Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem 3rd party Donkey Konga 3rd party Battalion Wars 3rd party Geist 3rd party
Nintendo_Ownes7
When in the hell is Nintendo Wars, Geist, Donkey Kong, and Eternal Darkness all third party? Last I checked, Nintendo still owns those IPs.He meant the developer even if Nintendo owns the IP; He wanted a list of just titled developed by Nintendo.Third party developed or not, Nintendo still owns them.
By all accounts Geist was a great idea poorly executed. A quick Wiki tells me "Game Informer lists the game among the worst horror games of all time." and Edge said "Unfortunately, no sooner does Geist suggest it can blossom into something fresh and exciting that its undermined at every turn by a frustrating insistence on being nothing more than a mundane firstperson shooter"
It's like an MS fan listing Too Human as a great new MS ip. It was a great idea but the actual game was a flawed mess.
locopatho
I see a lot of fans that really like this game. And if we're going with the opinions of reviewers and journalists as a base, the guy who wrote the review on our very own Gamespot gave it a 7.8/10, which is basically an 8, and there were a couple of other reviewers that gave it a good score. I think opinions on this game aren't one sided at all. It's more of a hate/love situation, from what i can tell.
By all accounts Geist was a great idea poorly executed. A quick Wiki tells me "Game Informer lists the game among the worst horror games of all time." and Edge said "Unfortunately, no sooner does Geist suggest it can blossom into something fresh and exciting that its undermined at every turn by a frustrating insistence on being nothing more than a mundane firstperson shooter"
It's like an MS fan listing Too Human as a great new MS ip. It was a great idea but the actual game was a flawed mess.
Lucianu
I see a lot of fans that really like this game. And if we're going with the opinions of reviewers and journalists as a base, the guy who wrote the review on our very own Gamespot gave it a 7.8/10, which is basically an 8, and there were a couple of other reviewers that gave it a good score. I think opinions on this game aren't one sided at all. It's more of a hate/love situation, from what i can tell.
I was going by Metacritic where it got a 66. There are games like that, love it or hate it type games. I'm glad some people enjoyed it. I enjoyed Too Human, warts and all. I don't think it belongs on a list of great games tho.
Most of their recent(last five years or so) new ips were either minigame collections on wii (xenoblade aside) or small eshop titles for 3ds. Where are the last of us, beyond two souls type games with big budgets targeted at adult, core gamers? Something like eternal darkness would be appreciated. MFDOOM1983
Those types of games don't cater to Nintendo's current users. Nintendo is after the kids/families and fans of Nintendo properties, with the same library.Â
There is also the AAA tier which consits of 3D Mario, 3D Metroid and 3D Zelda. And now Bayonetta 2 / Xenoblade 2. They are the critical darlings running for GOTY/90%+ scores which reach out to a wider audience (not just Nintendo fans, but the general core gamer). It's in this category you find non-Nintendo fans buying a Nintendo system to enable them to play 4-5 gems.
That's it really. A new IP AAA effort that targets the male 20-30s audience would be a waste of valuable resources, a flop, since the market isn't there. Just like there is no market for Banjo Threeie / TimeSplitters 4 on DudebroBox.
[QUOTE="locopatho"]They do make new IPs. But Nintendo fans ALWAYS smuch together multiple consoles and handhelds to make their lists, when people are generally talking about one console. They also add in Japan only games, crappy games, and some veeery questionable "new" IPs. Battalion Wars, Donkey Konga, Excite Truck, Endless Ocean etc aren't new IPs just because of a different name/genre. That's like calling Halo Wars or that Uncharted card game new IPs. You could make a much shorter, much more honest, much more impressive list by filtering out the crap and lies.locopatho
Endless Ocean is a new IP even if it is similar to Arika's other games Everblue on the PS2 since Nintendo owns the IP of Endless Ocean it is the spiritual successor meaning it is a new IP. It's the exact same as the Forever Blue series, they just renamed it to avoid copyright issues. It's like calling Black Ops a new IP compared to Modern Warfare. It's the same thing with a different name...
And the Tomb Raider reboot is Uncharted reskinned.
[QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="Nintendo_Ownes7"]Endless Ocean is a new IP even if it is similar to Arika's other games Everblue on the PS2 since Nintendo owns the IP of Endless Ocean it is the spiritual successor meaning it is a new IP.
SuperFlakeman
It's the exact same as the Forever Blue series, they just renamed it to avoid copyright issues. It's like calling Black Ops a new IP compared to Modern Warfare. It's the same thing with a different name...
And the Tomb Raider reboot is Uncharted reskinned.
This whole argument is silly.
Not when it's the same developer. A dev renaming their series from Everblue to Forever Blue for legal reasonsm isn't a new IP, sorry :(
Art Style Wii Sports Excite Truck Wii Play Endless Ocean Wii Fit Wii Music Disaster: Day of Crisis Captain Rainbow Common sense of people power TV Tact of Magic FlingSmash Dynamic Slash And-Kensaku Pandora's Tower Kiki Trick Xenoblade Chronicles The Last Story Zangeki no Reginleiv
___
Â
You have to be joking with this list. Disaster Day of Crisis was a bomb. All those "WII" titled games are suck. And Nintendo is reusing their cannon character it doesn't count. Luigi's mansion is still Luigi again and Donkey konga? OKAY.Â
Bread_or_Decide
WiiMusic sucked but Wii Sports and Fit scored well so they count
[QUOTE="locopatho"] It's the exact same as the Forever Blue series, they just renamed it to avoid copyright issues. It's like calling Black Ops a new IP compared to Modern Warfare. It's the same thing with a different name...locopatho
And the Tomb Raider reboot is Uncharted reskinned.
This whole argument is silly.
Not when it's the same developer. A dev renaming their series from Everblue to Forever Blue for legal reasonsm isn't a new IP, sorry :( Did you play either to think that they're the same game? It is a new IP That is like Bayoneeta isn't a new IP because its similar to DMC and the guy worked on both games
[QUOTE="locopatho"] It's the exact same as the Forever Blue series, they just renamed it to avoid copyright issues. It's like calling Black Ops a new IP compared to Modern Warfare. It's the same thing with a different name...locopatho
And the Tomb Raider reboot is Uncharted reskinned.
This whole argument is silly.
Not when it's the same developer. A dev renaming their series from Everblue to Forever Blue for legal reasonsm isn't a new IP, sorry :( Under your logic, GRID isn't a new IP because it's DIRT on roads. Uncharted is a rehash of Tomb Raider mixed with Gears of War, Torchlight is a Diablo clone, and Killzone is a Halo clone.
Nintendo makes tons of new IPs. I don't think that was ever in question. I think people are talking about consoles though and not downloadable games which shrinks the list. Its not bad though, they could stand to release more new IPs. Pikmin, Wii series, Last Story, Xenoblade and Pandora's Tower were all a good start. They need to just do a better mix of old and new.
And the Tomb Raider reboot is Uncharted reskinned.
This whole argument is silly.
hiphops_savior
Not when it's the same developer. A dev renaming their series from Everblue to Forever Blue for legal reasonsm isn't a new IP, sorry :( Under your logic, GRID isn't a new IP because it's DIRT on roads. Uncharted is a rehash of Tomb Raider mixed with Gears of War, Torchlight is a Diablo clone, and Killzone is a Halo clone. Those are different series. Forever Blue and Everblue are literally the exact same thing with a tiny name change for legal reasons. Would you call Modern Warfare a new IP if it dropped the "COD"?
[QUOTE="hiphops_savior"][QUOTE="locopatho"] Not when it's the same developer. A dev renaming their series from Everblue to Forever Blue for legal reasonsm isn't a new IP, sorry :(
locopatho
Under your logic, GRID isn't a new IP because it's DIRT on roads. Uncharted is a rehash of Tomb Raider mixed with Gears of War, Torchlight is a Diablo clone, and Killzone is a Halo clone. Those are different series. Forever Blue and Everblue are literally the exact same thing with a tiny name change for legal reasons. Would you call Modern Warfare a new IP if it dropped the "COD"?It was going to be a new IP until Activision decided to add Call of Duty to the title.
It was just going to be called Modern Warfare or something else. Before Modern Warfare Call of Duty was synonymous with WWII.
[QUOTE="locopatho"][QUOTE="hiphops_savior"] Under your logic, GRID isn't a new IP because it's DIRT on roads. Uncharted is a rehash of Tomb Raider mixed with Gears of War, Torchlight is a Diablo clone, and Killzone is a Halo clone.Nintendo_Ownes7
Those are different series. Forever Blue and Everblue are literally the exact same thing with a tiny name change for legal reasons. Would you call Modern Warfare a new IP if it dropped the "COD"?It was going to be a new IP until Activision decided to add Call of Duty to the title.
It was just going to be called Modern Warfare or something else. Before Modern Warfare Call of Duty was synonymous with WWII.
Modern Warfare 2 almost dropped the "COD" part as well.
Log in to comment