding in flipsville galaxy,

-creating pathways for chomps in chompworks (more puzzle oriented than mario usually is)

-navigating a whole level that only appears within the radius of Yoshi's light in sweet mystery galaxy

-Navigating a bobomb that appears below the glass cylander your on to break the glass below you in Space Storm

-The reverse slide in which you must dodge cylindrical enemies from behind you in Slipsand

-the sand bird that breaks and reappears moments later in slipsand galaxy

-The fire balls that melt momentary lava circles in the ice quickly followed by icicles that create momentary ice patches in the lave in shiver burn galaxy

-The constantly folding world of Boo moon galaxy

-a flat surface that pops up into something you can platform on and wall jump with in boo moon galaxy

-Navigating tiny planetoids as large lava monsters constantly pass through them in Melty Monster Galaxy

-The whole rolling sequence in Melty Monster Galaxy

-The large spiinning platforms and wheels with only certain points to be safe as well as be able to climb up on in reverse in clockwork ruins

-A level where you can only see your suroundings when the beat allows light to flash in Flash Back Galaxy

-controlling walljumpable ledges with your spin attack in Flip-Out galaxy

-and much more!

The first Mario galaxy didn't even have a third of the originality that the second has

Anywho, If I were to change a score it would be the Legend of Zelda the Phantom Hourglass from a 9.0 to a 7.5. It had superb DS functionality in touch controls, but the adventure wasn't very entertaining and the world was by far the smallest zelda world to date which you had to explore with a boat on rails... It was just annoying especially with the Temple of the Ocean king. The series needed a change, but I much prefered the Majora's Mask change than this

Every CoD game after modern warfare to 6.5shakmaster13

Every COD after COD2

• COD3 6.5
• COD4 8.0
• COD: WaW 7.5
• COD: MW2 6.0
• COD: Black Ops 7.5

[QUOTE="kontejner44"]

[QUOTE="0Hamburgher"]smg 2 to a 4.1Pikminmaniac

I think what this guy is trying to say is that SMG2 is really just a "1.5"

I hope not. the sequel is far more original, imaginative, and brilliant than the first. It clearly showed that the development team were playing it very safe witht the first mario galaxy then let loose in the second and it payed off big time!

I truely feel that the second game was far more varied and original in its concepts:

-Yoshi added a varied way to play (Tongue pointer controls)

-Spin drill allowed you to drill through planets to reach higher areas

-using mario's spin attack to switch panels to jump on

-Cloud Mario allowing you to create your own platforms

-Gravity effects that spin in a never ending circle in Tall Trunk Galaxy

-Running up walls at super speed in high tail falls

-navigating a world that's falling apart from sawblades

-The ever repeating walkways that vanish at the edges in Haunty Halls

-Blocks that appear and disappear to the beat of the music in Beatblock galaxy

-Gravity that shifts acording to your ground pounding in flipsville galaxy,

-creating pathways for chomps in chompworks (more puzzle oriented than mario usually is)

-navigating a whole level that only appears within the radius of Yoshi's light in sweet mystery galaxy

-Navigating a bobomb that appears below the glass cylander your on to break the glass below you in Space Storm

-The reverse slide in which you must dodge cylindrical enemies from behind you in Slipsand

-the sand bird that breaks and reappears moments later in slipsand galaxy

-The fire balls that melt momentary lava circles in the ice quickly followed by icicles that create momentary ice patches in the lave in shiver burn galaxy

-The constantly folding world of Boo moon galaxy

-a flat surface that pops up into something you can platform on and wall jump with in boo moon galaxy

-Navigating tiny planetoids as large lava monsters constantly pass through them in Melty Monster Galaxy

-The whole rolling sequence in Melty Monster Galaxy

-The large spiinning platforms and wheels with only certain points to be safe as well as be able to climb up on in reverse in clockwork ruins

-A level where you can only see your suroundings when the beat allows light to flash in Flash Back Galaxy

-controlling walljumpable ledges with your spin attack in Flip-Out galaxy

-and much more!

The first Mario galaxy didn't even have a third of the originality that the second has

Anywho, If I were to change a score it would be the Legend of Zelda the Phantom Hourglass from a 9.0 to a 7.5. It had superb DS functionality in touch controls, but the adventure wasn't very entertaining and the world was by far the smallest zelda world to date which you had to explore with a boat on rails... It was just annoying especially with the Temple of the Ocean king. The series needed a change, but I much prefered the Majora's Mask change than this

[QUOTE="Pikminmaniac"]

[QUOTE="kontejner44"]

I think what this guy is trying to say is that SMG2 is really just a "1.5"

nintendoboy16

I hope not. the sequel is far more original, imaginative, and brilliant than the first. It clearly showed that the development team were playing it very safe witht the first mario galaxy then let loose in the second and it payed off big time!

I truely feel that the second game was far more varied and original in its concepts:

-Yoshi added a varied way to play (Tongue pointer controls)

-Spin drill allowed you to drill through planets to reach higher areas

-using mario's spin attack to switch panels to jump on

-Cloud Mario allowing you to create your own platforms

-Gravity effects that spin in a never ending circle in Tall Trunk Galaxy

-Running up walls at super speed in high tail falls

-navigating a world that's falling apart from sawblades

-The ever repeating walkways that vanish at the edges in Haunty Halls

-Blocks that appear and disappear to the beat of the music in Beatblock galaxy

-Gravity that shifts acording to your ground pounding in flipsville galaxy,

-creating pathways for chomps in chompworks (more puzzle oriented than mario usually is)

-navigating a whole level that only appears within the radius of Yoshi's light in sweet mystery galaxy

-Navigating a bobomb that appears below the glass cylander your on to break the glass below you in Space Storm

-The reverse slide in which you must dodge cylindrical enemies from behind you in Slipsand

-the sand bird that breaks and reappears moments later in slipsand galaxy

-The fire balls that melt momentary lava circles in the ice quickly followed by icicles that create momentary ice patches in the lave in shiver burn galaxy

-The constantly folding world of Boo moon galaxy

-a flat surface that pops up into something you can platform on and wall jump with in boo moon galaxy

-Navigating tiny planetoids as large lava monsters constantly pass through them in Melty Monster Galaxy

-The whole rolling sequence in Melty Monster Galaxy

-The large spiinning platforms and wheels with only certain points to be safe as well as be able to climb up on in reverse in clockwork ruins

-A level where you can only see your suroundings when the beat allows light to flash in Flash Back Galaxy

-controlling walljumpable ledges with your spin attack in Flip-Out galaxy

-and much more!

The first Mario galaxy didn't even have a third of the originality that the second has

Anywho, If I were to change a score it would be the Legend of Zelda the Phantom Hourglass from a 9.0 to a 7.5. It had superb DS functionality in touch controls, but the adventure wasn't very entertaining and the world was by far the smallest zelda world to date which you had to explore with a boat on rails... It was just annoying especially with the Temple of the Ocean king. The series needed a change, but I much prefered the Majora's Mask change than this

All you have to do is play about 10-20 minutes into either game for your answer. The setting has nothing to do with it. You simply will not find level design so brilliant in any other games out their. Almost every level in SMG2 reveals an original idea. You could seriously make entire games based off of an idea that Nintendo may have only used once or twice in SMG/SMG2.

Every COD after COD2

• COD3 6.5
• COD4 8.0
• COD: WaW 7.5
• COD: MW2 6.0
• COD: Black Ops 7.5

Avian005

[QUOTE="nintendoboy16"]

[QUOTE="Pikminmaniac"]

I hope not. the sequel is far more original, imaginative, and brilliant than the first. It clearly showed that the development team were playing it very safe witht the first mario galaxy then let loose in the second and it payed off big time!

I truely feel that the second game was far more varied and original in its concepts:

-Yoshi added a varied way to play (Tongue pointer controls)

-Spin drill allowed you to drill through planets to reach higher areas

-using mario's spin attack to switch panels to jump on

-Cloud Mario allowing you to create your own platforms

-Gravity effects that spin in a never ending circle in Tall Trunk Galaxy

-Running up walls at super speed in high tail falls

-navigating a world that's falling apart from sawblades

-The ever repeating walkways that vanish at the edges in Haunty Halls

-Blocks that appear and disappear to the beat of the music in Beatblock galaxy

-Gravity that shifts acording to your ground pounding in flipsville galaxy,

-creating pathways for chomps in chompworks (more puzzle oriented than mario usually is)

-navigating a whole level that only appears within the radius of Yoshi's light in sweet mystery galaxy

-Navigating a bobomb that appears below the glass cylander your on to break the glass below you in Space Storm

-The reverse slide in which you must dodge cylindrical enemies from behind you in Slipsand

-the sand bird that breaks and reappears moments later in slipsand galaxy

-The fire balls that melt momentary lava circles in the ice quickly followed by icicles that create momentary ice patches in the lave in shiver burn galaxy

-The constantly folding world of Boo moon galaxy

-a flat surface that pops up into something you can platform on and wall jump with in boo moon galaxy

-Navigating tiny planetoids as large lava monsters constantly pass through them in Melty Monster Galaxy

-The whole rolling sequence in Melty Monster Galaxy

-The large spiinning platforms and wheels with only certain points to be safe as well as be able to climb up on in reverse in clockwork ruins

-A level where you can only see your suroundings when the beat allows light to flash in Flash Back Galaxy

-controlling walljumpable ledges with your spin attack in Flip-Out galaxy

-and much more!

The first Mario galaxy didn't even have a third of the originality that the second has

Anywho, If I were to change a score it would be the Legend of Zelda the Phantom Hourglass from a 9.0 to a 7.5. It had superb DS functionality in touch controls, but the adventure wasn't very entertaining and the world was by far the smallest zelda world to date which you had to explore with a boat on rails... It was just annoying especially with the Temple of the Ocean king. The series needed a change, but I much prefered the Majora's Mask change than this

sandbox3d

All you have to do is play about 10-20 minutes into either game for your answer. The setting has nothing to do with it. You simply will not find level design so brilliant in any other games out their. Almost every level in SMG2 reveals an original idea. You could seriously make entire games based off of an idea that Nintendo may have only used once or twice in SMG/SMG2.

Fire Emblem on the Wii. That was an extremely bad review. He knocked a tactical RPG for not having Mii support for christ-sake.

Knights of the Old Republic to a 10.

WipeoutHD : deserves a solid 9 !

Mass Effect to a 9.0. It's really sad how it scored an 8.5 for such an amazing game.

Twilight Princess to a 9.0 :P

Mass Effect 2 to a 9.5

Out of those three, I would pick one.

Big Rigs: Over the Road Racing, GS 1.0.

It should be -10.

Silent Hill 2 - 9.0Konamic

System Shock 2 8.5 :arrow: 9.0 +

Oh yeah, I almost forgot one of the worst RPGs of this gen. Final Fantasy XIII deserved nothing higher than a 6.

Mass Effect 2. 9.5 AT LEAST.charizard1605

Probably lost odyssey from a 7.5 to an 8.5

Metal Gear Solid 4 - 8.5 (Story was way more confusing than the simple MGS3)

Metal Gear Solid 3 - 9.5 (Story alone should make it a 9, cant believe its the lowest rated MGS game)

Grand Theft Auto IV - 9.5 (Game is amazing but has its faults. A 9.5 also would have brought the hate down)

Lost Odyssey - 9(Greatest JRPG this gen deserves more than a 7.5)

Assassin's Creed- 7(Second one is very well done but first one is completely average)

And most importantly....

Super Smash Bros brawl - 8 (A replica of a game made 8 years prior has no business getting a 9.5.)

[QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

None...because I couldnt care less what some pencil-pusher amateur journalist on GS thinks about a game I like.

AdobeArtist

Easy to criticize the work of others (calling them amateur) from your home behind your anonymity without a single professional credential, isn't it? ;)

In any case the score I would change (not that I'm saying the reviewer was 'amateur' ) is Too Human to a 7.0. True the game had its control issues, and the level scaling past 30 was unbalanced, but damn was that game FUN. The frenetic pace of the action when ping ponging between hordes of enemies was insane. And I just kept going back for more, with the fantastic array of skill tree building and abundant loot collecting that offered so much character customization. far from perfect but still better than a 5.5.

Of course i'm anonymous,you think i'm stupid enough to mouth off to some wormy game reviewer's face in real life? I'd be put in a hospital obviously :roll:

GS reviewers arent exactly renowned journalists that have articles featured in Time Magazine and had to spend a few years in some prestige college to get where they are.They offer their opinion about video games.most people with basic writing skills and a "opinion" could do what they do.I've seen user reviews on here that were more insightful and better written than "professional reviews"

and as for my lack of professional credentials?... what makes you so certain I didnt major in writing or journalism? it's nice to assume things. Afterall,I am being anonymous,so again how would you know?

but to answer your question...No,I'm more of an Artist and by Artist,I mean a "Real Artist" as in: someone who expresses themselves in a abstract way through Painting,Drawing,Photography,Music........and not someone who just edits pictures together of Scarlett Johansson or some Samus Aran Cosplayer through Adobe ;)

I was waiting until Gamespot posted the GT5 review to say, "GT5!" :P

---

Seriously though, I'd change Legend of Dragoon, that game is cIassic to me :).

I was waiting until Gamespot posted the GT5 review to say, "GT5!" :P

---

Seriously though, I'd change Legend of Dragoon, that game is cIassic to me :).

Episode_Eve

[QUOTE="charizard1605"]Mass Effect 2. 9.5 AT LEAST.Arach666

[QUOTE="Arach666"]

[QUOTE="charizard1605"]Mass Effect 2. 9.5 AT LEAST.charizard1605

[QUOTE="charizard1605"][QUOTE="Arach666"] Yeah,I don´t know about that... :P

Arach666

Bump Ratchet & Clank: Tools of Destruction from a 7.5 to an 8.5. The review was just pathetic, to say the least.

[QUOTE="Arach666"][QUOTE="charizard1605"] You know I'm fiercer about Mass Effect than I am about Zelda, right? :evil:charizard1605

Bump Ratchet & Clank: Tools of Destruction from a 7.5 to an 8.5. The review was just pathetic, to say the least.

xYamatox

Starcraft 1 should be 9.0 or higher