List your top 5 most overrated games this gen

By critics? GTA IV MGS4 COD4 GeOW Oblivion Fallout 3 Halo 3 Far Cry 2 UT3 Bioshock Perfect Dark Zero Off the top of my head.skrat_01

Your hard to please.

[QUOTE="mitu123"]

Uncharted 1

Resistance 2

Wario Ware: Smooth Moves

Soul Calibur IV

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess

gmc2u_64

[QUOTE="skrat_01"]By critics? GTA IV MGS4 COD4 GeOW Oblivion Fallout 3 Halo 3 Far Cry 2 UT3 Bioshock Perfect Dark Zero Off the top of my head.kunal1092000

Your hard to please.

Oh don't get me wrong I likedall of those games, they are good.

I just think critics were too kind on the faults.

Killzone 2 Prince of Persia Mass Effect Resistance 2 BioshockC-Lee

All of those games were amazing!!!

Except for Prince of Persia. That game itself rewrote the book on how easy a videogame can get.

• Gears 2
• Gears 1
• MGS4
• CoD4 (the MP)
• Resident evil 5 (a copy past job of RE4 gets a 9 on GS :? )

[QUOTE="gmc2u_64"]

[QUOTE="mitu123"]

Uncharted 1

Resistance 2

Wario Ware: Smooth Moves

Soul Calibur IV

The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess

mitu123

• Gears 2
• Gears 1
• MGS4
• CoD4 (the MP)
• Resident evil 5 (a copy past job of RE4 gets a 9 on GS :? )

Wii_Gamer_277

[QUOTE="Wii_Gamer_277"]

• Gears 2
• Gears 1
• MGS4
• CoD4 (the MP)
• Resident evil 5 (a copy past job of RE4 gets a 9 on GS :? )

C-Lee

1. Assassins Creed

2. Metal Gear Solid 4

3. Prince of Persia

4. Killzone 2

5.Final Fantasy V (first and last of final fantasy game I ever played, it is terrible)

[QUOTE="mitu123"]

[QUOTE="gmc2u_64"] I'm surprised that you didn't mention Perfect Dark Zero given' how much you love Perfect Dark.

Wii_Gamer_277

I spent a lot of time on both so I know how good they are.

[QUOTE="Wii_Gamer_277"][QUOTE="mitu123"] It gets bashed way too much by fans and even newcomers, despite being AAAE here.

mitu123

I spent a lot of time on both so I know how good they are.

1. Grand Theft Auto IV.
2. Metal Gear Solid 4.
3. Perfect Dark Zero.
4. Halo 3.
5. Infamous.

I only got 2 that still lingers in my mind:

1. Banjo-Kazooie Nuts & bolts (Solid 7.5-8.0, but NO WAY does it deserve a 5/5 AND Xbox 360 GOTY 2008 (*Cough*Giant Bomb*Cough*).

2. Super Paper Mario (Loved Paper Mario & TTYD, but the drastic changes EASILY make this the worst of the series).

Huh, notice a common theme these two Games share?

gmc2u_64

excuse me sir but IM the local Bnajo fanboy and I say *looks at username*

oh its you, fine your allowed to not like it lol you actually had a good argument against it :P

Just how is L4D overrated, considering all the hate it got?

My list:

-MGS4

-Mass Effect

-COD4

-Dragon Age

-Halo 3

Uncharted 2

Gta IV

Halo 3: Odst

MGS4

Assassin's Creed

On GS only, and in no particular order:

- Perfect Dark Zero

- Warioware Smooth Moves

- GRAW 2

- LittleBigPlanet

- Gears of War 2

1)Uncharted 2.The most overrated game of the year.It is worth only 7~8 out of 10.Uncharted 1 is better.

2)Killzone 2.....boring.Worth a 7 out of 10.Halo is a lot better.

3)Infamous.Worth a 7 out of 10.Prototype is better.

4)Little Big Planet.......very silly game.Worth a 7 out of 10.Kameo is a lot better.

5)Resistance.......this game look very ugly.Worth only 6 out of 10.

Why is everybody saying inFAMOUS? Its never discussed here

GTA IV + Expansions
Oblivion
MGS4
Resistance FOM
Infamous

1)Uncharted 2.The most overrated game of the year.It is worth only 7~8 out of 10.Uncharted 1 is better.

2)Killzone 2.....boring.Worth a 7 out of 10.Halo is a lot better.

3)Infamous.Worth a 7 out of 10.Prototype is better.

4)Little Big Planet.......very silly game.Worth a 7 out of 10.Kameo is a lot better.

5)Resistance.......this game look very ugly.Worth only 6 out of 10.

[QUOTE="Panosola"]

1)Uncharted 2.The most overrated game of the year.It is worth only 7~8 out of 10.Uncharted 1 is better.

2)Killzone 2.....boring.Worth a 7 out of 10.Halo is a lot better.

3)Infamous.Worth a 7 out of 10.Prototype is better.

4)Little Big Planet.......very silly game.Worth a 7 out of 10.Kameo is a lot better.

5)Resistance.......this game look very ugly.Worth only 6 out of 10.

mhsdrake

Its not taste. Its just more of he doesint like the PS3 much so he takes any opportunity to bring it down.

[QUOTE="gmc2u_64"]

I only got 2 that still lingers in my mind:

1. Banjo-Kazooie Nuts & bolts (Solid 7.5-8.0, but NO WAY does it deserve a 5/5 AND Xbox 360 GOTY 2008 (*Cough*Giant Bomb*Cough*).

2. Super Paper Mario (Loved Paper Mario & TTYD, but the drastic changes EASILY make this the worst of the series).

Huh, notice a common theme these two Games share?

dragonfly110

excuse me sir but IM the local Bnajo fanboy and I say *looks at username*

oh its you, fine your allowed to not like it lol you actually had a good argument against it :P

1. Halo ODST
2. Grand Theft Auto IV
3. Gears of War
4. Crysis
5. Assassin's Creed

Most of these games are relatively great but I felt it score higher than it should have.