It may be possible Xbox one won January NPD

Maybe that's why PS4 is on a Roll and current gen 8 console leader. The GAMES.

no, that wasn't the second option.

Besides the ps4 doesn't have "the games". It has 'the indies'. Damn near all of the ps4's exclusives have flopped, or just have been generic/terrible. The XB1 has decent exclusives and 'the indies' though...meaning its the system with, "the games".

Hmm now the PHYSICAL 12 month gold Sku is flying toward the top 5 in hourly. Which also shows a very odd trend here, add that Xbox gift cards are in the top 12, 3 of them, and they have no deals, all this seems very odd. Seems like Amazon is not the place to get an Xbox one and people are buying them other places this month, not sure what more unusual evidence is needed for a possible win.

Which you have no proof of because you didn't check before I brought it up and then claimed it was still on sell at the "present" time because you literally can't read. You make a lot of mistakes (in fact the same mistake Tormentos did, if I said it has run out of stock, along with other websites mentioning they ran out of stock, with a counter, and a DATE for when they will get more stock (oh noess) but you check as SOON as I say it for THAT day then how the hell do you even have a platform to stand on? You clearly didn't check before and now it's too late now. But of course making shit up in a deceptive condescending way is what you did, lol teacher, if you were a teacher we would have had a rational argument where we agree to disagree at the end, instead you started with the usual youtube child comment bullshit like tormentos, those poor kids are disabled now probably.) It makes even less sense since Amazon has sold out with those same 2 situation before, yet now it's impossible because you say so and you didn't look so since you didn't see it it's not real? I mean if you had checked as soon as I made this thread (you didn't until later) you would have saw the same thing and now saw any sku for Amazon on any page. I'd say agree to disagree but something tells me that's something you can't actually do.

Shut up.

Yep that one month that had the price back up, then back down, with all these gold memberships at the top of the lists the last 2 weeks. We have so much info that this month is make or break I can't find any at all.

Forza H2 flopped here so did halo MCC the 2 biggest games the xbox one had last year.

Games are games period stop downplaying indies that is basically the only thing you will have decent to play on xbox one for the next 8 months,Ori and the blind forest..hahahaaa

70 games more on PS4 than on xbox one say that the XB1 is the system that doesn't have the games..lol

Because it is been sold for $39.99 instead of $59.99.?

Why is GTA again in the top 20.? For the same reason it dropped to $39.99 and it got a spike all your arguments have been prove wrong and the xbox one has basically trail the PS4 all month long.

It enever did and you could actually buy a XBO from Amazon on those days PERIOD,orders were fulfill by Amazon centers,and your unit was package,ship and you got customer service all from Amazon.

AMAZON never ran out of units,all units ship from fulfillment centers are send to you by amazon,so regardless of amazon having no physical units in one part,it had units on their fulfillment centers which has the effect of been the same shit,which is why the XBO keeped charting because it keep selling period.

xbox live card don't reflect xbox one sales you can't be this dumb xbox live cards are also for the 84 million xbox 360 MS sold,so basically not every one who buys a live 12 month card is buying it for an xbox one..

Ok...i'm running out of comebacks to ur shit lol. No matter what I say you'll just come back with Sony cheerleading. theres not really anything there even respond too. So **** it, you win.

@TigerSuperman: you obviously have an issue here. What is it son? Let it all out. Let's hear what has you pitching a fit. Better yet, you can send me a private message with a way for us to contact each other off of system wars...we'll put you on stage and we'll see how you do. Contact me, lets discuss whatever issues you seem to be having. Because It can't just be you being too stupid to decipher someone who uses metaphors in sentences lol. Lets get you stage and talk this out slowshot

;)

What?

SEND ME A PERSONAL/PRIVATE MESSAGE ON HERE WITH YOUR PHONE NUMBER, SKPE, OR ANY OTHER WAY WE CAN HAVE A VERBAL CONVERSATION. SO WE CAN HAVE ONE..DERP..DERP lol.

Lets show the people how much better than me you are. I'm going to give you the stage to show you're right about me and that you're not just some clown on a keyboard pretending he's better than what he is.

theres no point of staying on a forum to do it. You have an obvious problem with me....so lets talk n get to the root of it. Lets get you on stage. Send the info...lets parlay :)

Few days with 12 month gold at top, Physical 12 gold (wut?) also within that top area for awhile. XBox One Sku struggling to stay on 1st page, pretty sure Amazon will be wrong (that along with the other factors) too strange. Point cards are also up there, though they fell a little, it's still too strange, and those don't have discounts. In order for gold to be that high, since it's required, and also only applies to 2 systems, one is down, while all the PSN cards are across numerous systems and more than one country mostly, this just gets weirder and weirder.

I say a win or a very small gap in either favor.

Also Physical gold being up near digital gold just seems out of the blue. That's 3x as many people, and separate groups. Hmm.

THE XBOX 360 USES XBOX LIVE CARDS.

There you have it a clear justification for the increase in sales after the price drop.

Yep the 3 posts I had responding to you means i have a problem with you, somehow.

He does this to everyone. He claimed I was stalking him in the past lol. The guy isn't properly set. Best to let it go.

Now 12 month Physical XBLG has moved to number 5, and XBLG 12 months digital is still at number one. Keep in mind the PSN+ and PSN cards involve a bunch of systems, and thus, this means tons of people are buying Xbox ones, just not on Amazon, because 12 month gold is required for MP play, which is what you would have gotten during the holiday season, unlikely mroe than 5% of Xbox one buyers during December did not get gold, so Xbox One must have had a very good january NPD (and also February so far) outside of Amazon because some ones had to be buying thise gold cards and it's clearly not Xbox One or 360 users on Amazon. Add 360 is down in general, and all of a sudden it seems clear that most of those Golds are for Xbox one.

I still won't go beyond probably but I will say it will be very close. I'd say 15k minimum, either side AT LEAST with a max of Xbox One winning by around 100k+

This is ... still going on

You're still going on with this insane theory? Are you going to keep bumping this thread right up until the NPD January results come in?

If you think the January Amazon results are important there's a pretty easy conclusion you can make:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/bestsellers/2015-01/videogames

#9: Playstation 4 Console

#20: Xbox One Assassin's Creed Unity Bundle

/done

The Xbox One holiday fire sale is over, and once again the Playstation 4 console is selling better in NA.

Nope, 12 months of gold is required (keep in mind PSN+ is across more platforms, including the PS4 which has a larger installbases than Xbox One) for MP. Apps are not behind a paywall anymore ether, Xbox 360 is down. Who's buying the 12 month gold cards? Who's buying the PHYSICAL 12 month gold cards as well? Been cosistently on top since the last week in January, even before the sale, Xbox point cards were also up for a few days before falling back down, but still at a decent position, no discount. (also your link is old)

The fact the Physical is that high just scream volumes. If anything there are better deals for the Xbox one elsewhere. Seems like a very high probability.

It can't be a discount because this has happened before when the Xbox 360 and Xbox one were selling better and it wasn't evenc lsoe to as high and the Physical version didn't even really exist.

Then you have the Physical version. Which is very high.

You have 12 month MP required cards beating out cards that are across multiple systems, and since there isn't a pay wall anymore, that just seems weird for people to be buying so much in droves.

Xbox 360 is down, so most of those 12 month cards are for the Xbox one.

Actual Xbox on rising and falling between 12 and 20 randomly most of the time. Doesn't seem like a good indicator this month.

12 month gold cards have been outselling the XBox One by great margins consistently since the second week of january (before the price re-drop)

I clearly see either a small, small victory, either way, or a surprise big win for Xbox One.

You God Damn better believe!!!

Those Live Gold card sales, tho..

Where does it say I though the Xbox Would definitely win though?

No, you got it all wrong. It's funny because you actually thought it had a chance.

This is the third NPD thread I've seen made by him for just January, in all he heavily implies a MS win. This one is even funnier because he speculates on cow excuses pending believed victory.

This is the third NPD thread I've seen made by him for just January, in all he heavily implies a MS win. This one is even funnier because he speculates on cow excuses pending believed victory.

No, you got it all wrong. It's funny because you actually thought it had a chance.

Care to put that into a percentage? By what percent of the XBone's sales did the $50 more expensive PS4 win by?

Frankly, the XBone didn't even outsell the launch-aligned January for the original XBox. It's not just that XBone got beat on its home turf, it is in a complete self-destruct death spiral.

Yet it's still ahead of the original xbox.

Where does it say I though the Xbox Would definitely win though?

I made the NPD thread, I made a predictions thread, and I made this thread. man do you ever use your brain?

Tell me again about how Amazon gift cards are going to give the Xbox One a win for January NPDs, will you? It's super-interesting.

”PlayStation 4 was the top selling console in January, it and remains the cumulative leader in the U.S., according to NPD data,”

I predicted precisely this, back when the price cut and bundles were originally announced. XBone was going to cannibalize its demand in 2015 for the sake of going HAM on the holidays. Now, it's a ship without sails. A boat without oars. Free-floating against a machine that has a very heavy lineup of games in the first 6 months of 2015 and going into the holidays with Uncharted 4.

You're on a sinking ship. There's no way to spin that. It's no 360.

dat sig tho :)