mario galaxy 2 > starcraft 2

GS score wise , PC was really close to a AAAAE this time

scorewise yes... both are great games, however personally i find SC2>>>>>>>>>SMG2 by a lot :)

Yup...let's compare a Platformer/Adventure game with an RTS.

Yup...let's compare a Platformer/Adventure game with an RTS.

Kandlegoat

If Starcraft 2 was on the Wii it would have got a 20.wooooode

Not after being dumbed down for the port, of course >_>

If Starcraft 2 was on the Wii it would have got a 20.wooooode

It'd be higher than that. :P

[QUOTE="Kandlegoat"]

Yup...let's compare a Platformer/Adventure game with an RTS.

AmnesiaHaze

yeah and?...still lame.

Haha, now hermits know how cows and lems feel :P

SMG2 best game this gen!!!1

Can't really compare a RTS with a platformer. With that said, the only RTS series I enjoy are the Age games, so I'd probably rank SMG2 over Starcraft 2 anyway.

I know I'd certainly prefer to play Mario Galaxy 2 than Starcraft 2...but I don't see the point in comparing the two.Planeforger

its not that easy to compare the two...soo idk

GS score wise , PC was really close to a AAAAE this time

AmnesiaHaze

[QUOTE="AmnesiaHaze"]

GS score wise , PC was really close to a AAAAE this time

AzatiS

Why are you comparing a platformer to an RTS?IppoTenma

[QUOTE="AzatiS"][QUOTE="AmnesiaHaze"]

GS score wise , PC was really close to a AAAAE this time

oldkingallant

GS aren't biased but they do review games based not only on the standards of the specific platform but also on the genre. Both are fantastic but I have to agree with AzatiS, the content and quality that SC2 offers is astounding in regards to both SP and MP.

[QUOTE="IppoTenma"]Why are you comparing a platformer to an RTS?AmnesiaHaze

GS score wise , PC was really close to a AAAAE this time

AmnesiaHaze

Ugh, I hate these discussions. Yes, Super Mario Galaxy 2 is one of the greatest games of all time, and the best in its genre. SCII probably is the best or one of the best in its genre too, but I don't play RTS all that much.

Can't we just accept that both games are great in their own right?

[QUOTE="AmnesiaHaze"][QUOTE="IppoTenma"]Why are you comparing a platformer to an RTS?infamousxii

GS score wise , PC was really close to a AAAAE this time

I haven't played either but due to standards its obvious that SC2 on wii would have got 10 (in lack of higher scores) and SMG2 on PC would have probably been 9.0gamebreakerz__

I don't know about that, there's not many 3D platformers on PC so a game as well designed as SMG2 could easily get a 10 against non-existent standards.

I haven't played either but due to standards its obvious that SC2 on wii would have got 10 (in lack of higher scores) and SMG2 on PC would have probably been 9.0gamebreakerz__

[QUOTE="infamousxii"][QUOTE="AmnesiaHaze"] im not really comparing the games , the topic title just refers to the scores , the point is more that pc almost got a AAAAE this time , almostAmnesiaHaze

"insert funny face palm pic"

Also you should take into fact that SC2 will be played on a competive level for years to come shelling out millions in prize money and items. infamousxii

GS scores are opinions aswell. Mass Effect 2 is my favourite game this year and was outscored by many games here.

GS score wise , PC was really close to a AAAAE this time

[QUOTE="AmnesiaHaze"][QUOTE="infamousxii"] I see your still on your crusade to prove console is better than PC because it doesnt have a 10. Anyways everyone but you unstands that PC will never get a 10, the pc is unlimted in it's ability so nothing will ever be perfect.infamousxii

Insertion completed. That'll be 10 internets please!

[QUOTE="AmnesiaHaze"][QUOTE="tommyas"] So its a better game according to one review (one opinion)? Nice logic. Oh wait thats SW logic...tommyas

"insert funny face palm pic"

infamousxii

Why are you comparing two games from two different genres?

Yes. If cames like Stalker played on console like they do on a high end PC they would recieve a 10.infamousxii

[QUOTE="infamousxii"] "insert funny face palm pic"

AmnesiaHaze

[QUOTE="infamousxii"] "insert funny face palm pic"

[QUOTE="infamousxii"]Yes. If cames like Stalker played on console like they do on a high end PC they would recieve a 10.oldkingallant

[QUOTE="infamousxii"] "insert funny face palm pic"

scorewise yes... both are great games, however personally i find SC2>>>>>>>>>SMG2 by a lot :)

Malta_1980

[QUOTE="infamousxii"] "insert funny face palm pic"

[QUOTE="gamebreakerz__"]I haven't played either but due to standards its obvious that SC2 on wii would have got 10 (in lack of higher scores) and SMG2 on PC would have probably been 9.0oldkingallant

If Starcraft 2 was on the Wii it would have got a 20.wooooode