Infinite Undiscovry isnt doing to hot.

[QUOTE="dream431ca"]I can smell the stench of lemming damage control, and :lol: at Disgaea 3 getting a better score than both of those 360 JRPGs.Chaos_HL21

8.5, is a better score than 7.5? This isn't golf.

It's funny how you go back to the gamespot scores when this:

Tales of Vesperia X360 80.1%

Infinite Undiscovery X360 71.0%

Disgaea 3 PS3 81.2%

seems to put those 2 360 games at a disadvantage.

[QUOTE="Chaos_HL21"]

[QUOTE="dream431ca"]I can smell the stench of lemming damage control, and :lol: at Disgaea 3 getting a better score than both of those 360 JRPGs.dream431ca

8.5, is a better score than 7.5? This isn't golf.

It's funny how you go back to the gamespot scores when this:

Tales of Vesperia X360 80.1%

Infinite Undiscovery X360 71.0%

Disgaea 3 PS3 81.2%

seems to put those 2 360 games at a disadvantage.

But I'll stick with that, since I've always thought GS should use Metacritic.

[QUOTE="Chaos_HL21"]

[QUOTE="dream431ca"]I can smell the stench of lemming damage control, and :lol: at Disgaea 3 getting a better score than both of those 360 JRPGs.dream431ca

8.5, is a better score than 7.5? This isn't golf.

It's funny how you go back to the gamespot scores when this:

Tales of Vesperia X360 80.1%

Infinite Undiscovery X360 71.0%

Disgaea 3 PS3 81.2%

seems to put those 2 360 games at a disadvantage.

I love Disgaea, really I do, but a 1.1% difference isn't really much to brag about.

[QUOTE="Chaos_HL21"]

[QUOTE="dream431ca"]I can smell the stench of lemming damage control, and :lol: at Disgaea 3 getting a better score than both of those 360 JRPGs.dream431ca

8.5, is a better score than 7.5? This isn't golf.

It's funny how you go back to the gamespot scores when this:

Tales of Vesperia X360 80.1%

Infinite Undiscovery X360 71.0%

Disgaea 3 PS3 81.2%

seems to put those 2 360 games at a disadvantage.

Ok so Halo 3 93.5% >MGS 4 92.6%? Seems like MGS 4 is at a disadvantage.

This is a Gamespot forum so Gamespot reviews are used (even if they suck)

[QUOTE="dream431ca"][QUOTE="Chaos_HL21"]

[QUOTE="dream431ca"]I can smell the stench of lemming damage control, and :lol: at Disgaea 3 getting a better score than both of those 360 JRPGs.Chaos_HL21

8.5, is a better score than 7.5? This isn't golf.

It's funny how you go back to the gamespot scores when this:

Tales of Vesperia X360 80.1%

Infinite Undiscovery X360 71.0%

Disgaea 3 PS3 81.2%

seems to put those 2 360 games at a disadvantage.

Ok so Halo 3 93.5% >MGS 4 92.6%? Seems like MGS 4 is at a disadvantage.

This is a Gamespot forum so Gamespot reviews are used (even if they suck)

That's true, but even Lemmings are guilty of going to the metacritic scores when the GS score isn't what they want. LO abd Blue Dragon are 2 prime examples.

Tales of Vesperia X360 80.1%

Infinite Undiscovery X360 71.0%

Disgaea 3 PS3 81.2%

Disgaea having more reviews then ToV and IU.

Krigon

[QUOTE="Chaos_HL21"]

[QUOTE="dream431ca"]I can smell the stench of lemming damage control, and :lol: at Disgaea 3 getting a better score than both of those 360 JRPGs.dream431ca

8.5, is a better score than 7.5? This isn't golf.

It's funny how you go back to the gamespot scores when this:

Tales of Vesperia X360 80.1%

Infinite Undiscovery X360 71.0%

Disgaea 3 PS3 81.2%

seems to put those 2 360 games at a disadvantage.

Cant have it both ways. If we go by gamerankings then Halo 3 >> MGS4

That's true, but even Lemmings are guilty of going to the metacritic scores when the GS score isn't what they want. LO abd Blue Dragon are 2 prime examples. dream431ca

All fanboys do that, their game flops they go to Gamerankings Metacritic, although I don't remember them doing that with Blue Dragon, only one major person was hyping (IIRC) that game and then he jumped ship after it.

I do think Blue Dragon should of been alittle higher, it was a fun little JRPG, but there are many GS reviews that I disagree with, such as the Disgeae 3 reivew, 7.5 it got robbed, but we are on Gamespot so their reviews is law.

[QUOTE="dream431ca"]That's true, but even Lemmings are guilty of going to the metacritic scores when the GS score isn't what they want. LO abd Blue Dragon are 2 prime examples. Chaos_HL21

All fanboys do that, their game flops they go to Gamerankings Metacritic, although I don't remember them doing that with Blue Dragon, only one major person was hyping (IIRC) that game and then he jumped ship after it.

I do think Blue Dragon should of been alittle higher, it was a fun little JRPG, but there are many GS reviews that I disagree with, such as the Disgeae 3 reivew, 7.5 it got robbed, but we are on Gamespot so their reviews is law.

if you think that reviews weird check out the R&C: QFB review and then check out the score they gave it :?

[QUOTE="dream431ca"]That's true, but even Lemmings are guilty of going to the metacritic scores when the GS score isn't what they want. LO abd Blue Dragon are 2 prime examples. Chaos_HL21

All fanboys do that, their game flops they go to Gamerankings Metacritic, although I don't remember them doing that with Blue Dragon, only one major person was hyping (IIRC) that game and then he jumped ship after it.

I do think Blue Dragon should of been alittle higher, it was a fun little JRPG, but there are many GS reviews that I disagree with, such as the Disgeae 3 reivew, 7.5 it got robbed, but we are on Gamespot so their reviews is law.

Why don't we switch to using Play reviews instead? Then we'd have to read the review instead of going solely by an arbitrary number slapped on with no real meter. I think most ps3 owners would prefer meta/gr scores be the law of the land, we just like rubbing lem's faces in their own hypocrisy over MGS4 :P

[QUOTE="Chaos_HL21"]

[QUOTE="dream431ca"]I can smell the stench of lemming damage control, and :lol: at Disgaea 3 getting a better score than both of those 360 JRPGs.dream431ca

8.5, is a better score than 7.5? This isn't golf.

It's funny how you go back to the gamespot scores when this:

Tales of Vesperia X360 80.1%

Infinite Undiscovery X360 71.0%

Disgaea 3 PS3 81.2%

seems to put those 2 360 games at a disadvantage.

Only gamespot scores count here. Those are the SW rules.

Ahem

Metacritic:

Tales of vesperia 80

Disgaea 3 79

Well sonyfriends better luck next time :)

Ahem

Metacritic:

Tales of vesperia 80

Disgaea 3 79

Well sonyfriends better look next time :)

liquid-ocelot

[QUOTE="liquid-ocelot"]

Ahem

Metacritic:

Tales of vesperia 80

Disgaea 3 79

Well sonyfriends better look next time :)

angelkimne

[QUOTE="Chaos_HL21"]

[QUOTE="dream431ca"]That's true, but even Lemmings are guilty of going to the metacritic scores when the GS score isn't what they want. LO abd Blue Dragon are 2 prime examples. mbrockway

All fanboys do that, their game flops they go to Gamerankings Metacritic, although I don't remember them doing that with Blue Dragon, only one major person was hyping (IIRC) that game and then he jumped ship after it.

I do think Blue Dragon should of been alittle higher, it was a fun little JRPG, but there are many GS reviews that I disagree with, such as the Disgeae 3 reivew, 7.5 it got robbed, but we are on Gamespot so their reviews is law.

Why don't we switch to using Play reviews instead? Then we'd have to read the review instead of going solely by an arbitrary number slapped on with no real meter. I think most ps3 owners would prefer meta/gr scores be the law of the land, we just like rubbing lem's faces in their own hypocrisy over MGS4 :P

Digaea 3 suck. It's not even comparable to TOV by a mile. Maybe it should be Spectral Force 3 vs. Disgaea 3

ocinom

It doesn't suck, it's main problem is that it's a PS2 game burned onto a Blu Ray disc and sold at an inflated price.

it's an SRPG, try to get the genre of the game your defending right atleast.And developing your character through battle and story is the basic mechanic of any type of RPG, it's what RPG is.

TheKonspiracy

its a jrpg, within the subcatagory of srpg.

it goes:

rpg

wrpg-jrpg

srpg-and whatever other genres there are.

saying its not a jrpg is just an excuse, it IS

EDIT:talking about disgaea 3

[QUOTE="TheKonspiracy"]

it's an SRPG, try to get the genre of the game your defending right atleast.And developing your character through battle and story is the basic mechanic of any type of RPG, it's what RPG is.

_witenite_

its a jrpg, within the subcatagory of srpg.

it goes:

rpg

wrpg-jrpg

srpg-and whatever other genres there are.

saying its not a jrpg is just an excuse, it IS

EDIT:talking about disgaea 3

well it's not exactly a regular jrpg, in the traditional sence.

[QUOTE="_witenite_"][QUOTE="TheKonspiracy"]

it's an SRPG, try to get the genre of the game your defending right atleast.And developing your character through battle and story is the basic mechanic of any type of RPG, it's what RPG is.

TheKonspiracy

its a jrpg, within the subcatagory of srpg.

it goes:

rpg

wrpg-jrpg

srpg-and whatever other genres there are.

saying its not a jrpg is just an excuse, it IS

EDIT:talking about disgaea 3

well it's not exactly a regular jrpg, in the traditional sence.

its the same way a JRPG is an RPG. take away the W and its an RPG. take away S from SRPG and its also an RPG. and since disgaea is an rpg in strategic fomr, made in japan, and a jrpg is also just an rpg made in japan, then they are the same.

that may have come out a bit confusing :P

[QUOTE="Krigon"]

Tales of Vesperia X360 80.1%

Infinite Undiscovery X360 71.0%

Disgaea 3 PS3 81.2%

Disgaea having more reviews then ToV and IU.

spinecaton

I'm starting to think Gamepro shouldn't be allowed to review JRPGs anymore. So far they are the lowest scorer for both ToV and IU...

Gamepro is the worst gaming magazine on the market, so I wouldn't even view their review. I'm waiting to see what GI and OXM give these games. Tales of Versperia is very good. Infinite Undiscovery isn't out yet, but I'll have it next week. I'm hoping The Last Remnant is as good as Tales if not better.

its the same way a JRPG is an RPG. take away the W and its an RPG. take away S from SRPG and its also an RPG. and since disgaea is an rpg in strategic fomr, made in japan, and a jrpg is also just an rpg made in japan, then they are the same.

that may have come out a bit confusing :P

_witenite_

i know what you're trying to say, but i'm just saying that if i had to put it into one category i think that SRPG would better describe it than JRPG.

[QUOTE="_witenite_"]

its the same way a JRPG is an RPG. take away the W and its an RPG. take away S from SRPG and its also an RPG. and since disgaea is an rpg in strategic fomr, made in japan, and a jrpg is also just an rpg made in japan, then they are the same.

that may have come out a bit confusing :P

TheKonspiracy

i know what you're trying to say, but i'm just saying that if i had to put it into one category i think that SRPG would better describe it than JRPG.

:o what about JSRPG :shock:

[QUOTE="TheKonspiracy"][QUOTE="_witenite_"]

its the same way a JRPG is an RPG. take away the W and its an RPG. take away S from SRPG and its also an RPG. and since disgaea is an rpg in strategic fomr, made in japan, and a jrpg is also just an rpg made in japan, then they are the same.

that may have come out a bit confusing :P

_witenite_

i know what you're trying to say, but i'm just saying that if i had to put it into one category i think that SRPG would better describe it than JRPG.

:o what about JSRPG :shock:

yeah, i could go with that :)

just have seen the add for the game and it dosent say only on x360 guess its not a exclusive game and will end up on ps3 with extra content maybeDontBeHatin1983

Unlikeyly. Project was funded with MS money.

[QUOTE="TheKonspiracy"][QUOTE="_witenite_"]

its the same way a JRPG is an RPG. take away the W and its an RPG. take away S from SRPG and its also an RPG. and since disgaea is an rpg in strategic fomr, made in japan, and a jrpg is also just an rpg made in japan, then they are the same.

that may have come out a bit confusing :P

_witenite_

i know what you're trying to say, but i'm just saying that if i had to put it into one category i think that SRPG would better describe it than JRPG.

:o what about JSRPG :shock:

[QUOTE="ocinom"]Digaea 3 suck. It's not even comparable to TOV by a mile. Maybe it should be Spectral Force 3 vs. Disgaea 3

CronoSquall

It doesn't suck, it's main problem is that it's a PS2 game burned onto a Blu Ray disc and sold at an inflated price.

It's $49. And (to original guy) don't even try to compare it to the utter crap that is Spectral Force 3.